5 ms·
Both of the cartridges mentioned in the article are going to be quite loud; combined with the relatively low rate of fire, it would be fairly tractable to track
by aidenn0 14y ago
Both of the cartridges mentioned in the article are going to be quite loud; combined with the relatively low rate of fire, it would be fairly tractable to track someone down who is firing multiple shots. Someone setting up, firing a single shot and then waiting a week could be a bit more difficult, but then there are many more opportunities for them to get seen lugging around an 18lb rifle.
- rdl 14y agoIf you suppress a .338 Lapua or other serious, loud, supersonic rifle, you can usually get a fair number of shots off before humans can figure out your direction/range. It's still really loud, but makes localization much harder. I'm not sure how it affects shotspotter/boomerang, though. (Now that WA allows suppressor use, I'm totally getting a 20" bbl folding stock TRG-42 .338 Lapua and can once I move up there).
- daenz 14y agoDoesn't suppressing significantly lower the velocity of the round? Won't that affect the ability to hit the target and as well as the damage done?
- rdl 14y agoI don't have the table in front of me, but you give up 10-20% (mainly from going to a 20" from a 27"). It reduces range, but using e.g. 300gr Lapua Scenar, it retains plenty of terminal energy and is above 1400fps for >1200m (vs. 1600m otherwise). I've never had access to a range beyond 1000 yards, anyway.
- phreanix 14y agoHaving been (accidentally) downrange of a suppressed AR (556), I'd say I localized the direction of fire within a few seconds. Granted I knew the terrain and probably had an idea where shooters would be set up, so that probably helped. I've worked with suppressed PCP's a lot (legal where I was), and it does affect shot dynamics. I'm guessing one could hack this monster scope to reflect that. I just don't really see anyone, good intentioned or not, going through all that trouble.
- bmelton 14y agoWhile I think that the notion of banning something on the potential for misuse is absurd, it is possible to suppress the shot-noise as well as suppress the muzzle flash somewhat to make it harder to locate. It's still not going to be foolproof, especially as the range of a 338 lapua is going to put you in relative sight distance, vs a more traditional sniper rifle which has an effective range of a mile, mile and a half. Also it's worth noting that the DC sniper used a very pedestrian AR15 for his sniping, and just hid himself in a trunk to keep things hidden, which would work well for pretty much any kind of gun (except if anybody was very near it and saw the muzzle blast).
- laurencerowe 14y agoIn Britain, we banned hand guns because people used them to shoot other people. Gun deaths went down.
- bmelton 14y agoBut even though they may have gone down, they haven't been eliminated. It's also worth noting that at least for the data I've seen, since the gun ban, assault crime has gone up, and as a result I am apparently 5 times more likely to be raped, beaten or mugged in the UK than I am in the United States. I can't make any claims or assertions to your murder rates as you guys don't count a murder as a murder until and unless a conviction is made (and I can't speak to the effectiveness of your justice system with any degree of knowledge), but on the whole, Britain isn't objectively better because of the gun ban. I'm also not saying that it is objectively worse, as it is a very hard issue to quantify on the whole, but one of the things that makes the United States special (at least at its formation) is that it specifically allows for an armed civilian population to keep its government honest. I don't know of (probably due to ignorance, because I haven't looked for) another country that has done the same.
- vacri 14y agois that it specifically allows for an armed civilian population to keep its government honest. This is a canard - where have all the second amendment activists been for this century so far? They don't seem to be doing a very good job of it, and don't seem particularly interested in protecting any amendment other than the second. Times have changed, and it's time to move on from the fantasy that 'guns in the hands of civilians keeps the US government honest'. I'm also not saying that it is objectively worse, as it is a very hard issue to quantify on the whole It's not a hard issue to quantify at all. The UK doesn't have a gun-carrying culture. A gun ban there doesn't really affect much in either direction; rises in crime are due to other things. It's not like criminals are out there mugging people because 'now we know they can't carry guns'. They never did. We went through the same thing here in Australia when we brought in greater restrictions in the wake of the Port Arthur massacre. Despite ridicule and predictions of impending Wild West-ness by the US pro-gun lobby, life went on as usual - because we never really strongly identified with guns, and don't carry them around much. Crime went down, but again, not because of the gun ban - because we entered an economic boom, and when the public is in boom times, crime drops because people are more contented. Finally, you have to be very careful when you compare non-murder violent crime between nations because of vastly different reporting defintions. The FBI doesn't even bother reporting regular assaults, it's aggravated assaults only. Whereas in Australia (and I believe the UK as well), you get a few charges for a fistfight, which inflates the stats. The prosecutor will bring in a scaled series of charges, they all get counted in the stats, but the defendent is sentenced on the severest one only. In short, unless you're being careful to note the reporting differences, it's apples and oranges. Murders are easier because there's not much in the way of subjective wiggle-room.