3 ms·
If you ignore the fact that the guy was trying to board with 2 liters of liquid, when the limit is 100ml, then yes. Imagine he was trying to board with a 2kg pa
by ricardobeat 14y ago
If you ignore the fact that the guy was trying to board with 2 liters of liquid, when the limit is 100ml, then yes. Imagine he was trying to board with a 2kg pack of sugar instead. Just saying it is 'medical' is not enough, otherwise anything would go through just by saying the magic word.
From the agent's perspective, some guy with a camera showed up with 2L of juice, clearly not allowed, and didn't want to give any further explanation. What should he do?
- erikpukinskis 14y agoAccording to his blog post, there is no limit on volume. I don't know where you're getting this 100ml number.
- lwf 14y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=3.4+oz+in+ml https://www.google.com/search?q=3.4+oz+in+ml
- ricardobeat 14y agoThere is no volume limit for medication. The issue here is that in his case store-bought juice is his 'medicine'.
- doctorwho 14y agoI'm a type 2 diabetic. The medecine I take affects my blood sugar. The "medecine" that protects me from my medecine is sugar and can be bought anywhere. It's medicinal to me regardless of what any moron TSA agent might think. If my flight is delayed and I can't eat or drink something sugary when I need it, my blood sugar drops and I go into a coma and risk brain damage. Should I depend on the flight attendant to rush me some sugar if I'm about to pass out or should I be allowed to carry it with me? I don't have to rely on sugary drinks in emergencies, I can use sugar pills but his needs are more constant and immediate. I may not agree with this adversarial approach but I sure as hell understand his position.
- eridius 14y agoAre you a doctor? What qualifications do you have to determine that something does not have a valid medical use?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- silencio 14y agoMy father travels with a bottle of juice/soda regularly because it is a reliable, known, and fast way of raising his blood sugar when it gets too low, and it is far more palatable than non-liquid methods of doing so. He has never been hassled when it is explained to a TSA agent (and he has a doctor's note too). Just because it's not prescribed or regulated doesn't mean it can't be medically necessary. Not to mention I have personally traveled with all kinds of things including Costco-sized bottles of contact lens solution and gigantic aerosol cans... it is what it is and with screening I don't see why TSA can't let people through with it.
- ricardobeat 14y agoI think that's totally fine, but unlike your father he doesn't want to explain at all or carry a doctor's note. You can't show up to the gate with a gallon of water and get through security just by saying "it's medical" with no further explanation.
- gambiting 14y agoMy question is(I honestly don't know) - do you not get shops behind the security screening like any country in the EU does? I don't bring anything to drink with me, but immediately after going through security I go to the nearest duty-free shop in the departure lounge and just buy a bottle of juice or whatever. Problem solved.
- saraid216 14y agoThe prices are generally higher back there, for what I hope are obvious reasons.
- hnolable 14y agoJust FYI, they tested the liquid in question for explosives and of course it turned up negative (as can be seen near the end of the video). Would requiring a doctor's note or more explanation really make any of us safer. I'm sure the terrorists have doctors too. I think the main point here was this was already decided in court and even put into policy and the TSA just disregarded it.
- ricardobeat 14y agoI'm sure terrorists have chemists too, and would defeat that swab test in a week if it was that easy to take large amounts of unknown substances through security.
- hnolable 14y agoNot necessary. The TSA already gave a better alternative. FTFV: They can put the liquid in several smaller bottles and then let him through with it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0m12mLXgO1A&t=11m10s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0m12mLXgO1A&t=11m10s
- bmelton 14y agoSo what you're saying (and I'm trying to ask this without laughing), is that per TSA rules, I can't bring a liter of potentially explosive liquid, but I can bring several smaller containers of potentially explosive liquid, as well as a dry (empty) 1 liter bottle?
- hnolable 14y agoI assume they would probably still _attempt_ to limit the amount of total liquid. But the idea that terrorists can bypass a chemical bomb detector but not figure out a way around the amount of liquid limit is laughable.
- ricardobeat 14y ago
- fuuuuuuuuuuu 14y ago> Just saying it is 'medical' is not enough, otherwise anything would go through just by saying the magic word. Legally speaking, just saying it's 'medical' should be enough to trigger a testing for safety, followed by permitting it through. You're not required to reveal a particular disease (or use of something) under the ADA.