6 ms·
> I guess I'm not seeing where the government enters the picture here. Government half-assed it. How? By providing neither complete liberalization and deregula
by rdtsc 14y ago
> I guess I'm not seeing where the government enters the picture here.
Government half-assed it. How? By providing neither complete liberalization and deregulation (a libertarian dream I hear often -- why can't my health insurance be like my car insurance...etc..etc), nor fixing prices (a la Japan) or providing free a healthcare alternative.
It is the worse of both worlds it seems. All of the recent health care reforms are pretty much bullshit from what I can see if they dropped the single payer option. Without controlling the costs. Yeah I can insure my 26 year old children but my premiums have gone up 30%+ in last 2 years. It is like they are trying to plug holes in a hunk of Swiss cheese. "But we'll mandate them to give free preventive care checkups, we got them now! Everyone cheers. HMOs turns around, laugh and raise premiums by 30%.
- tptacek 14y agoIt feels like, at least until guaranteed issue kicks in, the government has no-assed this problem, except for Medicare, which is by many accounts tremendously efficient and effective.
- rdtsc 14y agoThey are heavily regulating it. If you ask some people they would say "everything is screwed up because govt is regulating it" others say "everything is screwed up because they are not involved enough with it". I lean towards the latter, but I can buy the argument from the other side as well perhaps.
- kalleboo 14y agoWhen there's a battle of opinions between "they're regulating too much" and "they're regulating to little", my presumption is the actual answer is "they're regulating it in the wrong way".
- bradleyjg 14y agoI fail to see how Medicare can be considered effective and efficient when it costs about as much per capita as what other countries pay to cover everyone, it covers less than 1/6 of the population, and only covers about half the total health care costs of the covered population. It may be better than the private US healthcare system, but that's not saying much.
- wtallis 14y agoMedicare has to do business with US providers, so of course it's still going to be more expensive than in a civilized country. According to your numbers, the tax burden relative to the level of service is at most about 12 times worse than other countries, though the fact that Medicare covers the people who most need expensive care means it's actually much closer to international costs. It's certainly effective in that it does provide a lot of care for a lot of people, and it's about as efficient as it can be without completely revamping the supply chain it depends on.
- bradleyjg 14y agoThere is a healthcare system in the United States that does far better -- the Veterns Administration. So clearly it is not impossible. Even leaving aside government provisioned care, there are several simple ways Medicare could use its massive purchasing power to control costs. Part A could take into account alternate available treatments and their effectiveness-adjusted-cost when determining what procedures to cover. Part B could coordinate care through a single gatekeeper physician. Part C could be eliminated, as it was a cost saving experiment that failed. Finally, Part D could negotiate with drug providers on behalf of the entire pool instead of delegating negotiation to dozens of insurance companies, each with smaller pools.
- wtallis 14y agoThe VA does a better job because they actually run their own hospitals and clinics. That makes a huge difference - they can directly control many of the costs, and can wield their negotiating power far more effectively than Medicare is currently allowed to.
- bradleyjg 14y agoI certainly agree that much of the blame for Medicare not being better than it is lies with Congress, which seems to be the upshot of your comment.
- 14y ago
- snowwrestler 14y agoThe efficiency of Medicare is often overstated. Medicare spends a lot per patient, which makes administrative costs a smaller percentage of total spending. And some administrative tasks are handled by other government agencies, but many calculations of Medicare efficiency don't include those.
- twoodfin 14y agoAdditionally, there's a not insubstantial chunk of Medicare spending that's essentially fraudulent, and that no "real" insurance company would pay, but Medicare lacks the "overhead" to do much about all but the most egregious cases. Why else did you think there were so many daytime TV ads for "free" scooters before Medicare cracked down? And that's just one example.
- rayiner 14y agoYou didn't really answer his question. What exactly is the government doing? I haven't really studied the issue deeply myself, but the usual complaint I hear is about things like selling insurance across state lines. But I'm not clear on how 15 or 25 or 40 (IL, TX, CA, respectively) isn't a big enough population to capture most of the efficiencies of scale that are there to be captured.
- caw 14y agoOne of the arguments for shopping across state lines is changing the risk profile. There are certain conditions that are more prevalent in certain states or regions (e.g. obesity in the "deep south"). Another argument is that states individually mandate what should be covered under insurance. If you can buy from another state, then you can get (cheaper?) insurance such that you're not paying for things that aren't relevant to you.
- tptacek 14y agoThe reality is that shopping across states will result in the least-regulated states hosting the dominant providers; it creates a race to the bottom.
- AlexeiSadeski 14y agoYou mean a race to the top :)
- twoodfin 14y agoAnd the more regulated providers will have no way to sell their added oversight as a benefit worth paying for? That doesn't seem plausible: Certainly PPO's were able to sell "see a specialist without a referral" to many group plan customers.
- waylonk 14y agoI live in New Zealand, and the system is neither completely liberalized, or deregulated, and works fine. There is a public healthcare system that is paid for by taxes. The quality is really good generally, though rationalisation does happen with time, so we have quite big waiting lists. However, there is also a private medical system that you're free to use. The largest one is actually a non-for-profit insurance society, and they run a chain of hospitals as well. If the public system is overloaded, sometimes Health Boards (government) will pay private hospitals to do operations. Either way, medical insurance is really cheap, optional, and healthcare is seen as a right between the government and the citizen, not some weird relationship with an employer. Move to New Zealand?
- rdtsc 14y ago> There is a public healthcare system that is paid for by taxes. I wouldn't call that "liberal" and "deregulated". At least no according to US political-speak. Providing a free alternative and thus competing with the health insurance companies is a pretty obvious involvement in the health care by the government. That is a sane option and I like it. We have enough regulation and involvement but it just stops short of actually offering a viable free alternative. So the government sticks its fingers in the pie and makes a mess then the health insurance companies do the same and in the end the citizens get screwed.
- lostlogin 14y agoSouthern Cross health care - not for profit, but I wonder what it's executives earn? It isn't a feel good organisation at any stretch, and the beady eye of the government has reached out in the past due to some unethical practices they have. Preferred providers etc - keeping the money within its hospitals more like it. I might be cynical, but I've observed them working within the private healthcare sector and it isn't pretty.
- lancewiggs 14y agoDirectors were paid $48,000 and the chairman $80,000. The CE and senior executives earned a total if $2.7m between them all. All FY 2012. And all very reasonable https://www.southerncross.co.nz/Portals/0/Group/Corporate/2012%20SCMCS%20Annual%20Report.pdf https://www.southerncross.co.nz/Portals/0/Group/Corporate/20...