4 ms·
Medicare has to do business with US providers, so of course it's still going to be more expensive than in a civilized country. According to your numbers, the ta
by wtallis 14y ago
Medicare has to do business with US providers, so of course it's still going to be more expensive than in a civilized country. According to your numbers, the tax burden relative to the level of service is at most about 12 times worse than other countries, though the fact that Medicare covers the people who most need expensive care means it's actually much closer to international costs. It's certainly effective in that it does provide a lot of care for a lot of people, and it's about as efficient as it can be without completely revamping the supply chain it depends on.
- bradleyjg 14y agoThere is a healthcare system in the United States that does far better -- the Veterns Administration. So clearly it is not impossible. Even leaving aside government provisioned care, there are several simple ways Medicare could use its massive purchasing power to control costs. Part A could take into account alternate available treatments and their effectiveness-adjusted-cost when determining what procedures to cover. Part B could coordinate care through a single gatekeeper physician. Part C could be eliminated, as it was a cost saving experiment that failed. Finally, Part D could negotiate with drug providers on behalf of the entire pool instead of delegating negotiation to dozens of insurance companies, each with smaller pools.
- wtallis 14y agoThe VA does a better job because they actually run their own hospitals and clinics. That makes a huge difference - they can directly control many of the costs, and can wield their negotiating power far more effectively than Medicare is currently allowed to.
- bradleyjg 14y agoI certainly agree that much of the blame for Medicare not being better than it is lies with Congress, which seems to be the upshot of your comment.