4 ms·
Quantum setback for warp drives
- grinich 18y agoI don't understand how Hawking radiation is significant. It's far less than the cosmic background radiation everywhere in the universe. (This is why we can't "see" black holes.)
- jerf 18y agoThis is something like standing on Pluto and saying you don't see what's so bright about the sun. Why not come stand on the surface of the sun and then make up your own mind? Hawking radiation is not intrinsically weak. Hawking radiation as generated by a large blackhole is weak. Flashlights are not weak; flashlights as powered by my nearly dead batteries are weak. With a different spacetime configuration you can get arbitrarily strong Hawking radiation, just like you can get arbitrarily strong light using more power. Hawking radiation around a very small black hole tears it apart relatively quickly. The Universe does not seem to like playing games like this and it tends to wipe out any structure that permits causality violation (as any FTL drive would) in an unsurvivable blaze of either Hawking-radiation or in an explosion of the vacuum energy (see Hawking's work on what would happen if you towed a wormhole around enough at relativistic speeds to cause a causality violation). And by "unsurvivable", I don't mean "probably fatal to life but we might be able to engineer around it". I mean, "unsurvivable to the space-time structure in question"; whatever mass or energy happens to get in the way is orders of magnitude away from even affecting the outcome, let alone standing a chance of survival.
- grinich 18y agoThanks for the great reply! I guess I'd only read about Hawking radiation with respect to black holes, and never considered its implications on a larger scale. Sounds like it has larger implications than I thought. Were you citing a specific paper by Hawking (towing a wormhole)? I'd like to read more.
- thwarted 18y agoI haven't read the Hawking paper in question specifically, but the idea of towing a worm hole around is that you move one end of a worm hole for some period of time at relativistic speeds. Since as you approach c, time slows down, so the stationary end of the worm hole is further in the future than the one that was moved around. It's a pretty stock layman's example of how time travel could be possible and I'm sure Hawking has torn a, er, hole in it some how.
- jimfl 18y agoIf the bubble is unstable then it probably just needs constant modulation, meaning the FTL ship is flown more like a helicopter than a rocket ship. That makes it more maneuverable.
- geuis 18y agoYeah let's get to the point where it's technically possible to build one. This is exactly like preminent scientists in 1903 publishing papers about how powered flight was impossible.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThis just in: Quantum mechanics and relativity don't get along. Film at 11 <<yawn>>
- jerf 18y agoSo, previously, if you applied an impossible amount of impossibly-stable negative mass in an impossible configuration that was impossible to maintain due to impossible-to-predict interactions with the interstellar medium and goosed it in an impossible manner you might have been able to move faster than light. Now some guys have revealed that it's also impossible due to quantum effects. Frankly, that's just one more "impossible" in a rich sea of impossible assumptions to make this style of warp drive work. As I like to say, once you accept one impossibility into your theory, the fact that impossible results occur is not fundamentally interesting. People who babble about how people thought that traveling faster than sound was impossible and who are we to say this is actually impossible need to spend more time with real relativity and not Star Trek "wishing is an acceptable substitute for engineering" relativity. People who think that the Alcubierre drive was ever actually possible betray a profound misunderstanding of both the drive and relativity, in their zeal to get to the results they want instead of the reality they have. If FTL is possible, it won't be as a result of QM or relativity. It might come from the eventual fusion, but a deeper understanding of relativity shows that you're still facing a steep uphill battle. The thing that you come to understand if you actually understand relativity is that it is not merely that FTL travel is "impossible" because c is some "cosmic speed limit". c is not the cosmic speed limit. c is the number that indicates the relationship between space and time in the Minkowsky metric. c comes from the literal shape of the universe, which is not the Euclidean one you think it is. Travelling "faster than c" is not merely breaking the 55mph speed limit on your local road, it is fundamentally a undefined, gibberish statement in relativity. Everything outside of your lightcone is profoundly indistinguishable from anything else outside of your lightcone. The deepest discussion of relativity I know of that is freely online: http://www.mathpages.com/rr/rrtoc.htm http://www.mathpages.com/rr/rrtoc.htm