4 ms·
Perhaps but your conclusions are equally silly (and not based on logic). Voucher programs are very new and rare. Why would you expect them to function at the
by grandalf 18y ago
Perhaps but your conclusions are equally silly (and not based on logic).
Voucher programs are very new and rare. Why would you expect them to function at the same level as established (and well funded) public schools after a very short time.
For comparison, imagine if FedEx were allowed to deliver residential mail -- would you expect 100% coverage of every US address overnight? Of course not. The ramp-up will take time, and with voucher money entrepreneurs will invent better schools and existing schools will be able to ramp up due to network effects long enjoyed by the public monopoly.
Also, you are right that parochial schools enjoyed a bump in enrolment that they may not have deserved, but they benefit from having had (for a long time) other sources of funding, namely donations. Also, I think you exaggerate the "indoctrination" quite a bit. Are public school students not indoctrinated that FDR and Henry Kissinger were great men? I'm not sure why you have to draw the line and say that only indoctrination about the supernatural is distasteful!
- briansmith 18y agoCato's article claimed that this study showed that private schools were clearly better at educating students than private schools. My point about performance was to show that the study itself says that isn't the case, based on the executive summary of the study itself. How was that silly or illogical? My point regarding special ed and alternative schools is that these programs make averge-cost-per-student and average-performance-per-student metrics incomparable between public and private schools. The statements are derived directly from the study report. How is that silly or illogical? I didn't say that only indoctrination about the supernatural is distasteful. Indoctrination--religious or otherwise--is unethical. You bring up FDR and Henry Hissinger as examples of public school indoctrination, but there are many public schools (like mine) that presented those men in an objective manner. There is no doubt that some teachers in some public schools may engadge in some kinds of (often religious, nationalistic, or otherwise political) indoctrination. However, it is something that can be identified and corrected within the public school program without changing any fundamental aspect of the public education system. The only way to rid religious schools of the indoctrination--for which they were created and which is one of their main selling points--is to close them or transfer them from religious organizations to secular organizations (which is something I fully support).
- grandalf 18y agoCato meant better per dollar -- one can only imagine the outcome if the kids were able to keep the extra $20K per year of savings and apply it to future college tuition, room and board, travel around the world, etc. Your second point is somewhat true, but special ed represents a small enough portion of the overall population that it doesn't inflate the numbers too much. I'd argue that the public schools are by design indoctrination machines -- imagine if, say, the Taliban creates an official Taliban school, would you claim that it isn't intended to indoctrinate students in the ways of the Taliban? US Public schools are (with the exception of affluent suburban public schools) mostly just factories intended to crank out vocational workers while providing free daycare for the K-12 years so that the family can more easily sustain two breadwinners. Think about what is taught in public schools: Punctuality, obedience, spelling, phys-ed, basic math, basic reading comprehension, home-ec, government, state/local history, US history, etc. Huge emphasis is placed on sports and athleticism, and in the typical high school the "jocks" rule the halls, abusing and intimidating anyone they choose. The food served in most public schools is below the quality served in fast food restaurants, and many feature soda and candy machines in abundance. For all but the few who are extremely academically gifted, public school is little more than minimum security prison through the 12th grade, at which point most individuals either join the military or go to work at Wal-Mart.
- briansmith 18y agoBelow, another commenter said that special education consumed 25% of the public budget. I don't know where he got that statistic, but if it is true then clearly we can't consider it to be a "small portion" of anything. The Taliban is a religious organization that indoctrinates people similar to other religious organizations. What does it have to do with public schools? Are you suggesting that public schools are not secular enough and not objective enough? If so, I totally agree with you. But, it can be fixed. Religious schools are fundamentally broken as they have indoctrination of children at their core. You make a lot of unsubstantiated claims in the rest of your message. I don't even know how to respond to them. If you have a claim with some substance then maybe I can respond to it.