16 ms·
U.S. plans to let spy agencies scour Americans' finances
- unclebucknasty 14y agoWhen the story is told of our history, people will be amazed that such a great nation was dismantled with barely a notice. And no one will recall the exact hour: a little freedom here...a few rights there...another bit of privacy given over to our government...
- milkshakes 14y agoI'd say 9/11 is as likely a candidate as any for "the exact hour"
- RexRollman 14y agoFear is a hell of a thing.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoNo doubt. But hey, at least we're safe now.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoDefinitely the catalyst that started it all.
- pekk 14y agoIt isn't better if that power is given over to you and your buddies who are not democratically elected. It is worse.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoI'll take option C.) None of the above.
- mayneack 14y agoBarely a notice? I'd say this is noticed quite a bit compared to other world powers being dismantled. Every random civil libertarian with a blog will be able to point to their blog and say "I saw this coming." Sure, many people probably noticed all sorts of other things, but they didn't all tweet about their daily lives for everyone to see and record.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoBut I don't think the "masses" have noticed or that it has become a social/political issue of nearly the magnitude that it's importance would suggest. In fact, many who are aware of the changes even defend them as being necessary. They still don't notice the overall direction or net effect. Some of the comments on this thread alone speak to that.
- anigbrowl 14y agoOh spare us the hyperbole, the US has always had and wielded with gusto a robust customs power. Eligible bank transactions are already fully accessible to the FBI and letting other agencies run their own pattern-matching algorithms on a sea of dat isn't going to reduce your freedom one whit. If you want to criticize this, get specific about which provisions you find objectionable and where you feel the limits should be and why, instead of striking these insubstantive prophetic poses. As Mark Twain said, 'The rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated.'
- tshile 14y agoI think the objectionable part is where government agencies, with no oversight (they just claim it's to protect 'national security' when congress asks), are given full access to the financial records of every citizen. Just a guess though. The FBI having previous access is not a justification for giving it to every agency. Finally, having a problem with this doesn't mean you don't have a problem with the FBI having access. You may be late to the game but some of us have been complaining about this since the first version of the Patriot Act. Just because you decided to jump in now doesn't mean the criticism of these moves is new or somehow leaving out the previous expansion of government access to previously considered private data.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI was calling up the EFF for advice on anti-bulletin board legislation in in the UK in 1991, the concept of government overreach is not new to me. I am not endorsing mass data collection without any legal safeguards (although there are some strong legal arguments to consider non-cash financial transactions as matters of semi-public record); I think your criticisms here are entirely valid even though my opinion differs somewhat from yours. What I'm objecting is the substitution of rhetoric for reasoned argument, with these post-facto pronouncements of the nation's death and suchlike. If I want emotional appeals that seek to exploit confirmation bias I can just turn on talk radio or listen to commercials for gold and rifle ammo.
- tshile 14y ago
- Ovid 14y agoSo, in my spare time I help people become expats. The (precious few) studies of US expats show that most of them have moved to other countries for someone they love, followed by work or adventure (search for von Koppenfels' study). Very few of us expats have left for political reasons. However, when I talk to people today who want to leave, while adventure and love are still cited, it's the political crap in the US which is driving a lot of it. People are telling me that "the US isn't the country they grew up in." They're saying they can't fight the Koch Brothers, the Waltons, Big{Oil,Pharma,Banking}, Citizens United and so on. I think it's not coincidental that the rate of 18 to 24-year-olds who are interested in moving abroad has skyrocketed from 12% in 2007 to 40% in 2011 (http://www.americawave.com/2011/10/05/somewhatseriously-interested-in-relocating-by-age-group-and-year/ http://www.americawave.com/2011/10/05/somewhatseriously-inte...) but the number of them planning to relocate has collapsed (http://www.americawave.com/2011/10/06/yes-plan-to-relocate-by-age-group-and-year/ http://www.americawave.com/2011/10/06/yes-plan-to-relocate-b...). I think the reason is simple: young people are tired of the constant bad news but they don't have any money to move abroad. Interestingly, when they talk to me about this, they're usually not looking for greener pastures: they aren't assuming the world is better somewhere else or that they can escape what's going on. Maybe that puts 'em back in the adventure category instead of moving for political reasons? (That being said, the demographics between actual expats and would-be expats could be radically different). Note for the curious: I moved abroad for adventure, not political reasons. Five countries and counting. TL;DR: Young people in the US are waking up from all of the bad news and wondering what it would be like to live somewhere else, but they think they don't have the money to leave the US.
- grecy 14y agoreddit.com/r/igotout
- RougeFemme 14y agoI would think the a big reason that 18 to 24-year olds are willing to consider moving abroad is the lousy job market since 2007 - due to a variety of reasons, not the least of which was the financial "crisis".
- ajtaylor 14y ago
- belorn 14y agoThis make sense. They initially only had bank data from EU, since that was an easier political target to go at. That meant that the first step went through without any issues, so they can now go and expand the scope. It doesn't make it right, but it follow some well known roads in how database systems over people get created.
- adolph 14y agoIt would be nice if they had an API to show me if I am overpaying for auto insurance or if another bank has better interest rates. Probably Intuit would lobby against it...
- janlukacs 14y agoGuilty until proven innocent. Why not, the state should do whatever it takes to protect you, right? :) Having lived as a kid in a communist state in eastern europe i'm starting to think people in the US got so politically "lazy" that they are starting to forget what freedom means.
- kunai 14y ago> i'm starting to think people in the US got so politically "lazy" that they are starting to forget what freedom means. This. A thousand times this. You nailed it. People here don't give a damn about freedom. They don't care if it keeps getting taken away, because their lives aren't affected directly. When it starts, though, they'll get up in arms about it. It's no use, though. The government isn't going to change unless people do something right now. Waiting until a government actively takes rights away from you to protest is irresponsible, to say the least. Part of this problem stems from the horrendously broken public school system. Kids are not taught to think for themselves, rather, herd mentality is not only the norm, but it is encouraged! Why do you think so many people vote consistently Democratic or consistently Republican rather than independently? Why do you think half of the country still believes that there's a (supposedly "loving") giant bearded man in the sky deciding whether people should suffer eternally or be on cloud nine? "A government big enough to give you everything you want is big enough to take away everything you have."
- kiba 14y agoThis. A thousand times this. You nailed it. People here don't give a damn about freedom. They don't care if it keeps getting taken away, because their lives aren't affected directly. When it starts, though, they'll get up in arms about it. People do care about freedom. There are a lot of folks who love the 2nd amendment. They just need to care more for the other amendments instead of just the 2nd amendment. Part of this problem stems from the horrendously broken public school system. Kids are not taught to think for themselves, rather, herd mentality is not only the norm, but it is encouraged! Why do you think so many people vote consistently Democratic or consistently Republican rather than independently? Why do you think half of the country still believes that there's a (supposedly "loving") giant bearded man in the sky deciding whether people should suffer eternally or be on cloud nine? Why do you think you have critical thinking skills?
- xradionut 14y agoIt's probably already being done covertly. I assume anything done on the internet or the normal banking/financial/credit system is subject to capture. Combine that with all the social media and other government agency , and you could build a reasonable compete profile on any individual participating.
- polarix 14y agoBuy bitcoins now.
- mindslight 14y agoWhy? So you unambiguously know that all your transactions are reported and data mined? sigh.
- kunai 14y agoA comment posted on the original article: "It’s time to Investigate all Activities from The GOP and Tea Party and Wealthy ,Because They are The Real Terrorist Americans Citizens,For That Reason they are scare to the drones.The History from the wealthy in this country is not Very clean ,For That Reason The FBI has to Investigate This People.They Want Shut Down The Federal Government." These people are the problem. There needs to be an IQ and political education test before people can register to vote. Sound crazy? Yes. Extreme? Yes? Will it work? Maybe; probably not. Is it worth a shot? At the rate things are going, I'd say definitely. By the way, expect a posting about this on rms' blog way before anybody else heard about it. EDIT: Found another politically uneducated comment: "You need to replace every mention of CIA with obama. HE is the one behind this crime and HE is the one 'in direct contradiction to their oath and the 4th Amendment.'" My goodness. EDIT: Interesting that people seem to think the only choice is blue or red. Ever heard of the Libertarian Party? "@sjfella, seriously man, do you think Romney with his neo-con Bush advisers would have done any better with respect to maintaining of civil liberties while still hunting down terrorists? IMO, it would have been much worse under a Romney administration, we probably would have never even heard of this and they would still be doing it. The right and the neo-cons are the ones that want to throw out all our values just to fight the ‘war on terror’, hence things like the Patriot Act and Gitmo."
- icki 14y ago>There needs to be an IQ and political education test before people can register to vote. Would you care to expand upon this argument? What sort of test would you require, and how would such policy effect American democracy?
- kunai 14y agoWhen you have to get a job, you can't simply get an interview with a blank resume. If you want to take the MCAT, you can't just walk in to the exam hall with zero medical knowledge. Why shouldn't the same go for voting? Education is paramount for a good democracy. If the national education system doesn't work, even fixing it is futile because there are already so many indoctrinated and uneducated voters in the population. The best option is to weed out the uneducated ones from the educated ones. The political education test would be similar to a test you take for naturalization: it quizzes you on the party system, how the nation was founded, what the Bill of Rights specifies, et al. Right now the only qualification to vote is citizenship. That needs to be changed.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoNO, NO, NO! This is like CCTV footage or GPS records. Its either mine and just mine, or it is freely available to everyone for everyone. A camera that overlooks a park and is freely streaming to the web is a social benefit, allowing mothers to check the park before taking children down, and so on. A camera overlooking the same park and is only streamed to the CIA is a tool of an oppressive state. Lets keep the free society, it has done us well for 200 years
- smackay 14y ago200 hundred years is such a short time in terms of human history. A blink of an eye and it was gone.
- rayiner 14y agoThis doesn't extend to financial transactions generally, just ones flagged by banks as "suspicious." "Financial institutions that operate in the United States are required by law to file reports of "suspicious customer activity," such as large money transfers or unusually structured bank accounts, to Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN)." I find it a little bit hyperbolic that people are calling the end of the republic at the proposal that intelligence agencies have broader access to financial records they already have access to anyway--financial records that only cover certain kinds of suspicious transactions.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAhhhhhh thank you So, if for example, HSBC is helping drug money launderers to move money around for years, and never flagging it as suspicious (they are regular customers) then the CIA does not get the SP. Ah well, nothing to see here. My apologies for the earlier rant
- rayiner 14y agoYes, this model, like any other system in existence, has failure modes in situations where the banks are in on it.
- nekojima 14y agoFrom what I understand of the case, the cash was smuggled from the US to Mexico and deposited into accounts with HSBC based in Mexico. Consumer goods were then purchased in Mexico and shipped to Colombia and elsewhere (but not the US). While there should have been a lot more local oversight for money laundering, why should US government agencies have access to bank accounts in Mexico to determine if there has been money laundering activities? This is a local matter, as it is in other jurisdictions, and the US can formally complain through the established channels, treaties, and agencies which allow for sanctions to be placed on banks and jurisdictions where there is excessive money laundering activities and low oversight.
- nwzpaperman 14y ago
- sliverstorm 14y agoI was surprised- haven't agencies been using finance information to track and bring down big criminals for decades? This explains it: The Federal Bureau of Investigation already has full access to the database. However, intelligence agencies, such as the Central Intelligence Agency and the National Security Agency, currently have to make case-by-case requests for information to FinCEN.
- danenania 14y agoYou know what maximizes the effectiveness of law enforcement? A totalitarian society. Consider this every time you hear about a new power grab that is justified by 'it will help us catch the bad guys'.
- gnosis 14y agoIt must be nice to have finances.
- gambiting 14y agoWhen I was a kid I always hoped to emigrate to America one day. Such a great country. Now I think I would not want to become a US citizen even if I was getting paid for it.
- SageRaven 14y agoTime for everyone to order teddy bears, propane bottles, and a copy of the Quran from Amazon whenever they book a plane ticket. Bring back the "spook fodder" concept from the heydays of USENET.