3 ms·
People diagnosed with cancer are obviously more likely to die of cancer, since cancer is never cured, and everyone must die of something. What matters is how lo
by snowwrestler 14y ago
People diagnosed with cancer are obviously more likely to die of cancer, since cancer is never cured, and everyone must die of something. What matters is how long they live with their cancer. That is why survival rates are a better measure of cancer treatment efficacy than mortality rates.
- lostlogin 14y agoCancer is never cured? An early find of some cancers will have you living longer, due to increased awareness and vigilance. And why is survival a better measure than mortality? 2 sides of the same coin?
- rbehrends 14y agoThe problem with that is that cancer survival rates are measured from the time of diagnosis, not from the time the cancer presumably began (because that's often difficult to tell). And even with identical treatment efficacy, cancer that is diagnosed early will have a higher five-year survival rate than one that is diagnosed later. In short, we're lacking good data at the national level to measure what you'd like to measure; and we do have studies (e.g., the one in the first link I gave you) that at the very least cast doubt on the belief that an aggressive cancer screening schedule reduces cancer-related or all-cause mortality. As Robin Hanson puts it: "While cancer screening does consistently lead to more cancer detection and more cancer treatment, it consistently doesn’t lead to lower mortality."
- snowwrestler 14y agoThere won't be identical treatment efficacy, because cancer treatments work better the earlier they are started. Early diagnosis is not a data problem, it is an inherent part of why the U.S. gets good results fighting cancer.