6 ms·
How driverless cars will affect our cities
- rayiner 14y agoThis sounds like some perverse suburban fantasy. To an extent I'm okay with the idea of people following their preferences, but the fact is that the market is being undermined by municipalities in this case. All those land owners in San Francisco are halting further development of the city, driving prices artificially through the roof and driving people who might prefer to be in a more urban setting into the suburban wasteland. Where at least now they can tool around in their robotic cars. Fucking wonderful. On a less bitter note: as someone who lives in the future (future circa 1930) and spends 0% of his day in unproductive commuting, you west coast folks are in for a treat in 20-25 years when (if) this happens. That extra hour or so a day of unstructured time to read, surf the net, or just veg is really wonderful.
- virmundi 14y agoI agree with the fantasy part. I do want to point out that the landowners are not necessarily halting building, but they are limited with what they can do. San Fran needs to build up. Unfortunately, they are not allowed (http://www.planetizen.com/node/39697 http://www.planetizen.com/node/39697).
- potatolicious 14y agoLike virmundi brought up, landowners are not the bottleneck in San Francisco - if anything they'd love to knock over that 3-story Victorian and put a huge apartment building in its place. After all, those 5 apartments in his existing building cannot possibly be worth as much as 30 brand new ones, no matter how stratospheric the rent gets. The root cause of almost every San Franciscan problem is rampant NIMBYism. Look at a bus map on the city and notice how closely the stops are spaced together - you have buses that stop on literally every block due to local lobbying, and any attempt to remove some redundant stops to make things run faster elicits an incredible wail from local constituents for whom the only thing that matters is themselves. Development is the same story. People moved to SF for the pretty Victorians they get to see when walking down the street, and any attempts to change this landscape, no matter how mindful of history, art, and architecture, is struck down to preserve the status quo (wherein the status quo is a sick, perverse emulation of the early 1900s). San Francisco is the city where everyone is trying to squeeze through a very small door, while the people who just squeezed through are busy trying to slam the door shut behind themselves.
- rayiner 14y agoI agree with you, I should have used "resident" instead of "land owner." The people that vote on the municipal boards, whoever they are.
- JumpCrisscross 14y ago"a technology that condenses the time needed for commuting along the same route – and allows doing so in the back seat – will make [affordable, spacious dream] homes more agreeable" As a New Yorker who spends a lot of time in back seats, I think the author is exaggerating the effect driverless cars will have on the palatability of commute times. I am more sensitive to commute times than my friends in the Bay Area, gladly moving to cut a 20 minute commute to 10. Even though I have a car taking me door-to-door, and even though I'm reading my email and screwing around on Hacker News the whole time.
- jimktrains2 14y ago>"a technology that condenses the time needed for commuting along the same route – and allows doing so in the back seat – will make [affordable, spacious dream] homes more agreeable" Ugh, more sprawl.
- nkozyra 14y agoIn other words, no matter how great, easy, convenient or pleasant things get, people will find a way to complain.
- chiph 14y agoPeople want mass transit ... as long as it looks like a car.
- jeffasinger 14y agoPeople want point to point mass transit. I'd love to use Mass Transit for my daily commute. But at 1 hour for taking the bus vs 10 minutes to drive, it just doesn't make sense.
- danielweber 14y agoPeople want a transit system that takes them where they want to go when they want to go, that is clean, that they don't have to share with strangers, that they won't have someone asking them for "spare" change [1], that has their personal accouterments available for them, that allows them to do other things with their time, that isn't terribly expensive, that doesn't smell like urine. [1] http://www.davebarry.com/gg/newyork.html http://www.davebarry.com/gg/newyork.html
- fennecfoxen 14y ago[1] "I once watched three German tourists -- this is a true anecdote -- attempt to get off the northbound No. 5 Lexington Avenue IRT train at Grand Central Station during rush hour." Yeah, taking the Lexington Avenue Line is usually a mistake if there's any alternative (e.g. walking, crawling, just staying home, or getting kidnappend and carted off to southeast asia for random organs to be harvested...) Rush hour just makes it worse.
- masklinn 14y ago> Cities will greatly expand, again: Faster and more efficient transportation will convert locations that are currently too remote for most users into feasible alternatives, abundant with space. Here's my alternative idea: cities will contract because you won't need to ever have your own car anymore (with all the required space that entails), city centers will keep making driving your own car more of a pain (as is already happening in european cities) and as gas prices keep increasing the incentive of owning and using your own car will drop, just as the cost of using self-driving electric cars on short in-city commuting will do.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoEither way, in many places (like San Francisco) the constraint isn't places that are too far away, it's places which have too much traffic between here and there. If you could replace a freeway full of human-directed cars with a freeway full of robot-directed cars, this would let you put more people not just further into rural areas, but around existing neighbor cities too. (One of the reasons the SF peninsula is interested in new "transit-oriented developments" near Caltrain instead of other developments: highway capacity on US-101 and 280.)
- iromem 14y agoTrue, but the constraints to construction and therefore to densification - particularly in the Bay Area - are immense. When it's hard to build in the city and it's the urban fringe is a miserably long commute away - housing prices go up. When it's hard to build in the city and the urban fringe suddenly looks feasible, because traffic moves faster - you see city expansion.
- sutterbomb 14y agoAgreed. Owning a car, let alone two or more for a family, is currently very difficult or prohibitively expensive in an urban setting. If you can have the same access as owning, but without the hassle, this removes a barrier for many people. In fact, car-sharing would likely have higher availability and therefore lower wait time in densely populated areas, in some ways increasing your "travel freedom" compared to an exurb.
- pash 14y agoI'm hopeful that driverless cars will be a boon to cities, particularly to the many second-tier American cities whose formerly vibrant cores have been decimated by the need to supply parking for suburban workers. For the past sixty years, suburbanization has increased demand for parking and fed a feedback loop that's destroyed urban density. More people driving means greater demand for parking, which means buildings get torn down for lots and parking structures. Nodes of activity spread farther apart, so more people drive, and drive more often, further increasing demand for parking. The result is a country of paved-over cities with more parking spaces than people [0]. Driverless cars have the potential to break the feedback loop by decoupling destinations from nearby parking, shifting parking out of central cities and freeing land for all the things that make urban living great. Perhaps the feedback loop will start working in the other direction. (I don't think driverless cars will lead to a redoubling of suburbanization, by the way, because I think big houses and wide open spaces are far down the list of reasons most suburbanites live in the suburbs.) 0. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/arts/design/taking-parking-lots-seriously-as-public-spaces.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/arts/design/taking-parking...
- tocomment 14y agoWhy are big houses far down the list? What's high on the list?
- potatolicious 14y agoThe perception and/or reality of safety. Suburban flight in the US didn't occur until long after cars became ubiquitous. People had the means to move to suburbs for years but didn't do so en masse until the urban cores started to rot. People moved out of cities when they became shitholes, and people stay out of cities out of a perception that they are shitholes. Said perception may be true or false depending on where you are. There is also the issue that for people with families, many urban centers have in the past few decades reconstituted and cleaned up, but without the infrastructure that families are looking for: e.g., schools. Suburban living is all about being safe from criminal hordes outside the gates - whether real or imagined.
- rdtsc 14y agoCan anyone tell me if a driverless car hits and injures someone and it is the fault of the driverless car. Who is really at fault? Does the victim sue the driver, the software writer, both. I can see data logging and pervasive monitoring will be needed in order to prove who was at fault, or what exactly happened. In anyway I see somewhat of a legal obstacle more than a technical at this point. EDIT: clarification, removed "hits me" reworded for clarity.
- rayiner 14y agoIf I were judging this case, I'd call a car an inherently dangerous instrumentality and hold drivers strictly liable.
- mikeg8 14y agoAre you a judge? do you have any background in traffic laws and/or driver liabilities? Or is this just your two cents...
- rayiner 14y agoJust my two cents (though as someone with a JD). The idea that manufacturers would be liable for collisions is quite laughable. Is your computer manufacturer liable for the damage resulting from system crashes, bugs, etc? Of course not. Manufacturers are liable for design or manufacturing defects but a collision in a driverless car does not necessarily indicate a defect. They aren't magic--a certain number of errors are to be assumed. In some cases, it may not be physically possible to prevent a collision (computers react at the speed of electrons, but cars only at the speed of big heavy physical objects). No, I think driverless cars will be handled by extending the concept of "inherently dangerous instrumentalities." If you're say demolishing a building with explosives, your standard of liability is not whether you were doing so carefully. It's strict liability: it's an inherently dangerous process so you better carry sufficient insurance because if it goes wrong you're strictly liable. Cars will, and should, be considered the same way, and will likely be handled through no-fault insurance systems paid for by drivers.
- rayiner 14y agoI think a lot of these things also aren't thought through: 1) Driverless cars might possibly allow higher capacity/speeds on major highway thoroughfares, causing cities to expand. Or, they might totally solve the "last mile" problem of commuter rail. High-speed car travel dramatically increases wear and tear on roads, and building more highly-worn roads further out might not make as much sense as building out rail.[1] 2) Driverless cars may case semi-urban areas (like Palo Alto or Tyson's Corner in Virginia) to contract, because of the dramatic reduction in parking requirements. It's not clear that the prevailing trends are towards bigger, sprawlier houses. Indeed, at least on the east coast, the development seems to be on moderate-density mixed commercial/residential in places like Northern Virginia. In the Chicago area (not east coast, I know), satellite cities like Aurora have been growing at 20-40% the last few decades. In the D.C. area, Arlington has been growing at double-digit rates over that period, and Alexandria has averaged about double digits. I can easily imagine driverless cars moving this trend along, replacing core cities with sprawling suburbs with core cities surrounded by dense satellite towns, connected by rail. [1] One of the interesting things about say the Metro North railroad I take to work is how relatively undisruptive it is to the surrounding area. There are nice houses a stones-throw away from the rail line, while there would never be such houses that close to a highway. And even the 2x2 express arrangement fits the capacity of a major highway into the space of a very modest suburban road. The whole Metro North system moves 300,000 people into Manhattan each weekday and operates on a meager budget of $200 million/year. I don't think there is any way you could maintain a comparable highway network for that price, and that's before you factor-in gas/mileage on the vehicles (which, operating at higher speed, are going to use more energy and wear out faster--it's simple physics). EDIT: I've seen 7-15 cents per vehicle mile quoted for maintenance and traffic services. Metro North probably represents a few billion vehicle miles equivalent.
- marco-fiset 14y agoThere will be far less car accidents.
- ck2 14y agoIf automated cars stop just one drunk driver from killing someone, I think the whole invention will be worth it if only for just that. Because I've come to realize people are just going to drive drunk no matter what the penalties may be and judges are going to keep letting them back on the road. So maybe robots will cause better behavior despite some horrible people in society.
- pyre 14y ago| If automated cars stop just one drunk driver | from killing someone, I think the whole | invention will be worth it if only for just that. Well, not if they cause more deaths from malfunction.
- ck2 14y agoThat's a valid concern but sensors and computing hardware is becoming so inexpensive it's possible to have two or more redudant systems that check each other's results before causing an action (or if one fails). That is how the space shuttle's computers worked based on 1980s technology, I think there were six of them checking each other's results.
- kailuowang 14y agoDriverless cars also means that taxis can be scaled a lot more according to real time demand. Unlike taxi drivers who have to work on a x hour shift, on demand driverless taxi can start and stop working at any time. Second, if people can call a taxi using a smart phone app then taxi's don't need to wondering around the city without passengers. These two factors combined will further dramatically lower the cost for taxi more, a lot more than the 2 thirds cost cut down this article predicted (http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/economy-lab/why-the-future-of-urban-transit-might-be-a-taxi/article6764554/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/ec...). The cost (and effort required) of using such taxis as main means for transportation will be significantly lower than owning a car even without the concerns of parking expense (in rural areas). Does that mean that cities will further spread out or the other way? Who knows. I think it means more freedom for people to select wherever they want to live. You can live in the middle of Manhattan without worrying how to get to the countryside with your dog. You can also live in the mountain and commute 5 hours a day to Manhattan to work (because that 5 hours won't be lost in driving any more)
- mikeg8 14y agoOne of my biggest questions is what does this do for Children and young teens? Can they now ride in their families car by themselves? Do rich 12 year olds get their own car? Driverless cars could open up entirely new age ranges to "driving" (10-16 and the elderly who can't physically drive anymore). And if these kids are riding around by themselves, what impact does this have on their social development. I enjoyed getting picked up by my mom or dad and the discussions we had in the car; and I look forward to picking up my children and talking with them about their days. But this may not be something future parents feel is important and those lost interactions would be a shame IMO...
- dclowd9901 14y agoWow, what a breathtakingly misinterpreted vision of the future of cars. Off the top of my head: 1) Parking lots will not dwindle in usage. What a silly notion. In fact, the demand for cheap driverless taxis will probably make public transit all but obsolete, thus causing more vehicles to occupy the road. Just because the cars will be in high demand doesn't mean they won't need a place to stop and wait on occasion. I could definitely see more efficient and sophisticated parking structures becoming more commonplace, ones where human usage isn't a consideration. Where do you think all those cars will go at 3am? They're not going to just keep driving around... 2) the author seems to think at some point, driverless vehicles will become so ubiquitous that policy would ever pass that stripped the usage of freeways away from drivers. As if that was even enforceable, there will always be a significant enough subset of the population that won't own or choose to use a driverless car. That's what makes driverless cars rather than driverless car infrastructure such an important development. It doesn't ask the world to change around it, or ask people to change.
- Nux 14y agoI welcome driverless cars! Tens of thousands of people die annually because of car accidents. Driverless cars should make sure that number decreases _dramatically_. Second, driverless cars should use fuel more efficiently and try not to cause too many jams. Optimise traffic and make it less polluting. Driverless cars don't need to be stored in/near your home; they can be parked in big neighbourhood parking facilities near-by and come pick you up when needed. Driverless cars should put an end to the auto insurance mafia.
- mattstreet 14y agoSome of the comments here point out how driverless cars would allow people to just call for a car when they need it, a sort of on demand taxi. I'd like to take it one step further and point out that it may make electric cars even more viable. If a car is going to be waiting until someone calls for one, rather than driving around the city looking for people - we could have a certain factor of "extra" cars charging while they wait. When you then request a car, the system would send you one that is sufficiently charged. When you arrive the car will reenter the system and recharge.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- atyoung 14y agoHummmm... Too optimistic. I think the driverless car thing is going to be hampered by rural living as well as the dependence on fossil fuel. Refueling is still a major limitation to this. I don't want my vehicle parking 5 miles away from my work using up more fuel at my expense. It sounds like a recipe for me hating cars in general. This kind of thing would also give techno terrorists a very easy way to cause havoc on the masses... I think we would need to take cyber security quite a bit more serious before this could take place.
- ekr 14y agoCars shouldn't be allowed inside cities at all, for obvious reasons (air polution, noise polution, overall well-being of all citizens). And secondly internal combustion engine is an inventian appropriate for 20th century, certainly not for the present age (because of its 20-25% efficiency, and when you take into account that that's engine efficiency, and the power output is actually used to accelerate several tons of metal, actual cargo is insignificant in most cases, you end up with 2-3% efficiency). This is really one proof of the incredible human stupidity. I would like to see most European cities in the following two decades, as having a traffic made up of bikes and few smaller electric cars. On the topic of driverless cars, it is solving the wrong problem. The advantage most of you mention is more time available for people. That's not really true in my view, because: when I'm in a car, I feel physical distress, some kind of motion sickness, and a great portion of the population has similar symptomes. This greatly reduces the amount of activities one can perform in a car. And secondly, because we're talking about replacing cities (distances < 30km), the best solution is to replace cars with bikes, and you get the additional exercise that's missing from most people's lives, and you don't need to waste time in gyms, which are not as healthy, and don't result in as much endorphines/happiness (I don't have studies to cite for this). And getting back to the topic of driverless cars. As a cyclist I would definitely feel safer around automated cars (but that's mostly because the place where I live is also inhabitated by many uncivilized drivers with no regard for other traffic participants, and no respect for the law, (Eastern Europe)). But then, the add efficiency of automated cars is quickly lost when you add cyclists and other vehicles to the equation. The bottomline : wrong problem, very few benefits, except in places like Eastern Europe, where it can't/won't be implemented because of social and economical reasons.
- h_r 14y agoWouldn't a bicycle be a lousy transport during the winter or when it's raining? Or when you need to carry something like a suitcase to the airport that's 20 miles away? Your reasoning seems to be incompatible with a bus system too.
- atyoung 14y agoHummmm... Too optimistic. I think the driverless car thing is going to be hampered by rural living as well as the dependence on fossil fuel. Refueling is still a major limitation to this. I don't want my vehicle parking 5 miles away from my work using up more fuel at my expense. It sounds like a recipe for me hating cars in general. This kind of thing would also give techno terrorists a very easy way to cause havoc on the masses... I think we would need to take cyber security quite a bit more serious before this could take place.
- saosebastiao 14y agoA reluctant upvote, but only because the author has put more thought into the matter than the typical futurist. But for some reason, he still is victim to the same trap that befalls many futurists: A misunderstanding of the new problems that arise. Cheap taxis that don't require parking and can drive closer together at higher speeds is great. But new problems arise: 1) Bottlenecks on streets due to the expansion of cars in dropoff zones. Imagine the typical airport dropoff zone on a busy day...and then think about that happening on nearly every street. Through-traffic is guaranteed to grind to a halt. 2) Smarter cars do not fix transportation networks. Braess's Paradox is not just a theoretical scenario; It has been observed in multiple cities and sub-city networks. Increasing road capacity can and will increase travel times...and it gets worse when everybody is independently optimizing their paths while driving in the same direction. 3) Supply and demand matching for taxis is an easy problem when you assume spatially random demand for travel in spatially random directions during temporally random times of the day. In the real world, taxis have a limit on the number of places they can be at the same time...and the non-randomness of times, origins, and destinations creates real problems with the availability of taxis...in addition to carshares, buses, trains, etc. Thus, the hypothetical futurist scenario relies upon an abundance of taxis, which may or may not occur due to the delicate balancing act between marginal utilization and capital/operating costs. A taxi that is used twice a day during rush hour is a taxi that does not exist. 4) Deadheading (driving to a demand-location while underutilized) has costs of its own: Now your taxi ride is paying twice as much for fuel for the same amount of of human transportation. A more realistic future involves smaller net benefits which can be only be partially offset to the extent that modification of urban geography permits; We may not be able to turn a hilly isthmus into a flat plain with grid streets, but we can move away from our archaic zoning practices that ensure non-random travel vectors. Carpool lanes will continue to have benefit. If, and only if we allow it, transit systems will become more efficient and less costly on a vehicle mile basis, compounding the benefit of grade separation in the still-gridlocked future.