4 ms·
One of the main things I learned by being in a "gifted" program in school, was that it's very rare that someone is truly "permanently ahead." Kids will be early
by derefr 14y ago
One of the main things I learned by being in a "gifted" program in school, was that it's very rare that someone is truly "permanently ahead." Kids will be early at learning some things, late at learning other things, but by 18 or so the majority of the population will have arrived at a similar skill level in most subjects[1].
This might be an effect of the current education system, not a cause, but I still think it's wrong-headed to put kids permanently into a "teach all the harder stuff RIGHT NOW" class just because they happened to have mastered one or two things early. It may just mean their parents decided to teach them one or two things the other kids' parents didn't; it doesn't mean they're at the developmental stage where they can absorb the more difficult material.[2]
What would help, in my mind, is for kids to be able to learn each subject at their own, separate pace--one "micro-skill" at a time, advancing to the next only when all the micro-skills relied upon as a base for the next micro-skill have been mastered (100%ed). [Think of it sort of like an unlockable "tech tree" of education.] For this to work, a school would need to provide:
A. free access to recorded lectures--not necessarily created by the school, but hopefully taken from the very best presentations of that micro-skill in the world;
B. computerized tests for each individual micro-skill that can be retaken infinitely without score penalty (but procedurally-generated so that this can't be used as a way to cheat), and which, importantly, should also be able to be used as a pre-test to "test out" of having to learn things one already knows;
C. the availability of tutoring/mentoring from others who have just finished learning the micro-skill (not teachers, for whom it's been forever since they learned it; and especially not "peers", who don't understand what they're saying yet.)
This is very difficult to implement, though, when the majority of school-time until at least University (and sometimes continuing through undergraduate studies) is spent in centralized lectures on messy conglomerations of many micro-skills taught in arbitrary order (that is, "courses"), where for each one, the students likely are either "above" or "below" the level.
This format won't be going away any time soon, so these hare-brained "just move them up or down in everything" schemes will continue to be put forth in its place.
---
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_cognitive_development http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_cognitive_development -- basically, there is a reason we don't start mathematics education with set theory, even though it's more "fundamental"--it's more abstract, and abstraction requires faculties that don't develop until later on. The same can be said for teaching kids "real programming" at an early age.
- croyd 14y ago"What would help, in my mind, is for kids to be able to learn each subject at their own, separate pace--one "micro-skill" at a time, advancing to the next only when all the micro-skills relied upon as a base for the next micro-skill have been mastered (100%ed). [Think of it sort of like an unlockable "tech tree" of education.]" This is exactly what the Khan Academy is doing. I believe there's at least one school (not sure if public or private) where they're experimenting with that model. See: http://www.ted.com/talks/salman_khan_let_s_use_video_to_reinvent_education.html http://www.ted.com/talks/salman_khan_let_s_use_video_to_rein... IIRC, the students in the class take most of the lessons via computer/tablet and move forward once they've answered a certain number of quiz problems correctly. The teacher can monitor the progress of each student, and if one is having difficulty than he/she can get some individual help from the teacher or another student.
- barry-cotter 14y agobut by 18 or so the majority of the population will have arrived at a similar skill level in most subjects[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean This is not true and suggests that the author has limited experience dealing with the general population. The college going population is not the general one, and even within that population there are huge differences in ability. This is like saying that UC Berkeley and Cal State San Jose are not meaningfully different in their student intake.
- derefr 14y agoI think you're talking about a very different kind of "ability" than I am. Some kids, coming out of high school, will know calculus, or have the ability to play an instrument, or the ability to render the human form in an anatomically-correct fashion. They also might know any amount of trivia--a list of presidents, the names of all the bones in the human body, etc. None of that knowledge is really representative of being any "better" at anything. They may have just spent less time on the basics, and more time on the advanced stuff. It might just mean they were pushed to take more credits by their parents. They will likely have fundamental gaps (the inability to multiply two numbers in their head, for example) and rely on crutches (like a calculator) to keep up with everyone else in the advanced classes they're forced to sprint through. They might have done it all through rote memorization, and have no clear idea of what any of it means. Recall the refrain of most medical students: "I don't have time for the lesson; just give me the formula." This is in opposition to the people who are "just better" at the fundamentals: each new thing they set out to learn, they'll learn faster and better, because they'll be building their new knowledge on top of mastery rather than a shaky 60%-and-move-on foundation. You might wonder about IQ: IQ or "g" is literally the measure of how fast you can recognize and employ new patterns, and therefore how fast you'll master new micro-skills. Kids with higher IQs will do better under time-constraint. But given as much time as needed, and assuming mastery of previous subjects, IQ is irrelevant. An amusing visual analogy: when you master a micro-skill, you've cleanly filled up a line of blocks in the "well" of your knowledge. When you master enough micro-skills, leaving no "gaps", the knowledge comes together and compresses: you get a Tetris. :)