4 ms·
Attention those of you only skimmed the article or haven't read it at all: pay attention to this piece at the end: "Gerald M. Bradshaw of Crown Point consults w
by jseliger 18y ago
Attention those of you only skimmed the article or haven't read it at all: pay attention to this piece at the end: "Gerald M. Bradshaw of Crown Point consults with students on how to gain admission to selective colleges, universities and law schools." In other words, the author of the article has a tremendous interest in making you think that SAT and other scores are important, and he cites no hard data indicating the growing trend he alleges he exists. Those of you who voted this up probably didn't read PG's essay, "<a href="http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html">The Submarine</a>", which covers just this kind of thing.
Stories like this make me wish I could vote articles down.
- jseliger 18y agoSorry to reply to my own post, but this relevant quote from The Submarine is worth considering: "A good flatterer doesn't lie, but tells his victim selective truths (what a nice color your eyes are). Good PR firms use the same strategy: they give reporters stories that are true, but whose truth favors their clients." In this case, however, I'm not even convinced we're getting the truth.
- tokenadult 18y agoYou have done something more useful than voting the article down by expressing precisely why you think it is a suspect source. Thanks. I submitted the article figuring I would get some well-informed replies about its accuracy here. After edit: Note that some other replies are indicating that some current employers ask job candidates for SAT scores. That has never been my experience, which is why I wanted the reality check on the submitted article. In some hiring processes, I could have gained ground against other candidates if SAT scores had come up in the hiring process.
- scott_s 18y agoBut did you not even notice the bit at the end? Halfway through, I figured this guy was selling services, and went to the bottom to find out what his affiliation was.
- tokenadult 18y agoI was aware of other workplaces, from other accounts by persons not in the test prep business, where SAT scores are a hiring criterion, so I thought this recent blog post was a good enough source to bring that issue into discussion.