7 ms·
Stallman has been viewed as "radical" his whole career. Certainly there was nothing more "pragmatic" about him in 2001. The important distinction is that the
by ajross 14y ago
Stallman has been viewed as "radical" his whole career. Certainly there was nothing more "pragmatic" about him in 2001.
The important distinction is that the things (you don't list specifics, so I'm just assuming) that Stallman finds "important" seem like senseless distractions to his audience. It's hard to remember now, but in 2001 the idea of patent-encumbered algorithms being a threat to free software was not nearly as well-understood as it is now. Most people in the community were happy to download and build LAME (or whatever), and just shrugged when the Linux distros turned out not to be able to ship it.
Stallman was right (and to be clear: he'd been screaming about patents for a decade already in 2001). We were wrong. This has been a pattern his whole career.
So, again without actual evidence, I'm just going to guess that within a decade that stuff you heard in 2009 that sounded so "radical" is going to seem a lot more clear in hindsight.
- angersock 14y agoStallman has two really, really annoying features: 1. He is a grating and uncompromising lunatic, and does not make any attempts to present himself as agreeable to other people. 2. He's been proven completely correct on everything he's warned us of in this industry to date.
- rimantas 14y ago#2 is total bullshit.
- holri 14y agocan you elaborate on that?
- olefoo 14y ago[ citation needed ] on both the declaration that he's been proven right and on your slapdash dismissal of that assertion. And, please, could you be more of a contributor and less like an aggressive drunk starting a bar fight?
- cgh 14y agoThis very story is a potential example. The mp3 patents in the US will expire in 2015. What "harm" has been done in that time? Fraunhofer made a pile of dough and that's about it. The open alternatives failed to catch on and my guess is that after 2015, mp3s will still be used as before. Very few users will know or care that the patents have expired. I guess you could say Stallman wasn't wrong exactly, just unnecessarily alarmist over this particular issue. I'm not saying software patents are benign, by the way - I'm only addressing mp3 here.
- nitrogen 14y agoWhat we lost was a competitive disadvantage for Linux distros and countless software and hardware products never released by independent developers. Failure lacks a marketing budget.
- cgh 14y agoI don't think desktop Linux's competitive disadvantage had much to do with mp3s, given its tremendous deficiencies elsewhere. I say this as someone who contributed to KDE back in the 3.x days and has been running Linux since 1997. But that's just an opinion - I guess it's possible a lot of people were put off by the hoops necessary to install an mp3 player, although to be honest I don't recall it being a problem for a good decade or so now.
- freehunter 14y agoIt's easy to look back and say "see, it didn't do any harm!" Predicting the future is much more difficult, and it's perfectly reasonable to look at past trends in that prediction. If Frauenhofer had stopped giving out licenses, would you still be making that argument? If they started patent trolling, what would you be saying? Calling someone out after the fact for warning about the potential for harm when the risk is very real based on what happened in the past just sounds like revisionism.
- tome 14y ago
- bane 14y ago2. He's been proven kinda correct on everything he's warned us of in this industry to date...yet for the most part it hasn't really mattered all that much.
- duaneb 14y ago> yet for the most part it hasn't really mattered all that much. I'm a little confused by what you mean. Do you mean what he's afraid about doesn't matter that much? Considering the massive patent lawsuits flying around I think that's pretty blatantly false. I mean, some of this has been ameliorated by industry's unexpected generosity towards the open source world (Google via a ton of shit, Apple via LLVM), but certainly not all of it. Personally, I've stopped ignoring what Stallman is saying. I'm not saying he doesn't have a side of him that worries about completely irrelevant shit, but I think he's been proven well enough on important topics that he deserves our (as hackers, consumers, and business owners) respect, even if you decide you disagree with him.
- bane 14y agoI guess I'm being too strong. I think what I mean is that if the world had followed RMS in keeping away from non free software we'd all be surfing the web through daemon that scrape a URL and then emails us the results. Put another way. RMS has warned about the dangers of hot water and has spent a lifetime taking cold showers. He's right of course, hot water can be dangerous, but warm water is just fine and gets things done. He's presenting a binary choice when its not the choice that matters. It's about how hot the water can get for your needs and not be dangerous is where all the important things are happening. I don't really care about what RMS says because it locks you into thinking binary extremes. Free or evil, the past or some hypothetical future, when it's the now that matters.
- vanderZwan 14y agoI guess I'm being too strong. I think what I mean is that if the world had followed RMS in keeping away from non free software we'd all be surfing the web through daemon that scrape a URL and then emails us the results. You don't think massive adoption of open source software would not at all imply that all the R&D effort spent on everything else over the last decades would have shifted to that instead?
- chimeracoder 14y agoTo further this point, take a look at "Why you shouldn't use the Lesser GPL for your next library", which outlines Stallman's very pragmatic reasoning for his strategy regarding the GNU C libraries: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/why-not-lgpl.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/why-not-lgpl.html > So, again without actual evidence, I'm just going to guess that within a decade that stuff you heard in 2009 that sounded so "radical" is going to seem a lot more clear in hindsight. I remember reading what Stallman said about cell phones, location tracking, and privacy back in ~2004 and thinking he was being paranoid. Boy was I wrong.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI think the problem is not so much with his message but with the steps that he suggests to address it. People are uncomfortable with doing things that severely change their lifestyle and it's easier to rationalise someone as crazy than it is to change. In 2001 there were plenty of people who were critical of Microsoft and their market share abuse but this was at a time when saying "stop using Windows" was akin to saying "stop driving a car".
- bmj 14y agoIn 2001 there were plenty of people who were critical of Microsoft and their market share abuse but this was at a time when saying "stop using Windows" was akin to saying "stop driving a car". Why was this? Perhaps because the state of free (as in speech) operating systems didn't allow most people to make the switch (put aside the corporate world for now). People want stuff that just works[0], and looks relatively pretty, and that was really not the state of GNU/Linux desktops at the turn of the century. I realize that the developers have fought against certain things outside of their control (closed source drivers, for instance), but there's always been that hacker attitude driving GNU/Linux development and usage, so the concerns of the non-power user are often an afterthought. If there existed a legitimate alternative to Windows with the same ease of use, it would be far less difficult to convince someone to switch. [0] Yes, I know, Windows crashes and Plug and Play is often not that.
- dllthomas 14y ago> In 2001 there were plenty of people who were critical of Microsoft and their market share abuse but this was at a time when saying "stop using Windows" was akin to saying "stop driving a car". In 2001, that wasn't the case at all. You still needed to put in some elbow grease, and there were corner cases for sure, but I was using Linux with no problems (except a lack of Counter-Strike), had been for years and so had my parents.