3 ms·
Wal-Mart would offer a discount on the customers' shopping bill, effectively covering the cost of their gas in return for the delivery of packages, he added. E
by ams6110 14y ago
Wal-Mart would offer a discount on the customers' shopping bill, effectively covering the cost of their gas in return for the delivery of packages, he added.
Eh, I think they are going to have to offer more than just a break-even on gas to get me interested in going out of my way to deliver a package. But I guess they can try it.
I actually don't see this working at all. Who is liable for the "loss" of deliveries in transit? If the person delivering the order causes a traffic accident, is Wal-Mart partly liable? Will they be checking insurance and driving records before letting someone deliver for them?
It would have to work more like a pizza delivery situation, where the drivers are actually employees, with a driving history check and insurance, though perhaps using their personal vehicles.
- jessaustin 14y agoThis is why they will eventually just make their already-much-put-upon employees do these deliveries on their way home from work. Probably with no compensation beside, "congratulations you get to keep your job for another couple of days!"
- wtvanhest 14y agoI feel like everything you mentioned is easily worked out once you understand their customer. Assuming they want to go through with the plan: Eh, I think they are going to have to offer more than just a break-even on gas to get me interested in going out of my way to deliver a package. But I guess they can try it. You are not likely the person they will be targeting to make deliveries. A lot of their customers barely make ends meet, if at all. Assuming they make a delivery close to their current residence, getting their gas paid for round trip to walmart, even if only a few dollars is a huge amount of money to them. I actually don't see this working at all. Who is liable for the "loss" of deliveries in transit? If the person delivering the order causes a traffic accident, is Wal-Mart partly liable? Will they be checking insurance and driving records before letting someone deliver for them? I don't know driving liability law, and it varies by state, but a company as large as Walmart can either self-insure or contract out insurance. This is a solvable economic relationship that can be worked out. It would have to work more like a pizza delivery situation, where the drivers are actually employees, with a driving history check and insurance, though perhaps using their personal vehicles. That would probably work, but isn't part of their stated idea. Every nit-pick here can be easily solved by professional management. The only question is whether after solving all those issues, it is economical or not.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> You are not likely the person they will be targeting to make deliveries. A lot of their customers barely make ends meet, if at all. Assuming they make a delivery close to their current residence, getting their gas paid for round trip to walmart, even if only a few dollars is a huge amount of money to them. The problem with this is that the Walmart customers who "barely make ends meet" are not that likely to live near the Walmart customers who would pay for this service. It might work in urban areas (where there is less physical separation between socioeconomic classes), but Walmart isn't as prevalent in such places, not to mention the urban poor often don't have cars anyway. For example, I know that I would be willing to pay for this service. But there is no one anywhere near my residence who would be willing to do this for the money.
- joshuacc 14y agoAs someone originally from a very rural state, it's actually quite common for the poor and the well-to-do to live pretty close together, especially near highways, so the logistics makes sense.
- wtvanhest 14y agoYeap, exactly. I used to live in Orlando, FL. People in lower income neighborhoods live 100 meters from high income neighborhoods. Additionally, you should not rule out low income people delivering to other low income people.
- chiph 14y agoI would think they'd want their own trucks. Here's why: For one, it'd stave off comparisons with the teen pizza delivery driver (I like delivery pizza as much as the next guy, but let's face it, they're not a professional-looking workforce) And there's also the advertising/marketing benefits of having your delivery vehicles (with big Walmart logos on them) being seen in traffic & neighborhoods. FedEx & UPS count that as a competitive advantage. It also gives them a future business opportunity to compete with FedEx/UPS. Walmart already has a highly efficient distribution system. This would be an extension of it .. they'd just have to add package sorting capabilities (if they're smart, they'd standardize on a few different box sizes).
- EliRivers 14y agoThere are already courier companies employing essentially casual employees. No uniform or anything like that; these people use their own cars and simply pick up a stack of parcels in the morning and deliver them as best they can over the day. No reason why a company as large as WalMart can't manage that, and by paying these people with a discount on their shopping instead of money, WalMart effectively pays less. Add in that WalMart already has established locations, so they won't need to rent distribution centres, and they're laughing.
- HarryHirsch 14y agoEight or ten years ago Amazon tried using Parcelnet, and what a desaster it was. Parcelnet, if anyone remembers it, was Moms With Vans that were contracted by (I think) Selfridge's to deliver their orders. If that sounds iffy, that's because it was. Packages would never arrive, there was no number to complain, it was awful. It's possible that Walmart are going for a rerun, but I wouldn't recommend it.
- EliRivers 14y agoThey were rebranded as Hermes Europe and they still operate. Amazon uses them today.
- ams6110 14y agopaying these people with a discount on their shopping instead of money Something the IRS will likey have a problem with....