3 ms·
> Once we have a tax code that's simple enough and a government that's competent enough to get think right How do you foresee this happening if we -- the gover
by danso 14y ago
> Once we have a tax code that's simple enough and a government that's competent enough to get think right
How do you foresee this happening if we -- the government and the public -- maintain a status quo in which feasible optimizations are never pursued because hey, we have a private alternative that doesn't charge too much to do it?
For the government to become more competent, the people have to demand reform. For people to demand reform, they have to be aware of how much better things could be. Private competition helps spur that reform, but this doesn't mean that the government shouldn't itself be expected to optimize things. This is not an either-or zero sum game
- gyardley 14y agoI'm arguing that without these prerequisites, this 'optimization' isn't an optimization at all - it'll be a step backwards, because it'll just end up ripping people off. People certainly should demand reform, but not this particular reform at this particular time. People should absolutely demand a simpler tax code - I don't know about you, but I'm still holding out hope we'll see some tax reform in 2013. 'Competent government' is a harder problem. Americans aren't Norwegians or Germans, and simply aren't good at large bureaucracy. Unless America starts subcontracting out its administration to the Swedes, better government is going to take either a change in American character or something smaller and less-centralized.
- danso 14y ago> Americans aren't Norwegians or Germans, and simply aren't good at large bureaucracy. Unless America starts subcontracting out its administration to the Swedes, better government is going to take either a change in American character or something smaller and less-centralized. This is a strange assertion, as if Swedes had an innate gene that allowed them to be more adept when they joined public service. Let's assume that that's not true and it's an ability learned through environment and civic education...I'm arguing that that reaching this ideal situation of "good character" will require -- when it is possible -- to make interaction with the government more efficient. Else, you may end up in a situation in which citizens are so distrustful of the government that they never see the point of achieving good civic character. And then we never end up being as good as the Germans and the Swedes.