7 ms·
D.C. (School) Vouchers: Better Results at a Quarter the Cost
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davetufts 18y agoIt's nearly impossible to discuss education, but ignore politics. It's political policy that mandates compulsory education, forces taxation to pay for said education, and outlines what is taught in public schools. Politics play a role in acceptable curriculum for home and private schools, what age children are forced into these institutions, and what drugs & vaccines they must take to participate in the public system. Politics can certainly play a role in vocalizing opposition to these policies.
- lsb 18y agoFeynman actually voiced his frustration over school textbooks, because education was so politicized: http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm And what do you do? Reject those, and choose books that your parent-friends are using? Pay tutors? (Hey, davetufts, I'm a Jumbo too.)
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- jacoblyles 18y agoPublic education is politicized because, being public, it is controlled by political institutions. Contrast this with a private service or commodity, like grocery stores. Nobody lobbies for which food items will be carried in grocery stores, rather the stores respond to the will of their customers.
- tokenadult 18y agoAnd that is true even if some low-income customers shop with food stamps ("food vouchers").
- tokenadult 18y agoAnd I might note for the record that pg, the kind founder of this forum, appears to have quite a strong interest in education issues. http://paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://paulgraham.com/hs.html http://paulgraham.com/hs.html http://paulgraham.com/college.html http://paulgraham.com/college.html http://paulgraham.com/wisdom.html http://paulgraham.com/wisdom.html http://paulgraham.com/credentials.html http://paulgraham.com/credentials.html
- falsestprophet 18y ago"Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site. If you think something is spam or egregiously offtopic, you can flag it by going to its page and clicking on the "flag" link. (Not all users will see this; there is a karma threshold.) If you flag something, please don't also comment that you did." http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- lsb 18y agoSelection bias. If your parents care enough to send you somewhere, they'll care enough to make you do your homework.
- tallanvor 18y agoVery true. And don't forget that everyone is entitled to a public "education". --Including kids who are vegetables and have to have someone watching them all the time. Editing to add more detail: Based on my reading, they're spending more then $300 million on special education, around 25% of their budget. $62 million goes to the university $46 million goes to the public libraries ~$100 goes to early education and ESL initiatives. Those are all expenses private schools never have to worry about.
- davetufts 18y ago"entitled"? That implies a choice. In the US, education is compulsory for certain age groups.
- tokenadult 18y agoRather, school attendance is compulsory absent a government-approved alternative, but one can attend school throughout childhood without ever being educated.
- davetufts 18y agoVery true -- I should have said compulsory attendance.
- ckinnan 18y agoVouchers are a public education. It is just the delivery mechanism that is private.
- raleec 18y agoNope. "Public" education implies that everyone can have it. Vouchers don't provide admission, just a means to pay tuition if you are accepted.
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoWhat would be interesting is looking at the performance of specific students who transitioned from public school to private schools or charter schools.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- briansmith 18y ago* Read the executive summary. Half of the subgroups did not have improved performance. Math performance did not improve. Reading scores did improve, but this specific improvement cannot be meaningfully be attributed to the public vs. private nature of the schools. And, the study does attempt to figure out if the reading improvements could be replicated within the public school system by copying the reading programs used in the private schools. * In the third year, over 83% of the participating students were attending schools where they were forced to endure continuous daily religious indoctrination. This is completely unethical. * No attempt was made to measure the performance of students that attended a school designed for religious indoctrination against the students who attended a school designed expressly for education. * According to the study, many parents (19%) turned down the vouchers they received after their students were accepted to public charter schools. It seems like parents are showing a strong preference for charter schools over private schools. IMO, this warrants further investigation into the funding of public charter schools instead of public funding of private education. * According to the study, many parents of special needs students were not able to use their vouchers because the private schools were not able to provide the necessary services. The public schools are bearing nearly all of the costs of caring for special needs students whereas private schools are mostly punting on the issue. Similarly, if you get kicked out of a public or private school for behavioral or criminal reasons then you will be sent to a public alternative high school. Cost comparisons need to be made using comparable student populations. * All measurements in this study suffer heavily from selection bias. Much of the data comes from voluntary surveys that were filled out by parents. It was basically a competition between political groups to convince the most parents on their side to return the surveys. Parents and students who were not interested in their students' education and/or the political ramifications of the survey are likely severely under-represented. It is silly to draw conclusions about the effectiveness of private schools vs. the effectiveness of public schools by Cato's summary or my summary of the study. A summary of a summary of a study can be easily spun however the writer wants to spin it. AFAICT, the study report itself has very little actionable information in it; at best, it points out areas that need more study before any conclusions can be drawn.
- grandalf 18y agoPerhaps but your conclusions are equally silly (and not based on logic). Voucher programs are very new and rare. Why would you expect them to function at the same level as established (and well funded) public schools after a very short time. For comparison, imagine if FedEx were allowed to deliver residential mail -- would you expect 100% coverage of every US address overnight? Of course not. The ramp-up will take time, and with voucher money entrepreneurs will invent better schools and existing schools will be able to ramp up due to network effects long enjoyed by the public monopoly. Also, you are right that parochial schools enjoyed a bump in enrolment that they may not have deserved, but they benefit from having had (for a long time) other sources of funding, namely donations. Also, I think you exaggerate the "indoctrination" quite a bit. Are public school students not indoctrinated that FDR and Henry Kissinger were great men? I'm not sure why you have to draw the line and say that only indoctrination about the supernatural is distasteful!
- raleec 18y agoThis is kinda disingenuous. 1) Vouchers do not cover the cost of most DC area private schools. They provide approx. $7500, but most top tier schools cast approx $20k, so the school is expected to kick in the remainder. 2) If vouchers became universally available it would simply inflate the cost of all private schools by the voucher amount, with no increase in student achievement. 3) A largely overlooked element is that private schools get to /choose/ whom they accept. This allows them to preselect the voucher recipients that they think would succeed.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoprivate schools are not allowed to deviate significantly from the idiot producing processes of public schooling: * Teacher Certification: Children instructed in private full-time day schools by "persons capable of teaching" are exempt from public school attendance under the compulsory education law. Cal. Educ. Code § 48222. The California Commission on Teacher Credentialing must forward to private schools on a monthly basis a list of all teachers who have had their state teaching credential revoked or suspended. The Commission must also send on a quarterly basis a complete and updated list of all teachers who have had their teaching credentials revoked or suspended, excluding teachers who have had their credentials reinstated, or who are deceased. Cal Educ. Code § 44237(g). Private schools may request information regarding the fitness of any applicant for a teaching position from the Commission. Cal Educ. Code § 44341(d). Curriculum: Students attending private schools are exempt from California's compulsory attendance law if the schools offer instruction in the several branches of study required in the public schools of the state. Cal. Educ. Code § 48222.* is it a shock that performance remains the same when you have the same teachers and the same curriculum?
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoOn the teacher thing, I was under the impression that private schools could hire and fire credentialed teachers as they saw fit, plus could generally afford to pay better to attract better teachers, whereas public schools are handicapped by powerful teachers unions. Granted, my knowledge of the subject is pretty much limited to this paragraph :) On the curriculum thing, it sounds like they just have to offer instruction in the same branches of study, which I'm assuming is things like Math, Reading, Science, etc. Not sure how that equates to the "same curriculum".
- nazgulnarsil 18y ago"credentialed teachers" see pg's essay on credentialism for my feelings. you have state certified teachers teaching a similar curriculum in the way that they were taught (the state certified way). This is a far cry from a truly independent education that is accountable to no one but the customers.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agosubsidizing private schools doesn't help as long as the taxation structure supporting public schools are still in place. all that will happen is private school tuitions will increase the way college tuitions have.