5 ms·
Gold is a piss poor investment. Owning Real Estate (and making money off of it) entails taking care of it. People taking care of their land (so that it can app
by dragontamer 14y ago
Gold is a piss poor investment.
Owning Real Estate (and making money off of it) entails taking care of it. People taking care of their land (so that it can appreciate in value) is a good thing. The typical Real Estate "investor" adds a ton of value to their home, not just through maintenance, but also additions (ie: a new deck).
This maintenance is true value added to the economy. True value that wouldn't have been added if the investor just left his cash in something else.
No one wants to buy a 30-year old home that had no maintenance on it. Unless you're a fan of buying homes with leaky roofs and a flooded basement...
- aneth4 14y ago> Gold is a piss poor investment. Relative to what? The USD? http://pricedingold.com/us-dollar/ http://pricedingold.com/us-dollar/ Real estate? http://pragcap.com/real-estate-gold-ratio-falls-to-30-year-low http://pragcap.com/real-estate-gold-ratio-falls-to-30-year-l... Gold is an asset that holds its purchasing power pretty well. It is what it is. It is not however a "piss poor" investment.
- dragontamer 14y agoUSD is a worse investment, and it seems like Real Estate is not much better than Gold :-p Stocks as investment: http://www.macrotrends.org/1378/dow-to-gold-ratio-100-year-historical-chart http://www.macrotrends.org/1378/dow-to-gold-ratio-100-year-h... And of course, ycombinator. You know... the angel fund / venture capitalist firm that runs this website? We're all here because of investors investing into technology. They do so because they believe they can ultimately make money with technology investments. At least, more so than Gold, Real Estate, or even Stocks.
- lclarkmichalek 14y agoYou know, comparing a commodity against a currency isn't very sensible. I don't know many (sensible) people who say "I'm just going to keep a load of dollar bills under my bed" when it comes to investing (which is what your first link compares to gold).
- aneth4 14y agoThere is really little difference between a commodity and a currency other than how the supply is constrained. It is perfectly sensible to compare them.
- phaus 14y agoThe price of gold is so ridiculously inflated right now that it's insane to invest in it. For people back in 2000, it was a great idea, but now the price is high. The most basic rule of investing is buy low, sell high. It sounds like a stupid catch phrase, but even people like Warren Buffet have said that it's true. You might be able to make a little bit of money, but unless the global economy collapses entirely, I doubt we'll see another major increase. Gold actually has gone down in value before, so it could easily happen again again.
- dragontamer 14y agoI just noticed something: your links are "lying with statistics". Everyone knows that if you want to "prove" that Gold is a good investment, just start your graphs at 1970s. After all, Gold reached a glorious bubble of inflation-adjusted $2200+ / ounce in 1970s, and has fallen since then. (yes, even with today's inflated prices, Gold is no where near its inflation-adjusted high). Lets take a more reasonable graph of Gold, ehh? Something longer term... and see what happens to your trend. http://www.macrotrends.org/1437/gold-to-s-p-500-ratio http://www.macrotrends.org/1437/gold-to-s-p-500-ratio Gold's trend is downward compared to the majority of the market. Each valley is lower, and each peak is lower than the last (with exception of stagflation period in the 70s)
- aneth4 14y agoI am saying gold is better than commodities. I'm saying gold is not a "piss poor" investment, as it holds its buying power quite well. That is the function of a conservative investment.
- dragontamer 14y agoThe S&P 500 (which you can easily buy with Vanguard Mutual Funds or SPY ETFs) has approximately the same volatility index as Gold right now. http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^VIX http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^VIX http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^GVZ http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^GVZ VIX for the S&P 500 is 13.58, while Gold VIX is 13.13. Stocks are both holding their buying power as well as Gold, and still offering better returns right now. Gold's "stability" is a myth. It is no more stable than any other investment. Bonds offer a conservative, stable investment platform. Gold does not.
- Thrymr 14y agoGold is a commodity.
- tatsuke95 14y agoWhy would you compare gold to one mediocre and one bad investment? It seems that few people here understand opportunity costs.
- bitcartel 14y ago> Gold is a piss poor investment. Do you know something that the Chinese, Germans and Russians don't ? "Central Banks Bought Most Gold in Nearly 50 Years" http://www.cnbc.com/id/100458951 http://www.cnbc.com/id/100458951 "The Russian central bank will continue to buy gold as it seeks to diversify its foreign reserves away from paper assets it views as risky" http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/24/russia-cbank-idUSL6N0AT41J20130124 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/24/russia-cbank-idUSL... "The startling news that Germany is repatriating its gold reserves from the United States and France has got precious metals speculators worried that this is the first major sign that trust between central banks across the globe could be deteriorating." http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlenzner/2013/01/19/the-germans-want-their-gold-reserves-back-in-germany/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlenzner/2013/01/19/the-ger... "How Much Gold Does China Really Have?... China is the world’s leading gold producer and also the world’s leading gold importer. And surprisingly their official gold holdings haven’t risen an ounce in over three years." http://www.moneymorning.com.au/20130211/how-much-gold-does-china-really-have.html http://www.moneymorning.com.au/20130211/how-much-gold-does-c...
- dragontamer 14y agoDid you read your articles? Germans are bringing gold back into their own country, as opposed to holding it in other exchanges. They have neither increased nor decreased their supply. China and India are world-class consumers of gold for jewelry, as expected of the world's most populous countries with a rising middle class. Gold is also used in microelectronic components. Chinese Banks on the other hand, have not increased their holdings according to your link. IE: China is not investing into Gold. They're using it. As for Russian and Iraqi Central Banks buying up Gold between 2012 and today... well... they've already lost 10% on their investment as Gold has dropped in value between last year and today. I mean, if you wanna follow the example of Russian and Iraqi banks, you're welcome to do so. But I don't think anyone considers them a paragon of the investing world.
- bitcartel 14y agoEr, yes, I can read: Why are Germany repatriating their gold? Why do they want it in their own hands? Why go through all that trouble instead of just selling? Why would they want to keep holding onto a "piss poor investment"? Regarding China, the article's author believes that China has been accumulating gold. The last known official figure is from 2009 and since then imports continue to rise, which in the authors opinion, have been destined for the Central Bank. As for Russia, they have been accumulating gold for a few years now, and it's right there in the article. "It owned 400 tonnes of gold at end of 2006... At the end of last year, the central bank held nearly 950 tonnes of gold". If you want to dismiss gold as a "piss poor investment" that's fine, but not everyone shares your view or your investment objectives.
- Evbn 14y agoYou are severely miscategorizing real estate. Look at what happened in the 2000s bubble. Property was flipping with no value adds, and even with added wear and tear. Buying desert property today and selling it for profit in 10 years when the city next door expands-- that is not wealth creation.
- eru 14y agoActually, it is. Speculators help in price discovery, and that is a real service.
- brc 14y ago>Gold is a piss poor investment This is a foolish statement no matter what the subject: >dotcom stocks are a piss-poor investment >railroads area piss-poor investment >Apple is a piss-poor investment All of these are true and false at some point. You can't make blanket statements like that. There are times when Gold as a store of value makes more sense than a central-bank inflated currency. There are times when the opposite is true. What is certainly true is that Gold is a very good long-term store of value, and the prices of Gold relative to other things, such as a loaf of bread, a barrel of oil, a parcel of land are quite stable over a long period of time. People often make the mistake of comparing Gold against fiat currencies and decide that Gold may be going up or down in value. What they don't do is look at Gold vs other things, which typically are rising in price just as fast as Gold. Certainly one thing is for certain, putting your savings into a fiat currency is a very bad long term plan.
- EGreg 14y agoGold is a good investment to mitigate against "tail risk" -- and so is BitCoin (although now because it is growing, it's good for taking an extreme log position is / hoarding). So you'll see it spike in value right before panics, and slowly lose value after things stabilize. Of course, gold or any commodity is a worse investment than a stock market index over time.
- dragontamer 14y ago"What is certainly true is that Gold is a very good long-term store of value, and the prices of Gold relative to other things, such as a loaf of bread, a barrel of oil, a parcel of land are quite stable over a long period of time." Wanna take a bet on that? http://www.macrotrends.org/1340/gold-vs-the-cpi-historical-chart http://www.macrotrends.org/1340/gold-vs-the-cpi-historical-c... Gold is out there, sometimes swinging by 1,700% over a decade... while the CPI doesn't change any more than ~100% / decade. Dollars (and investments measured in dollars: ie Inflation-protected Bonds like TIPS) retain their value better than Gold, while providing a more stable platform. A 10-year note at even 2% offers you 21% growth over 10 years... much better than the long "valleys" that Gold investments suffered across the last century. (And with historic rates sometimes hitting 14.56%, it was possible for 10-year notes to hit 370% growth over 10 years). Gold doesn't grow in value in the long term. And as shown in Gold Volatility Index, Gold is also a very unstable investment historically. In fact, Gold's volatility today is the same as the S&P 500 Index. http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^VIX http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^VIX http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^GVZ http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=^GVZ So it is just as volatile as stocks... while offering poor gains historically. Neither the conservative nor aggressive investor would want this kind of investment. That makes gold a "piss poor" investment in my books.