8 ms·
Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them Smarter
- ptbello 14y agooh and by the way, one of the mice is called Algernon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flowers_for_Algernon#Short_story http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flowers_for_Algernon#Short_stor...
- dsowers 14y agoJust finished that book last night. It was a good read, but deeply unsettling for some strange reason. His intelligence decline at the end makes the reader feel like retardation is a very near threat to all of us. It's one of those threats that seems worse than death, too.
- cpursley 14y agoWhat are we doing tonight, Brain? The same thing we do every night, Pinky... ...Try and take over the world!
- eadlam 14y ago"Try to ..."
- dualogy 14y agoDo we really want smarter rodents? (Then again, think if we could secretly outsource loads of PHP SQL-CRUD projects to them..)
- xradionut 14y agoThey might get some of the bad human traits. Consider religious wars over brands of cheese or colors of automotive electrical wires.
- 1337biz 14y agoThat is a brilliant idea for keeping the world wide mouse population under control!
- pixl97 14y agoBeing that many religions frown on birth control, being gay, and instead focus on having lots of babies... I don't think that would have the population control effect you are looking for.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Nyubis 14y agoThis is a good question. HGTG-scenarios aside, what if they become sentient? Do they deserve the same moral weight humans have now?
- ajitk 14y agoAren't they sentient? They are able to perceive and feel things.
- erifneerg 14y agoPeople often mix the words sentience and sapience to mean the same thing. Mice clearly can perceive and feel things but they do not show the intelligence we call sapience.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoOn the topic of AIs, not mice, but very relevant to the questions you mentioned: http://lesswrong.com/lw/x7/cant_unbirth_a_child/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/x7/cant_unbirth_a_child/
- reeses 14y agoThis was my immediate reaction. Pain experiments, as described in the article, are a necessary "evil" in many animal experiments. Human trials have the same conditions, with both the pain of treatment and the suffering of being in the "control" group and having false hopes; however, participants have consented to the experiment. We empathize much more strongly with animals that behave in human ways. Couple this with the "cuteness factor," which I use to mean that we are sensitive and protective of things that we find to be cute (babies, kittens, Yoda, puppies, etc.) and we have a very irrational, visceral response to the idea of torturing cute, smart, affectionate, best-dog-I-ever-had, animals. It's not inherently bad but it clouds our judgment on what is right and wrong in terms of our treatment of these animals and the ends that justify this treatment. We (as a species) kill and eat whales, which most of the developed world has agreed to be unacceptable. I don't know if this is moving in a "Rats of NIMH" or "Planet of the Apes" direction, but the philosophical ramifications of sentience are likely to be explored as a result of this type of "improvement". We have a huge body of sci-fi, speculation, religion, and thought-experiments regarding sentient non-human forms, including what defines "life" and "personhood". It will be an interesting test of humanity to see how we deal with any positive results of this type of exploration.
- brador 14y agoImagine if you could grow yourself a huge brain. I'm finding more and more that the biggest bottleneck in my awesome plans is me. Or maybe you could grow a second brain and switch them out while one sleeps/defrags.
- checker 14y agoHow would you keep those brains in sync?
- aswanson 14y agoDropbox perhaps could have a service tier for cerebral cortices.
- dm2 14y agoA cloud brain might be easier, just a good BCI and a connection to the internet would be all that's needed to get started.
- reeses 14y agoInstead of two hemispheres, split your brain into quadrants with high bandwidth and referential locality for task memory. Also, try to figure out a way to harness hormonal "intelligence" for general purpose cognition.
- terhechte 14y agoI for one welcome our new rodent overlords.
- wslh 14y agoYou don't know if they are already posting in HN now :-) singularity is near....
- tokenadult 14y agoTypical of Singularity Hub, this is a link-baity treatment of a story that has already been widely reported. The underlying research study http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(13)00007-6 http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(13)00... is interesting, and worth replicating with varied experimental conditions, and indeed it may be important for clearing up what glia cells do in the human brain. But in terms of treatments on human beings, this looks a lot more radical and a lot more likely to be expensive and subject to regulation than simply engaging in deliberate practice and finding a good coach.
- exodust 14y agoPerhaps the injected mice had less appetite from side effects of the human brain cells, therefore not crazy about the idea of getting hurt for food. Mice are already smart. They can steal and transport cat food in their mouths and stash it for later out of sight. That's not the actions of a stupid mouse.
- quasque 14y agoNone of the tests they used were food-related. If you're curious, pages 13 to 17 of the supplementary data (from "Auditory fear conditioning" onwards) describe the methods they used to test learning and memory: http://download.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/mmcs/journals/1934-5909/PIIS1934590913000076.mmc1.pdf http://download.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/mmcs/journals/1934-5...
- exodust 14y agoThanks, and good to know it's more than dangling carrots and lost appetite. Although I wonder if injected brains is an effective treatment for mouse depression? "...all mice were housed in individual cages for 2 months in a single room prior to testing."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- fabriceleal 14y agoReminded me of this: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2881 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2881
- nsns 14y agoThis title could be nicely used as a mirror for personal prejudice. If you manage to see through the lazy dust of anthropocentrism, you'll read it as full of horror and pain.
- quasque 14y agoEvery species favours its own - humans are not special in that regard.
- gruseom 14y agoOnly humans perform experiments on other species that we would regard as torture if they were done to us. We argue that it's for the greater good, of course, but the ease and speed with which we rush to accept that is suspicious; in other areas of life we would regard such arguments as obvious self-serving spin. It's not hard to imagine that future generations will look back on many of these experiments with the same moral horror that we have toward some of the past. I had this feeling when watching the Capuchin monkey fairness experiment in Frans de Waal's TED talk. From an ordinary point of view, it's cute and charming. You laugh along with the audience; the monkeys are funny. You go away with a heartwarming feeling that you've learned something about primate (and thus human) nature. But if the veil drops and you look at it more immediately, the video can also seem horrific. At least it struck me that way. That and other things have got me wondering whether there's something wrong with a science that excludes empathy as a component of knowledge.
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y ago> Only humans perform experiments on other species that we would regard as torture. Because only humans are capable to, do you seriously think overwhelming cognitive advantage would be used any different if we had different traits? If our heads were shaped like the ones of mice? Or if we had 4 stomachs like the cows? And this selfishness and disregard for other animals well being is what made humans growth so quickly and one of the main reasons you and me exist.
- quasque 14y ago
- felix 14y agoI know how this movie ends... with the whole colony trying to get to the lee of the stone.
- currysausage 14y agoJust a few more years of research and Brecht's wonderful allegory might finally become reality: http://pamolson.org/ArtSharksMen.htm http://pamolson.org/ArtSharksMen.htm
- barbs 14y ago"...and human’s are the smartest of all thinkers" :|
- alexvr 14y agoI bet they named the mouse Algernon.
- knodi 14y agoPlaying with fire.
- shadowrunner 14y agoThese experiments are cruel. Who has the right to experiment on these animals? Who gave these "scientists" permission to inflict suffering on these mice? Accountability and compassion are lacking here. When will we as a race start challenging the morality of animal experimentation and vivisection? There needs to be protections afforded to animals. This cruelty needs to stop.
- benesch 14y agoTurn the question on its head. Why is it right to prolong human and animal suffering to minimize the suffering of a few lab animals? These experiments are incredibly important for science and healthcare.
- shadowrunner 14y agoAm I to believe you? Even if these experiments do have importance, are they more important than being humane and ethical? We're so damn advanced as a race, yet we can't come up with more humane alternatives? We have record unemployment and pharmaceutical companies that are making billions in profits, why can't we experiment on humans who give consent and are fairly compensated? It's more humane to animals and people.
- unimpressive 14y agoBecause these experiments kill stuff. The humans are more valuable, and I'm sorry that you'd rather see them die than a few rodents.
- shadowrunner 14y agoAnd I'm sorry you lack insight and empathy towards both animals and people who could use the income to have a better life.
- GHFigs 14y agoThe problem is you (as a scientist) don't know that an experimental subject will have a better life, or a life at all, and you don't have enough data about the risks to fairly compensate a person for taking those risks on. You're just making the cost of collecting data much more expensive while shifting the risk (of suffering, disability, death) from animals bred for the purpose to poor people.
- shardling 14y agoSix hours and no reference to the Rats of NIMH?! :) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs._Frisby_and_the_Rats_of_NIMH http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs._Frisby_and_the_Rats_of_NIM...
- bcx 14y agoBeat me by 34 minutes :-)
- antsam 14y agoI for one welcome our new mouse overlords.
- 2510c39011c5 14y agoCould they inject human brain cells into dogs, instead of mice? I just feel a dog who knows English would be more lovely than a mouse who knows the same language...
- heydenberk 14y agoChristine O'Donnell, 2010 Tea Party candidate for the senate in Delaware, totally saw this coming.
- systematical 14y agoSign me up for a shot of Einstein astrocytes.