4 ms·

Ask HN: Please help review my site CollectiveSys.com

8 points by jerryji 18y ago

Dear HN, I humbly ask for your precious feedback for my site http://collectivesys.com It's technically a Wiki + social networking site, and semantically a crowd-sourced review + social news site. I hope to make it the one-stop hub for evaluation of anything in the world. Last but not the least, sorry for trading your direct link convenience with my two paragraphs. Many thank in advance. Jerry

mahmud 18y ago
Dude, it's a bit too premature for adsense, dontcha think? Also, your summary of the project is too much jargon: "It's technically a Wiki + social networking site, and semantically a crowd-sourced review + social news site." Put that in active tense: "Read, edit and publish news and important stuff. Contact others and talk about stuff" Also, entries have the URL linked to the source. You might not wanna do that. I recommend a URL from the front page should go to a summary page, where people can read and post reviews, and there should be a big button/link where they can go to the original. Having a separate page will help you with .. err, figure that out, I'm not sure I want to go there now that I remember the adsense ;-)
- jerryji 18y ago
  This is a bit surprise to me -- I thought all HN users would have Adblock on all the time :) In fact, the AdSense is there just to align the user expectation from day one. Anyway, I can't agree more how annoying they can be and am going to turn them off now. Thanks for your advice on the summary.
hariis 18y ago
I looked at it for a few minutes and I get no idea what the site is about or what I can do. May be a welcome page with some blurb will help.
- jerryji 18y ago
  Thanks very much for the feedback. What I fear most finally comes true -- not even HN users can immediately figure out how to use the site (which was purposely left out from the brief)... How about some hints like you can get all news regarding social networking websites: http://bit.ly/dc6ko or compare DISQUS with Intense Debate: http://bit.ly/3Qhr9s Now I definitely need to rethink the usability issue.
  - DTrejo 18y ago
    I was able to figure out the point of the site by finding the greyed out "about" link at the bottom. It was too much work. Also, I think the ratings system for different products is difficult to understand. (I clicked on the anti-virus link from the about page, then on the Avast link. "objectiveness"? huh?)

8 points by jerryji 18y ago

mahmud 18y ago

Dude, it's a bit too premature for adsense, dontcha think? Also, your summary of the project is too much jargon: "It's technically a Wiki + social networking site, and semantically a crowd-sourced review + social news site." Put that in active tense: "Read, edit and publish news and important stuff. Contact others and talk about stuff" Also, entries have the URL linked to the source. You might not wanna do that. I recommend a URL from the front page should go to a summary page, where people can read and post reviews, and there should be a big button/link where they can go to the original. Having a separate page will help you with .. err, figure that out, I'm not sure I want to go there now that I remember the adsense ;-)

jerryji 18y ago
This is a bit surprise to me -- I thought all HN users would have Adblock on all the time :) In fact, the AdSense is there just to align the user expectation from day one. Anyway, I can't agree more how annoying they can be and am going to turn them off now. Thanks for your advice on the summary.

hariis 18y ago

I looked at it for a few minutes and I get no idea what the site is about or what I can do. May be a welcome page with some blurb will help.

jerryji 18y ago
Thanks very much for the feedback. What I fear most finally comes true -- not even HN users can immediately figure out how to use the site (which was purposely left out from the brief)... How about some hints like you can get all news regarding social networking websites: http://bit.ly/dc6ko or compare DISQUS with Intense Debate: http://bit.ly/3Qhr9s Now I definitely need to rethink the usability issue.
- DTrejo 18y ago
  I was able to figure out the point of the site by finding the greyed out "about" link at the bottom. It was too much work. Also, I think the ratings system for different products is difficult to understand. (I clicked on the anti-virus link from the about page, then on the Avast link. "objectiveness"? huh?)