2 ms·
Sure, there's an excuse. Or more correctly, a reason: network integrity. The question isn't what's technically possible. It's what's practically necessary to ke
by wpietri 14y ago
Sure, there's an excuse. Or more correctly, a reason: network integrity. The question isn't what's technically possible. It's what's practically necessary to keep parasitism to a minimum.
If Spamhaus blacklisted my ISP and had reasonable evidence that they were harboring spammers, I wouldn't yell at Spamhaus. I'd tell my ISP to kick out the spammers or I'd leave. This isn't a hypothetical for me: I moved a cabinet of gear out of an ISP precisely because they were dealing with the devil.
I can't remember now if Spamhaus was involved, but I was definitely grateful to find out that the ISP was harboring spammers. It was a clear sign that they were in financial difficulty and were being run by idiots. They were out of business less than a year later because of those financial difficulties, and because their good staff didn't want to work for assholes.
If you want to run a blacklist in a way that you think is better than Spamhaus, nobody's stopping you. If you are right, then presumably people will pick yours up and drop theirs. But my guess is that they'll retain their popularity, because people who actually have experience dealing with network abuse are pretty happy with their approach.