3 ms·
One problem is the definition of a MOOC. What is it? (not the acronym, we all know that, I'm talking about the meaning). 1) Is it training? Competing with b
by VLM 14y ago
One problem is the definition of a MOOC. What is it? (not the acronym, we all know that, I'm talking about the meaning).
1) Is it training? Competing with brick and mortar vo-techs and stackexchange and frankly just plain ole google?
2) Is it education? Competing with textbooks (paper and ebook) and brick and mortar college/univ and projecteuler and zillions of something-koan projects?
3) Is it socialization which is why everything gets deleted after it "ends"? Competing with a zillion internet social-type sites and facebook and G+ groups and even this site?
4) Is it presentation and puttin on an interesting show? Competing with MIT OCW videos and Kahn Academy?
5) Is it just signalling and raising awareness and showing off your hip-ness? Competing with the big social media sites, awareness ribbons (I want to buy a Chinese made $5 colored magnetic ribbon sticker to attach to my car to "raise awareness" of functional programming, either that or a colored bracelet, can anyone on HN help?)
6) Is it just a fad? Competing with "fill in the blank of memes".
For most existing products its possible to improve almost all areas, but if one product is optimizing area "X" above its possible someone reviewing with a focus on area "Y" is not going to be very happy. So you need to meta-mod review the reviewers or have some manner of tagging or something to indicate (the reviewers opinion of) whats good.
Above I was not trying to express an opinion, just trying to list the problem space, but I'll try an opinion based on some experience. If you want to optimize for #2 above in basic college math (calc, linear alg, etc) I claim you can't do better than MIT OCW's videos of Strang's classes (probably downloaded from archive.org?). But if you're trying to optimize for #4 above, then those videos are barely passable on a technical level (like if you can't read the blackboard at an overcompressed video level, why even release at that compression level? And some of the sound/mic needs work although its usable) and if you're trying to optimize for #3 above they're truly an epic fail not even really trying.
Another opinion, if you want to optimize for #4 it would be hard to beat most TED talks. Obviously done by pro-level video and audio crew on a good (from a technical standpoint) set.