4 ms·
Of these, Sailfish has the most serious and experienced team behind it. It won't leave the shop unfinished. It is do or die for Jolla. For everyone else phone O
by Zigurd 14y ago
Of these, Sailfish has the most serious and experienced team behind it. It won't leave the shop unfinished. It is do or die for Jolla. For everyone else phone OSs are a hobby.
Everyone else is learning by doing. Even Samsung. Samsung's feature phones run RTOSs licensed by Samsung, and, of course, while Samsung has made some impressive modifications to Android, that's far from showing they can make a complete modern phone OS.
- fingerprinter 14y agoI don't know if/how you can say that Ubuntu Touch is a "hobby". And outside of Apple and MS, there is literally no other company as experience at creating an operating system as Canonical and the Ubuntu community. Based on the early revs, Ubuntu is by far the most polished. Canonical is also led by someone with a driving vision, very deep pockets and an absolute want to make a mark on mobile. So, Ubuntu has the most experienced team, the most polished early rev product and a focused founder. No way that Ubuntu Touch isn't the front runner here. Frankly, it isn't even close (or fair) to compare the rest to Ubuntu.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoI agree with the grandparent. This matters more to Jolla; it's literally their company. If Sailfish doesn't catch on they will go out of business. I'd feel better if I knew in advance that everything they are working on is open source. While Ubuntu has experience bundle's open source software and to a smaller extent creating their own, they don't have any experience in mobile, which is a different ball game entirely. Early progress is impressive though, I will agree.
- Zigurd 14y agoGo listen to the Unity haters (I'm not one anymore, it finally seems to work well once you pry the Amazon spyware out of it) about Canonical's ability to innovate without shipping something half-baked. Ubuntu Touch is heavily dependent on Canonical being able to do major surgery on the Linux graphics stack on a very tight schedule. I agree with their plan and the reasoning behind it, but there are many reasons to doubt they can execute on schedule. As for the team, Ubuntu has some experienced phone OS developers but nowhere near the depth Jolla has. The way that Ubuntu used SurfaceFlinger as a provisional system compositor is brilliant. But getting from there to a product is more work than Canonical has ever had to put into a project.
- glomph 14y agoOnly if you restrict the conversation to PC user operating systems.
- shawn-butler 14y agoIt's funny to hear Samsung and Intel described as "hobby" developers. Intel and Nokia achieved a shipping platform with the N9 and I think some other partners may have shipped a Meego product before it was killed by Microsoft cash/Elop. Samsung shipped successful BadaOS phones under the Wave line. People on HN should be uniquely qualified to know what it means to actually ship a product and not dismiss it so out of hand. Bada was an extensive userland sitting on top of either Linux or proprietary BSD-ish kernels and was the culmination of probably a decade of effort. I never saw anything other than prototypes running on top of Linux kernels though. The shipping product was entirely proprietary and achieved some decent share in a few markets (Brazil and Europe I think) for the total lack of marketing.
- Zigurd 14y agoAs-shipped, Bada ran on, as far as I know, a feature-phone OS kernel, probably Nucleus from Mentor Graphics, but I don't know for sure. The Bada runtime and APIs are no great shakes. Much less well-developed than Qt, and no basis for a modern smartphone runtime. Before iPhone, mobile OEMs were not expected to know what to do with software. The exception, at the time, was Nokia, which by itself constituted the entire first tier of the mobile handset business. As for Intel, I'm sure many people on this forum have their own stories of Intel and an un-serious dabbler in OSs. The example I know of is their brief ownership of a DSP OS. Microsoft convinced them they really shouldn't be trying to define multimedia APIs and software for PCs, and that was soon over. The bottom line is, there is a firm basis in history for thinking neither Samsung nor Intel, much less the two "working together," such as that cooperation is, can produce a serious mobile OS product.