3 ms·
...in our ADD culture. As someone who has personal interaction with the disorder (I'm not officially diagnosed, but probably have it, my son has it, several si
by btilly 14y ago
...in our ADD culture.
As someone who has personal interaction with the disorder (I'm not officially diagnosed, but probably have it, my son has it, several siblings, nieces and nephews as well), I hate this phrase. Because people use it to mean the exact opposite of what the actual disorder is.
People with ADD or ADHD (different names for pretty much the same thing) do not lack focus. To the contrary, a primary characteristic is extreme focus. Instead we lack the ability to focus on what we are told to focus on.
Society labels this "distractibility" because the person does not focus on what those around would want them to focus on (following instructions, getting dressed, doing homework, etc) but instead goes back to what interests them (bugs, dinosaurs, math, etc). But in terms of ability to get fascinated by something, then follow through on complex tasks, people with ADD or ADHD are significantly more capable than the general public.
- michaelochurch 14y agoInteresting. That sounds a lot like me. You make a really strong point. Going back and changing it.
- jcheng 14y agoThat's an interesting and appealing description, but sounds pretty different than what Wikipedia has to say about ADD. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_deficit_disorder#section_2 http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_deficit_disorder#se...
- btilly 14y agoIt sounds different, but I am simply giving more detail about what happens inside of the disorder. Any decent book written in the last decade will confirm my description. People with ADHD or ADD don't have executive control of what they will focus on. Inability to focus on what you're told to focus on is noticed in most environments as not listening to instructions, inability to stay on assigned task, poor attention to detail if you do stay on assigned task, etc. Everything in that link you posted is covered. In most environments your excellent focus on things you're NOT "supposed" to be doing is not likely to be noticed. Or if it is noticed, it likely increases frustration over the inability to pay attention to assigned tasks. Speaking personally, I was very confused when screening for ADHD was recommended for my son. He seemed to have excellent focus - at 3 he would often get involved in a detailed task for half an hour or more, at 5 he would sit quietly through a full length documentary, then demonstrate how much he had learned for days afterwards. It was not until my sister explained from her experience that this was, in fact, characteristic that I became less resistant to having him screened. I was also resistant to medicating him because I'd absorbed all of the usual biases about how overmedicating leads to drug abuse. However after being pointed to the statistics for ADHD, medication became a no-brainer. Children with ADHD do not become addicted to their medication, and have the same risks of drug abuse as the general population. By contrast ADHD people who are not treated are at massively increased risk for all kinds of drug abuse, including both prescription drug abuse and cocaine. (Cocaine is an interesting one since it actually is an effective ADHD medication! Though inconvenient, illegal, and subject to abuse.) Therefore popular wisdom is exactly backwards - appropriate medication for ADHD reduces the odds of drug abuse later in life.
- tripleggg 14y agoWhy medicate? So he can pay better attention in class? So he can pay better attention to the teachers who are mostly wasting his time and talents? Why not find alternative means of educating your son that suit his temperament. I believe our education system is harmful and hostile to boys in general and especially ones who have "ADD." There is Khan Academy and there is your boys curiosity and then there is your own creativity. Between those three things I am sure you can arrange an alternate (better!) way of facilitating your sons education. I know this may sound like a radical idea, but felt it my duty to submit it for your consideration. I myself did well in school, but was bored and demoralized. I would have been farther ahead in life if I could just explore on my own and educate myself on the "need or want to learn" basis. I.E. whenever I was fascinated with a subject or needed to know something to complete a project, I'd learn it. P.S. I can relate I think I have mild ADD as well. I just don't think it's a disorder or is harmful in life.
- jcmontalbano 14y ago"We lack the ability to focus on what we are told to focus on," or indeed in general I find that I lack the ability to control what I'm focusing on. So I reduce distractions and work in a black box. With only one task in front of you, you get it done.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThat's it exactly - I guess the noise abatement society is really the self medicated ADD society. I simply cannot work if I am not in a quiet environment.
- rtpg 14y agoI have been diagnosed with ADD, and I know I can't trigger that focus, even for things I want to do. I sometimes fall into extreme focus mode, but it's usually on "accident".