4 ms·
Can anyone tell me if a driverless car hits and injures someone and it is the fault of the driverless car. Who is really at fault? Does the victim sue the drive
by rdtsc 14y ago
Can anyone tell me if a driverless car hits and injures someone and it is the fault of the driverless car. Who is really at fault? Does the victim sue the driver, the software writer, both.
I can see data logging and pervasive monitoring will be needed in order to prove who was at fault, or what exactly happened.
In anyway I see somewhat of a legal obstacle more than a technical at this point.
EDIT: clarification, removed "hits me" reworded for clarity.
- rayiner 14y agoIf I were judging this case, I'd call a car an inherently dangerous instrumentality and hold drivers strictly liable.
- mikeg8 14y agoAre you a judge? do you have any background in traffic laws and/or driver liabilities? Or is this just your two cents...
- rayiner 14y agoJust my two cents (though as someone with a JD). The idea that manufacturers would be liable for collisions is quite laughable. Is your computer manufacturer liable for the damage resulting from system crashes, bugs, etc? Of course not. Manufacturers are liable for design or manufacturing defects but a collision in a driverless car does not necessarily indicate a defect. They aren't magic--a certain number of errors are to be assumed. In some cases, it may not be physically possible to prevent a collision (computers react at the speed of electrons, but cars only at the speed of big heavy physical objects). No, I think driverless cars will be handled by extending the concept of "inherently dangerous instrumentalities." If you're say demolishing a building with explosives, your standard of liability is not whether you were doing so carefully. It's strict liability: it's an inherently dangerous process so you better carry sufficient insurance because if it goes wrong you're strictly liable. Cars will, and should, be considered the same way, and will likely be handled through no-fault insurance systems paid for by drivers.
- mikeg8 14y agoInteresting. Thanks for the response. One reason computer manufactures aren't liable is because a computer is an "open" system (so to speak) where a user can introduce all sorts of external variables that may affect it's performance/stability (viruses, malware etc). Ideally the software in the car is closed so malfunctions cannot be attributed to user intervention. And if one of the sole jobs of that software is preventing collisions thought a series or calculations, sensors etc, it seems like a failure would be more on the manufacture's end than the driver but thats just my opinion.
- rayiner 14y ago> One reason computer manufactures aren't liable is because a computer is an "open" system (so to speak) where a user can introduce all sorts of external variables that may affect it's performance/stability (viruses, malware etc). That's not the legal reason (and manufacturers aren't any more liable on totally locked down platforms than on open ones). The legal reason is that we don't hold manufacturers liable for the ordinary dangerous of using their product (as opposed to the extra-ordinary dangers of using a defective product). I'd imagine most collisions in driverless cars won't be from real design defects in the software, but rather from the simple fact that the real world is very complicated. If a driverless car is going around a blind turn and has spotty cell reception, or a deer jumps out in the middle of the road, or the road is wet, the algorithm could be doing everything right and still get into an accident. Again, driverless cars aren't magic. I don't think there is any situation in where manufacturers are liable for something other than a major, reproducible, foreseeable defect in the software. The question is, if the manufacturer isn't liable, who is? Sometimes life sucks and nobody is liable, but the law tends to avoid that. Hence my prediction that the liability will fall to drivers as it does today, on the theory that "you should expect that your 3,000 lb hunk of metal barreling along at 60 mph could hurt somebody."
- stonemetal 14y agoliable for collisions is quite laughable. Without a root cause analysis of the accident I am not sure I would call it laughable. How would driverless unintended acceleration be any different from Toyota's recent unintended acceleration recall and liability? If root cause is a defect then they will certainly be liable. Now that isn't to say any and every crash involving a self driving car automatically becomes their problem, it will be on a case by case basis just like now.
- freehunter 14y agoThe question becomes who is the driver? A passenger is normally not liable in the event that a driver causes an accident currently. If your car is driving itself, then you're inherently not the driver, you're a passenger. Especially if driverless cars are allowed to be ridden in without needing to pay attention or assume manual control, which I believe is the end goal for this technology. So if you want to hold drivers strictly liable for accidents, but the only person in the car is the passenger, then question still remains unanswered: who is liable?
- rdtsc 14y agoInteresting perspective. One can take various perspectives here: the person injured, the driver, the car manufacturer. It has ramifications for all of them. The general questions is, "is the judicial system ready to deal with robots, sold to others, who end up injuring and killing people?". I don't know if it is. Cruise control is there as others pointed. A car on a cruise control hitting someone will be the fault of the driver pretty much. There are also law suits about failing breaks and other defects, those after extensive back and forth, end up eventually being a manufacturer's problem.
- rubinelli 14y agoI think the legal situation is clearer than it looks. Hitting someone due to software failure isn't any different than if it happens due to a break or cruise control malfunction. As long as the equipment is approved by your local traffic authority and you did proper maintenance, you can prove it wasn't your fault. (not being your fault won't stop anyone who wants to sue you, but that's another matter entirely)
- ams6110 14y agoFault and liability aren't the same though. Even if an accident is caused by your brakes failing, it's still your car that caused the damage and it's you (your insurance) that will pay. Even if it doesn't result in a traffic citation on your driving records.
- w0utert 14y ago>> As long as the equipment is approved by your local traffic authority and you did proper maintenance, you can prove it wasn't your fault. Which is exactly why I'm still 100% convinced this whole pipe dream will disappear the moment self-driving cars become available to consumers, and a few serious accidents happen. No car manufacturer on earth is going to continue selling cars with the promise they can 'drive themselves' if that makes them liable for accidents. Exhaustively testing a cruise control system is one thing, but ensuring at least 'nine nines' of reliability of all the hardware and software systems of a self-driving car, in every possible situation it could be used, is simply intractable. Anything less than nine nines reliability, and someone will die because of a problem with your self-driving car at least once every week or so.
- rdtsc 14y ago> Hitting someone due to software failure isn't any different than if it happens due to a break or cruise control malfunction. I kind of agree with that. That is why I inserted the bit about pervasive logging of events. This technology will increase that many times over. Any manufacturer getting into this will need that in order to prove beyond any doubt that their software did the right thing. NOW bugs happens and in this case bugs will kill people at some point. So, can the manufacture be trusted with keeping logs themselves. The answer is no. Not if they have a strong incentive to make it look like it is not their fault. It it basically either their ass on the line or driver's ass. There will always be a question of "ok, so they do show that user pressed the pedal and tried to take manual control of the car, but how do we know they didn't insert that artificially in there...". I think there will be a need for 3rd party or government mandated continuous logging. Cameras, following distance sensors, accelerators, local road conditions monitoring and so on, so during a law-suit this 3rd party's product (who supposedly should have not interest in falsifying the data) would be used in establishing fault.