3 ms·
I obviously want one of these :) The place where this kind of thing would be most useful is integrated into a CROWS mount -- a fully automated turret which can
by rdl 14y ago
I obviously want one of these :)
The place where this kind of thing would be most useful is integrated into a CROWS mount -- a fully automated turret which can be put on top of a vehicle, in static emplacements, etc. Being able to make single, aimed, highly accurate shots on vehicles approaching a checkpoint from a .50bmg mounted on an unattended vehicle up forward would be really nice, since you could then not put any of your own forces at risk, while taking single shots to the engine (to disable the vehicle) vs. unloading on the vehicle with multiple bursts (which would be highly likely to kill the occupants, who may not be "bad guys").
Deskilling the precision marksman job isn't as important -- a real sniper needs huge amounts of other training beyond precision shooting, so the shooting training isn't the biggest barrier there, and the level of skill required for ordinary police 100-200m designated marksman isn't really much for the shooting, so much as for shoot/no shoot, various intermediate/barrier materials, etc.
The only way to do police levels of accuracy at 1000m would be with some kind of actively guided round; they generally won't accept a shot a military sniper would consider acceptable, as it's usually for hostage rescue situations. A military sniper is probably ok with taking a shot where if he misses, another enemy beside the one he's trying to kill gets killed instead, most of the time, as long as his odds of hitting the target are high enough. So those shots can be in the 600-1500m range. I've never heard of police shots beyond 300m. They're usually 50-150m but often with glass or other barrier material between them and the target.
- bmelton 14y agoCompletely agreed. Also worth noting is that a 338 lapua wouldn't get you much mileage in a military sniper situation, which is why God invented the Barrett M82 and its ilk. I haven't ever seen anything resembling it in the hands of SWAT or urban-area police, which is probably for the better for exactly the reasons you mentioned.
- rdl 14y agoThe NYPD just tried to buy a Serbu .50bmg rifle (a half-price M82), and got denied (because of NYS gun laws, Serbu refused to sell, and lulz were had by all.) I personally do not want NYPD to have .50bmg except maybe harbor police for interdicting boats. Once they have stuff like that, they'll want to use it, and their record for use of firearms isn't particularly stellar. I've seen plenty of .338 Lapua used in military anti-personnel applications, but by far the #1 is still .308 (168gr SMK type). .338 with 300gr VLD is essentially the same for range and enough ft-lbs to wound humans vs. .50bmg; it's just inferior for anti-materiel. The M82 is just way too big for anyone to carry. OTOH, the whole "stalk for a week to take a single shot at the enemy" kind of never happens anymore, either -- if they're stalking like that, it's an air force FACP or CCT who is going to just use a laser and call in much more firepower without compromising his position. Most military sniping I saw involved being within friendly lines, or driving to/from in a low-profile or hmmwv and setting up in a building. In early 2003-2005 I guess there were "go out with a motorized patrol, drop off along their route, do it all night, and then get picked up the next evening", but I obviously never observed this. So "too big to carry" isn't a real showstopper.
- bmelton 14y agoI wasn't aware the Serbu was on the police loophole list[1], but I'm glad that they are. I agree that I don't generally want metro-level police agencies having anti-materiel rounds in their arsenal, especially in places like California and New York. Still though, I'm building a 50 cal AR, so I don't see any reason they wouldn't be able to if they were so inclined, and Alexander Arms (makers of the .50 beowulf upper) have not declared for or against SAFE-act like legislation (probably because they haven't had to choose yet). [1] - http://www.thepoliceloophole.com/ http://www.thepoliceloophole.com/
- rdl 14y agoAgreed, but I'd support police having big/slow/heavy .30 or .50 AR-type weapons for SWAT teams much more than .50bmg, though.
- eigenvector 14y agoAgree that .338LM is similar in all aspects to .50BMG as far as lethality. You're talking about a round that has TWICE as much energy @ 1,500 yards as the widely used (by police) 124gr 9x19mm handgun load would have at the muzzle. Almost the same velocity and more than twice the mass.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoHuh? The .338 Lapua is a heavily used military sniper caliber the last I checked. It's used by Navy SEALs, the Brits, the Dutch, and many other countries. It is the round that was used to achieve the current record of longest confirmed sniper kill in combat (by a British Army sniper in Afghanistan).
- sliverstorm 14y agoAlso important, the police sharpshooters don't train as much as the military ones do, right? (I'm sure police snipers are no slouches)
- rdl 14y agoGenerally police sharpshooters don't train as much at sharpshooting as military do, but they're also fully trained police officers (in every case I'm aware of), so they know more than military snipers about chain of custody for evidence, general policing, etc. (and, less about final protective lines, indirect fires, etc., which military/infantry would need) In a lot of departments, it's an extra duty -- it's a regular police officer who happens to ALSO be the department sniper. SWAT is also an extra duty (and snipers are usually SWAT). In some of the bigger departments SWAT becomes a primary duty, and sniper is probably a relatively dedicated role within the team. It's crazy that DHS grants allow random minimal-threat small town, rural, or even medium sized town police departments to purchase essentially military capabilities for their SWAT teams, though. Armored cars, ~infinite weapons of every kind, endless training, etc. Because then they end up using SWAT to bust a person who was seen growing suspicious plants in his garage by an informant, which turns out to be a grandmother gardening to keep her prize tomato plants healthy in the winter. Or, a security expert who gets "SWATted" by Russian spammers after he exposes them.
- eigenvector 14y agoA sharpshooter is not a sniper. Sharpshooting is one skill that a sniper must possess, however, police typically require the former whereas the military requires the later. Sniper training involves a great deal of field craft in covert operations beyond mere marksmanship.
- steve19 14y agoI evaluate military technology and I have shot the rifle myself. I think the rifle has a lot of potential, but I see this rifle as more of a technology demo than the future of marksmanship. I was easily able to put rounds into a man sized target at long range despite less-than-ideal shooting conditions with a lot less concentration and effort than I would normally need. I think this would make an excellent police marksman tool. It lowers the skill needed for a police sharpshooter to do his job without injuring anyone. I don't see it being used by military snipers. It is big and heavy. It requires active ranging (two separate range finders) lighting up the location of the rifle for anyone with NVG (and the onboard electronics probably have a terrible heat signature). The "closed loop" (their words) of the system means that it requires everything, including ammunition, to come from the company who makes the rifle. Change one thing and the accuracy might be terrible. It is complex: you can diagnose and fix many problems with a normal rifle in the field. You can carry a spare optic in case your primary optic breaks. Expect to see this technology integrated into fighting vehicles and static emplacements (like the parent suggested).
- rdl 14y agoI don't think it would be too hard to have a "training mode" for something like this, where you bring it some new ammunition on a measured range, fire, and calibrate. In the police/military world, they generally only fire a couple types of ammunition anyway. (I wanted to do a company making custom suppressors tuned for your own specific rifle, load, etc., but it turns out almost all of the people buying suppressors and shooting a lot of rounds suppressed are using an issued rifle and ammunition, not developing custom loads.)
- shpxnvz 14y ago> ...means that it requires everything, including ammunition, to come from the company who makes the rifle. This is baffling... what on earth makes the ammunition proprietary? Does the chamber or priming system deviate from the SAAMI/CIP specifications for those cartridges?
- tcpekin 14y agoFrom the article, > "The problem with hand loading is that you just have inconsistent results. Some people do it very good, and some don't. What I really want to avoid is the situation where someone says, 'Look, your gun doesn't work. I'm missing, and it's your fault.' And the real issue is, well, you're missing because you screwed up the ammunition—you have it loaded too hot and it's firing too high. But you're never going to believe me!" He laughed. "I'm really not trying to make a ton of money on ammo, but I want to control the outcome and I want people to have a good experience." I don't think it is proprietary, rather than just very repeatable. Using the company made ammunition, they can (hopefully) ensure that every bullet has the same characteristics, so it can leave the barrel at the same velocity. From the quote above, I doubt the software can compensate for different grain bullets or different amounts of powder. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handloading#Accuracy_considerations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handloading#Accuracy_considerat...