5 ms·
Most important British innovation, heck, a case can be made that it is the single most important human innovation ever made. It hugely impacted everything from
by jerf 14y ago
Most important British innovation, heck, a case can be made that it is the single most important human innovation ever made. It hugely impacted everything from the purest of mathematics to the most mundane of modern practical concerns. As always, he stood on the shoulder of giants, of course, but he saw further.
- SeanDav 14y agoDon't agree here. You have to set a category, unless you are claiming that the Turing Universal Machine is a greater invention than the transistor, or penicillin or the wheel or fire or writing etc etc.
- jlgreco 14y agoI'd say it is more important than all of those, save writing. Both writing and the idea of mechanical computation represent fundamental leaps in human development. They change what we are, not just the comfort in which we live.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoRight. Penicillin was important, but there are other antibiotics. The transistor was also important, but there are alternatives that might have been used (e.g. techniques based on optics). The theory of computation is absolutely fundamental.
- SeanDav 14y agoCharles Babbage had a working computer long before Turin. If he could have implemented it in transistors or even valves rather than mechanical relays how much further would we have been today? The way I see it, you don't need to understand the theory of computation to solve probably any problem that is solvable via computation. Given, it would be potentially far less efficient but not fundamental.
- jlgreco 14y agoWithout the common mathematical language necessary to reason and talk about computation in the general case, and Babbage-linage programmers would have been at a severe disadvantage. The fact that general purpose computers only got a resurgence decades later, well after the period of time that the hardware and resources would have supported the construction of a general purpose computer, demonstrates the necessity of the concept. Could Babbage have created the analytical machine without the theory of computation? Sure. And Hero of Alexandria built a steam engine. Sometimes, the mere ability to create a device is not sufficient. You need the ability to step back and realize the profound nature of what you have just done, and the ability to create a language with which to communicate this realization to the world. Babbage and Ada only managed but a fraction of that, and I do not believe that completing a physical prototype was some sort of last missing piece in the puzzle. If you want someone other than Turing to point the finger at, then Claude Shannon is next in line waaay before Babbage. (also, it is not my understanding that the analytical engine was to be an electromechanical relay machine. do you have a source for that?)
- mich41 14y agoWithout the common mathematical language necessary to reason and talk about computation in the general case, and Babbage-linage programmers would have been at a severe disadvantage. Not sure about that. The Analytical Engine was capable of arithmetics and conditional branching. Code and input data were to be read from punched cards. Such machine was quite practical and if Babbage managed to build it, it would immediately get used for some number crunching - scientists and businesses would love a calculator which can autonomously eat streams of data and perform boring computations on them. Babbage and Lovelace were aware that AE can be used to process numerically encoded non-numeric data, so it would also find uses in text processing. Sooner or later somebody would invent Fortran and COBOL (after all, early compilers were pretty much string rewriters) and we would be headed to land in same place we actually did. Only CS PhDs would waste their time on attempts to algorithmically solve the halting problem instead of "wasting" it on the P=NP debate.
- 14y ago