5 ms·
I was with him until I watched the actual video, where he basically comes off like a guy deliberately looking for a fight who gets one. He tries to pull the "i
by DannyBee 14y ago
I was with him until I watched the actual video, where he basically comes off like a guy deliberately looking for a fight who gets one. He tries to pull the "i don't have to explain why it's a medically necessary liquid, you fuckers should screen it".
All they did was ask why it was medically necessary, which is reasonable, in order to prevent people from abusing the policy.
His citation that the special needs memo says things like "a doctors note" are recommended, not required, doesn't say anything to the contrary. Nowhere in the memo does it say "you will not be asked to explain why it's medically necessary", and in fact, the reason they probably recommend doctors notes/etc, is to avoid having to repeat a verbal explanation 100x over.
Realistically, if he challenges this in court, he's likely to end up making bad law.
People don't like to hear that non-sympathetic plaintiffs and bad actors often cause bad law to be made, but it's reality. Judges aren't automatons, and the law isn't that rigid in most cases (which is yet another thing engineers/etc don't like to hear).
He seems to act like fourth amendment law is not open to interpretation, or that fourth amendment law has not changed over time (in fact, to his detriment, since there are a lot more exceptions related to border searches and searches used to ensure security than their used to be).
By doing this he misses the one mildly likely result: He will be the cause of a new exception to the 4th amendment.
- tptacek 14y ago'DannyBee, who IIRC is a practicing lawyer, is alluding to a legal truism: "hard cases make bad law". Look it up; the links are interesting. I think about "hard cases" making "bad law" a lot, even in non-legal situations (like the PyCon drama).
- pyre 14y agoOr "three strikes laws" in California...
- Samuel_Michon 14y ago“All they did was ask why it was medically necessary” If he had explained all the ins and outs of his illness, then what? Are they in any position to judge the necessity of him drinking sugar water? If not, what's the use of explaining it to them? They should know their own rules and act accordingly. It's unacceptable for them to make someone wait for 20 minutes while they look up what they should already know.
- ricardobeat 14y agoI assume that's why a doctor's note is recommended, so that nobody needs to make assumptions.
- themgt 14y agoTSA contractors have absolutely no right to demand intimate medical information from people who simply wish to travel through the air. The fact that you would think otherwise is a symptom of how unhinged the thinking in this country has become. They prohibited him from drinking juice. He asked to be allowed to drink it in front of them, and they said no. What in the fuck is anyone from anywhere doing telling anyone they aren't allowed to drink juice? If you answer "safety" or "the law" or really anything, you are utterly, utterly lost. This is wrong.
- BHSPitMonkey 14y ago> TSA contractors have absolutely no right to demand intimate medical information from people who simply wish to travel through the air. They're not doing that. They're demanding a doctor's note (official communication from your doctor to people like employers, school administrators... in other words, not intimate information) only in the case that you need an exemption from the rule that prohibits you from carrying on large amounts of liquid. Should they exempt passengers from rules just for saying "naw, it's cool, it's a medical thing"?
- saraid216 14y agoIt's not an exemption from the rules when the rules explicitly say that it's cool.
- DannyBee 14y agoCan you point to where it says that? It actually does not say that they can't ask, and you don't have to prove it. The only thing the rules say is that it's "recommended but not required" that you carry a doctors note. That doesn't mean "welp, i don't have to prove shit, because i am not required to have a doctors note". It means it's recommended, but not required, that you have one. If you don't, there is nothing in these rules that say you won't have to explain yourself.
- saraid216 14y ago
- iandanforth 14y agoI'm not sure what video you watched. Here's a guy who, to the extent of his non-lawyer knowledge, stands up for his rights in the face of bureaucratic harassment. He doesn't yell, scream, or cry, he just insists on people following their own rules, not having his possessions taken, and being treated like a citizen whose rights should be respected. The above comment implies that it is reasonable for TSA contractors to inquire about medical conditions. That is a huge grant of personal information no one should have to make. The above comment also makes the assumption that instead of authority proving it has a need to restrict rights, individuals must prove they deserve freedoms. It is that reversal of attitudes that scares me more than anything.
- ricardobeat 14y agoIf you ignore the fact that the guy was trying to board with 2 liters of liquid, when the limit is 100ml, then yes. Imagine he was trying to board with a 2kg pack of sugar instead. Just saying it is 'medical' is not enough, otherwise anything would go through just by saying the magic word. From the agent's perspective, some guy with a camera showed up with 2L of juice, clearly not allowed, and didn't want to give any further explanation. What should he do?
- erikpukinskis 14y agoAccording to his blog post, there is no limit on volume. I don't know where you're getting this 100ml number.
- lwf 14y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=3.4+oz+in+ml https://www.google.com/search?q=3.4+oz+in+ml
- ricardobeat 14y agoThere is no volume limit for medication. The issue here is that in his case store-bought juice is his 'medicine'.
- eigenvector 14y agoPicking a model plaintiff for litigation of this type is very important. Just look at how the plaintiffs in what became DC v. Heller (the case that established the 2nd Amendment as an individual rather than a collective right) were selected: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller#Lower_Court_Background https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller...
- temphn 14y agoThe "rules" about liquid are silly. The TSA plays the ball rather than the man, going after 3 ounce bottles rather than people with a history of terrorist sympathy.
- thezach 14y agoActually its illegal to request a passenger to identify his or her disability to a TSA security checkpoint or require proof of the disability.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gambiting 14y agoI think you watched something else. I would have exploded like 10 times in that time, and he remained perfectly calm. And no, if it's not required by law, he should not be asked questions about his medical conditions or requirements. Period. If they want to be able to ask these questions,they should include such a policy. An agency that interprets their own rules however it sees fit is a recipe for disaster.