3 ms·
Normally the site/user generates SSL keypairs locally. The "public SSL certificate oligopoly" just signs them. So, the NSA could get arbitrary SSL certs issue
by rdl 14y ago
Normally the site/user generates SSL keypairs locally. The "public SSL certificate oligopoly" just signs them. So, the NSA could get arbitrary SSL certs issued from compromised CAs for MITM, including replacing them on servers, but still couldn't passively intercept/decrypt.
(Although there's ANOTHER 3 company oligarchy in SSL -- probably Apple and Google and Microsoft actually do generate on their hardware or software the majority of SSL keypairs used. If you compromised there, you could get access to everything, either at generation time, or later through a backdoor. This is unlikely as a pervasive thing since it would be eventually detected, but highly plausible for targeted attacks. If nothing else, government 0-day focused on those platforms to get access to keys would be enough, and wouldn't require cooperation of the vendors.)