4 ms·
>E.g. if I pay someone $100 now for $100 worth of lawn care over the next five years, I make damn sure I can trust that person. If I pay the bank $100 for a CD
by anamax 18y ago
>E.g. if I pay someone $100 now for $100 worth of lawn care over the next five years, I make damn sure I can trust that person. If I pay the bank $100 for a CD maturing in five years, I don't.
> This gives all banks an incentive to take undue risk
Actually, you've just demonstrated that FDIC insurance gives you an incentive to take undue risk. You'll deposit your money at any bank without regard for whether said bank is trustworthy.
BTW - It's curious that you seem to believe that better rules will help since you also seem to believe that "clever people" can always get around the rules.
As to whether a govt-run bank would do any better, feel free to point to the fraction of govt enterprises which are run as well as you'd require of govt run banks. Which states' DMV is "good enough"? How about the post office?
- MaysonL 18y agoThe trouble is that the trust a bank or any such institution receives is not, and probably cannot be, well correlated to its trustworthiness. Cf. Bernard Madoff, and the vulnerability of any bank (especially when no insurance exists) to a run.
- dantheman 18y agoThe threat of a run is only available if you lend out demand deposits, which is something that could be eliminated.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI have no clue what you are talking about. I'm an anarcho-capitalist. I was talking about how the FDIC creates bad incentives. I don't think I said anything about how new regulations would help, since the bit you quote is about how the difference between good regulations and bad regulations is in what kind of talent is misallocated. Edit: Perhaps the part about being 'balanced by regulations' threw you off. What I meant is that the government writes rules to keep people from doing what the FDIC gives them an incentive to do. Those rules, of course, do not work.
- anamax 18y ago> I was talking about how the FDIC creates bad incentives. And I'm pointing out that the bad incentives affect depositor behavior. Thanks to FDIC, you have little incentive to find a trustworthy bank. Instead, you judge entirely on other criteria.
- ilkhd2 18y agoBank of North Dakota. A government run one..
- byrneseyeview 18y agoThere haven't been enough defaults in North Dakota for that to be a serious issue. Some places are able to have lots of state involvement without getting into lots of trouble, e.g. the Scandinavian socialist states, Singapore, etc. Most of the defaults were concentrated in the 'sand states' -- California, Florida, Arizona, and Nevada.
- anamax 18y ago> Bank of North Dakota. A government run one.. Majority-Scandanavian states seem capable of lots of things that other states can't manage. Since the majority of US states are not majority-Scandanavian, we can't use the majority-Scandanavian ones as a model.
- ilkhd2 18y agoWell, ND is a German majority state. I understand that it is tempting to say that it has something to deal with scandinavian personality, but look up a bit up north you'll see Canada, with very non-scandinavian in it's population makeup, however I'd think it is a lot like Northern Europe in its political and economical structure