3 ms·
I saw Schneier debate Jonathan Zittrain and Mike McConnell on the topic of cyberwar. He was authoritative, calm, and pragmatic as he described the security and
by snowwrestler 14y ago
I saw Schneier debate Jonathan Zittrain and Mike McConnell on the topic of cyberwar. He was authoritative, calm, and pragmatic as he described the security and recovery systems of the Internet, and why it's unlikely that terrorists (for example) could take the whole thing down or permanently damage our banks with cyber attacks.
But as he strays more toward topics of motivation, power, and influence in his personal writing, I feel like he is getting more alarmist and shrill. It's not enough to talk about the mechanics of Internet security; now he wants to assign motivations and discuss the secret agendas of the poweful. I just feel like he is on shakier ground with respect to his technical expertise or personal experience. He's a great writer, but I'm not convinced I should privilege his vision of the future over anyone else's.
- tptacek 14y agoI agree that he's an unusually good writer, particularly of technical content. In that sense it is not really fair to compare him to Raymond.