3 ms·
But he's not actually citing their actual rules, he's citing his interpretation of the rules, and claiming various court decisions support him. He's wrong on bo
by DannyBee 14y ago
But he's not actually citing their actual rules, he's citing his interpretation of the rules, and claiming various court decisions support him.
He's wrong on both points, AFAICT.
Now, he may not like that their is more wiggle room than he likes, but ...
As for what is reasonable to inquire about, they can ask about a lot. This is particularly true since it's probably not a custodial interrogation, and they are clearly not asking about evidence of crimes.
You can cite "the way the world should be" all you like. I actually agree it would be a great place to live. But expecting the judicial system to transform it into that world is a dream.
- hnolable 14y agoExplaining how he's wrong on both points would be very useful.
- DannyBee 14y agoSure 1. The TSA is legally entitled to deference of its interpretations of its own regulations. See Chevron (for statutes. Yes, they get deference to interpret the statutes congress passed that say what they are allowed to do), or Auer (for their interpretations of their own regulations). It's ridiculous (in the case of Auer deference), but true. However, at least right now, if the TSA says "our regulations mean X", courts give them deference that their regulations mean X, and it takes a lot to overcome that. There is at least some hope that Auer deference will die in the next few years. Humorously, one of the justices most people here seem to hate the most, Scalia, is now the strongest opponent of Auer deference: "For decades, and for no good reason, we have been giving agencies the authority to say what their rules mean, under the harmless-sounding banner of “defer[ring] to an agency’s interpretation of its own regulations." (and earlier) "The Court there gives effect to a reading of EPA’s regulations that is not the most natural one, simply because EPA says that it believes the unnatural reading is right. It does this, more- over, even though the agency has vividly illustrated that it can write a rule saying precisely what it means—by doing just that while these cases were being briefed. Enough is enough." (You can also look at his earlier Talk America concurrence on this subject. http://www.volokh.com/2011/06/09/justice-scalia-questions-auer-deference/ http://www.volokh.com/2011/06/09/justice-scalia-questions-au... is a good reference about it) 2. Davis, which he tried to quote, says mostly exactly the opposite of what he wants it to: "airport screenings are considered to be administrative searches because they are conducted as part of a general regulatory scheme, where the essential administrative purpose is to prevent the carrying of weapons or explosives aboard aircraft." Note, this seems innocuous at first to an outsider, but administrative searches are not subject to the same requirements as general 4th amendment searches. They only have to be reasonable, not have probable cause. In particular, later it gets you down the path to this: "To judge reasonableness, it is necessary to balance the right to be free of intrusion with “society’s interest in safe air travel.” [US v. Marquez, 410 F.3d 612]). In a fight between "society's interest in safe air travel" vs "justifying why you need a liter of juice", i know who i would bet on. Again, i think such legal rules are wrong-headed, but it doesn't change my view of the current legal state of the world. But back to US v. Davis: "[an administrative search is allowed if] no more intrusive or intensive than necessary, in light of current technology, to detect weapons or explosives, confined in good faith to that purpose, and passengers may avoid the search by electing not to fly." This is a zinger for two reasons: 1. Now, remember, the TSA, because they get deference, mostly gets to decide what is "more intensive or intrusive than necessary", and courts will defer to them, for the most part. 2. As long as they let you out by saying you won't fly, they pretty much get a free pass. So there you go. Sucks but true. PS The idea that searches performed by the TSA are automatically administrative, or even that there should be an administrative search exception, was also conjured up out of whole cloth by the courts, so expecting them to suddenly reverse course and apply "the full force" of the 4th amendment (god i wish i didn't have to use that phrase), is well, wrong headed. Barring the supreme court getting a grand urge to stake out a position here (which is rare), if it happens, it will happen when society is less accepting of this kind of thing, not when it is more.
- revelation 14y agoDid you read the link? If you think all of these things "suck", why would you be opposed to FOIA for essentially all of the TSA's policy & procedures documents which is what he plans to do? There might be no legal remedy, but certainly a "public opinion" one. He also doesn't want to pursue anything on the grounds of their procedures or policy, but the ADA / Rehabilitation Act, and this is where all of us need to excuse ourselves into IANAL.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThe FOIA request and the threat of lawsuit are very different things. He's using TE former to attempt to bolster his claims for the later (which, if he can get the info, is a good strategy).
- DannyBee 14y agoOf course I read the link, he FOIA'd, filed ADA complaints, and is threatening a lawsuit. So, in order: 1. FOIA will get him some documents in about 3-4 years. Maybe. It'll take a while, and he'll get the old copies. 2. The ADA filings will do nothing. the ADA specifically exempts travel by aircraft when it comes to accommodations for forms of public transportation. It also does not say anything about US Government administrative searches. He would actually have to try to find something under the ACA (Air Carrier Access act), and there is nothing there. Any sane disability lawyer will tell him the above. This is all bluster for a a 1983 lawsuit, however, .... The 1983 lawsuit is probably a non-starter on the 4th amendment side. You'd have to show the TSA's actions are contrary to clearly established federal law. At least on the facts seen so far, they aren't, and courts have generally agreed to this. If they had arrested him, maybe he'd have a 1st amendment claim like Tobey does (so far) in Tobey v. Jones. But again, even sympathetic courts so far have thrown out most 1983 actions for 4th amendment violations against the TSA. 3. I am a lawyer, actually, so I don't need to excuse myself. I've actually even got a ADA recognized disability and have actually fought fights under the ADA. (though, in the interest of full disclosure, my normal day job now is IP law, i have dealt with plenty of constitutional law :P) In any case, i'm opposed for the reasons I stated in the first reply: He is, IMHO, unlikely to accomplish anything except making bad law through the above. Even his video is causing divided public opinion in this very thread. If you want to have a chance of doing something right now, you need the old disabled war vet who is being strip searched because blah blah blah. It's certainly his right to pursue what he wants, but I personally don't see it as helpful to the cause.
- iandanforth 14y agoAt the risk of philosophy there is a difference between expectation in terms of a demand, and expectation in terms of an assumption. There is no naiveté in understanding the common outcome and seeking an alternative one. I learned a lesson recently about having faith that the status quo can be changed from the tactics of the GLBT community. I had assumed that the only way to create real change would be to force change through radical action, but they expected people to act like rational caring individuals if they just went door to door, introduced themselves, and explained their way of life. This has been (to me) shockingly successful. It seemed naive, an absurd assumption that people would listen and act rationally, but to a staggering extent it has worked. Perhaps you think our legal system is too far gone to be given the same faith, and held to similar expectations of decency, but I would disagree.
- DannyBee 14y agoExcept in very rare cases, the legal system follows society, it doesn't lead it. This is why you see Justice Kennedy worried about ruling on gay marriage. It is obvious to everyone in that room that in 50 years they will likely be viewed as bigoted fossils if they rule against gay marriage (to quote the oatmeal). They aren't idiots. That doesn't mean they are going to jump up and scream that it should happen, because it's not their role in our system. That's congress and the states. They aren't going to be the folks who start the revolution, they are going to be the guys who say the revolution was right. As you've discovered, change of society does not always require radical action. But change of the legal system almost always requires change of society. When it happens the other way around, society still gets the last say. See, for example, the forced relocation of native americans, despite the supreme court ruling it unconstitutional.