4 ms·

> It appears that they did not actually try any other framework to be frank. Just noted their cons mostly. Wrote code in every one of the 13 frameworks I menti

by bear454 14y ago

> It appears that they did not actually try any other framework to be frank. Just noted their cons mostly. Wrote code in every one of the 13 frameworks I mentioned. Thanks, though, for assuming I'm a complete jackass.

deleted 14y ago
[deleted]
hmottestad 14y ago
Batman.js does look quite good. I'm currently using Angular for a personal project, and I really really like it. Pity you didn't.
- bear454 14y ago
  Thx
- bear454 14y ago
  I'm tickled pink Angular is working for you. I have to say, it looks really cool. But, its just not something we'd use in SUSE Studio. I'm sure a thousand other people will have a thousand other ways of describing how I've slighted or misrepresented their project... and I totally expected that. It's a blog post, not a term paper - there's just no way to comprehensively describe everything about everthing. That being said, the effort I put into making a responsible decision for my project wasn't one I took lightly. I'm sorry folks seem to think so, just because I tried (and slightly failed) to write a 3K word summary of 80 hours of JS framework madness.
wambotron 14y ago
I don't think you should take these comments personally. The world of frameworks is loaded with fanboys of one or the other. :/
taproot 14y ago
I don't like the way the AP made his feelings known but I felt a similar way, I felt the scoring of each point was rather subjective and more or less fixed in order to give the desired outcome. (eg: YUI 4 for community / consistency, and a laughable 3 for publicity, reading your definitions for those and your evaluation of yui, I'm amazed you didn't give 5's across the board) Also, "Wrote code" is pretty relative, did you ship something significant in each, preferably the same thing? Maybe even do your own todo but something relevant to your shop. Or even just a basic twitter / simple blog in each. Until you really use something for something meaningful writing a couple of little gists won't tell you what you really need to know. If you just want to use the shiny new cool kid on the block that is batman, just say so, lots of us do this, not enough of us simply own it (and its consequences.)

by bear454 14y ago

deleted 14y ago

[deleted]

hmottestad 14y ago

Batman.js does look quite good. I'm currently using Angular for a personal project, and I really really like it. Pity you didn't.

bear454 14y ago
Thx
bear454 14y ago
I'm tickled pink Angular is working for you. I have to say, it looks really cool. But, its just not something we'd use in SUSE Studio. I'm sure a thousand other people will have a thousand other ways of describing how I've slighted or misrepresented their project... and I totally expected that. It's a blog post, not a term paper - there's just no way to comprehensively describe everything about everthing. That being said, the effort I put into making a responsible decision for my project wasn't one I took lightly. I'm sorry folks seem to think so, just because I tried (and slightly failed) to write a 3K word summary of 80 hours of JS framework madness.

wambotron 14y ago

I don't think you should take these comments personally. The world of frameworks is loaded with fanboys of one or the other. :/

taproot 14y ago

I don't like the way the AP made his feelings known but I felt a similar way, I felt the scoring of each point was rather subjective and more or less fixed in order to give the desired outcome. (eg: YUI 4 for community / consistency, and a laughable 3 for publicity, reading your definitions for those and your evaluation of yui, I'm amazed you didn't give 5's across the board) Also, "Wrote code" is pretty relative, did you ship something significant in each, preferably the same thing? Maybe even do your own todo but something relevant to your shop. Or even just a basic twitter / simple blog in each. Until you really use something for something meaningful writing a couple of little gists won't tell you what you really need to know. If you just want to use the shiny new cool kid on the block that is batman, just say so, lots of us do this, not enough of us simply own it (and its consequences.)