3 ms·
What I am more interested in is their comment 'spamhaus should not be allowed to decide what goes on the internet'. I abhore censorship. Does Spamhause engage
by tomjen3 14y ago
What I am more interested in is their comment 'spamhaus should not be allowed to decide what goes on the internet'.
I abhore censorship. Does Spamhause engage in it?
- eridius 14y agoNo. From what I understand, Spamhaus basically provides lists that identify known spammers, or known spam hosts. These lists are used for things like filtering out spam emails. So Spamhaus is basically saying that Cyberbunker is a host to spammers, and therefore email coming from the Cyberbunker's IP addresses should be treated as spam.
- mhurron 14y agoIn the same way that your spam filtering is censorship or your ad blocker is censorship. Spamhaus isn't preventing anyone from putting anything anywhere, they provide a service that others can use so they don't have to see it. This post in no way is a comment on any of Spanhaus' practices which has garnered some criticism.
- jholman 14y agoThat's a philosophically vexed question. AIUI, as mhurron says, what Spamhaus does is publish a list. The nominal purpose of that list is to identify spammers, so that people who wish to filter out spam can be assisted by that. People do, in fact, use that list, to filter email. The email recipient wants to be protected from spam, so the recipient's ISP attempts to perform that service, and Spamhaus contributes an opinion that the ISP takes seriously. So, in practice, if Spamhaus adds you to their list, many many users will stop seeing email from you. Spamhaus has a great deal of power to mostly-silence domains. I have no reason to believe that Spamhaus uses their power for anything other than good. But it's not quite as simple as "do they censor? no". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spamhaus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spamhaus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNSBL#Criticisms http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNSBL#Criticisms
- derefr 14y agoI think, basically, Spamhaus should be thought of as the Internet's equivalent to a Credit Ratings Agency (S&P, Moody's, Fitch, et al.) In CRAs' own opinions, they are practicing "free speech" and giving what amounts to "numeric editorials on the quality of companies." In critics' opinions, large corporations and sometimes governments are relying on these "editorials", so CRAs' abilities to say whatever-the-heck-they-want should be regulated.
- jholman 14y agoI think CRAs are a perfect analogy, yeah.
- npsimons 14y agoIt's not censorship; it's simple property rights and basic freedom. I don't consent to someone else using bandwidth that I have paid for, space on my hard disk, or my attention and time, for advertising. Hosting is cheap enough; they can get their own damn website and opt-in mailing list. And spamhaus subscriptions are completely voluntary and optional. That being said, the problem with many BL's is that they are run by incompetents or extremists. They usually either end up blocking things that are not spam by accident (see lists of supposedly dynamic IPs), or block whole subnets (sometimes entire ISPs) to try and "teach them a lesson." or blackmail them into fixing the problem.
- lazyjones 14y ago> That being said, the problem with many BL's is that they are run by incompetents or extremists. Unfortunately, that includes Spamhaus. It's a bit sad to see how many companies will blindly support such entities because they've "heard" that they somehow help fight spam. As someone who's had issues with them because of their badly configured hosts and shady practices (e.g. using domains previously used by mail providers as "spam honeypots", meaning anyone who emails someone with an old address can be banned [all content mailed there is considered spam, regardless of what it actually is]), I am disappointed (yes, looking at you cloudflare).