7 ms·
This seems mighty kneejerk-y. A duplicaton issue causes your contacts to disappear, therefore you should move your contacts and calendar away from a service tha
by Karunamon 14y ago
This seems mighty kneejerk-y. A duplicaton issue causes your contacts to disappear, therefore you should move your contacts and calendar away from a service that probably has better engineers, better backup, better redundancy, and better uptime than any one of us could possibly muster, and onto a somewhat immature product with worse functionality and integration which is by no means immune to the same kind of problem?
Yeah.. see, I don't think the author has thought their cunning plan all the way through.
I understand the anti-google sentiment is at an all time high after the Reader shutdown fiasco, but let's stay rational, here!
- mikeratcliffe 14y agoNo, the loss of contacts happened for the first time about 3 years ago and has repeated roughly every 6 months. I don't understand why you think that Google have a better backup service than I can provide myself. I could backup my DB once per hour if I wanted. I am not anti Google but if a better service can be run from my own server then of course I will use it.
- dudus 14y agoSo you think your hard drive is more reliable than a Google Data Center?
- nathanb 14y agoNo, but I suspect I care more deeply about my own data than Google do.
- haakon 14y agoI'm sure Google quite loves your data.
- nathanb 14y agoBut if they lose it, do they care? It's one drop in the bucket of their analytics. The incentives I have to preserve my data are greater than the incentives they have. On their side, they have some very bright minds and some very deep pockets, as well as a proven infrastructure. But if they lose my data, they lose some analytics which may cost them pennies or perhaps dollars of ad revenue. On my side, I have myself and whatever advice I can cobble together from friends and the Internet, a reasonable salary, and the occasional hour or two of spare time. But if I lose my data, I lose over a decade of accumulated emails and contact information. I will gladly allow Google to back up my data (I use gmail to archive my call logs and SMS messages right now, in fact!), but I would rather be in control of the primary copy myself.
- koenigdavidmj 14y ago> The incentives I have to preserve my data are greater than the incentives they have. If you lose your data, you lose your data. If Google loses your data, they probably lost that of others too, and they make the evening news.
- nathanb 14y agoApparently not, since they've been losing OPs contacts for years (assuming the article is correct) and haven't made the news about it yet.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hp50g 14y agoI've run my own mail server since I got my first permanent connection in 1995. It's not hard to keep it up and reliable, especially on a small scale. It's not much harder to keep a large one up (I designed and operated a huge qmail hub in the late 90's). Everything is on hard drives just as it is at google and all the other providers. I don't use rack and data center distribution for redundancy or even RAID to be honest. However I do have a DLT and a fire safe (which acts as an anti-theft device as it weighs 200Kg) :) What I'm saying is there are varying grades of redundancy, backup and reliability. It might be good enough, or might give more confidence than the disclaimers Google offer.
- reeses 14y agoAs for functionality, Maildir with your MDA of choice gives you all kinds of rube-goldberg opportunities with text files. No silly "max connections" junk when your phone and your laptop hit IMAP at the same time. The one thing I really liked when going from procmail/postfix/dovecot to Google Apps was spam filtering. I hated keeping up to date with the various new methods spammers discovered to offer me good times with farm animals. Today, I get a lot of false positives, especially with the "this is spam because other people marked messages like this as spam" emails from my bank. I miss emails from family members, travel vendors, and even online shipment confirmation messages. I've had to create rules to catch them and move them to folders/labels as well as have a client-side process occasionally search for a whitelist and "rescue" the messages.
- hp50g 14y agoI use postfix+Maildir. I never get spam. I rarely give out my address and if i do, its usually an alias unless i really trust the person. Spam? Delete the alias and get the fucker blacklisted as it deterministically points to the culprit. I use usenet via eternal-September.org eith an alias and some junk in the address. Has worked fine for years now.
- bhauer 14y agoI only skimmed the article. But I agree with your worry that this looks to be instructions that could put anyone who follows them at even higher risk of pain. The aesthetic of the web site doesn't give me a warm and fuzzy feeling about the quality of the tools being promoted. That said, I suspect a key point the author would make in response to our concern is that we can vigorously backup the server hosting our contacts and calendar when we host these ourselves. In fact, this point is precisely why I host so much of my own stuff: I can manage how data is handled. Synchronization notoriously sucks, and if some synchronization failure causes many records to suddenly vanish, it would be easier to restore those records from a self-maintained server than to plead with Google's support. I wouldn't know the first thing about recovering synchronization-scrubbed records from the devices themselves (e.g., an Android phone). I suppose it would attack your point about "better backup" by asking what value that backup has if you can't easily leverage it to restore on demand. Still, I feel your points about quality, redundancy, and uptime could not be easily countered.
- joering2 14y ago> The aesthetic of the web site doesn't give me a warm and fuzzy feeling about the quality of the tools being promoted. Have you ever fired any of Oracle Corp setup/installers?
- bhauer 14y agoTouché. Those are awful. I'd say Oracle should be ashamed, but I'm sure Larry Ellison is feeling really bad about himself in between counting stacks of money.
- hnriot 14y agoOracle installers aren't meant to be pretty, but rather practical, they are run mostly by IT professions who know what they are doing. Remember an Enterprise solution has to conform to ADA in 57 different countries and be fully translated, must work on version current-15, must work on lynx, IE5, csh, bash, ksh, windows 31, osx and vms :) your convenience is pretty low on their priority list...
- psweber 14y agoThe idea doesn't make sense for most, but it's a nice, simple set of instructions if you wanted to do it.
- hp50g 14y agoI agree about moving contacts and calendar off Google myself. To be honest, if it's not actually somewhere you control, it's not yours. At least if you host or manage it yourself, you are only at the mercy of your own incompetence, whereas the cloud's competence is usually not something you can determine or anticipate regardless of SLA's and architecture. This gets demonstrated regularly if you watch the front page of this site :) I still use text files, a VCS and a couple of editor wrapper scripts as I have for at least 20 years to solve the calendar and contacts problem.
- spinchange 14y agoWhat about Google shutting down the open standard for syncing contact and calendar data across platforms? I don't ask this as a form of "anti-Google sentiment," but as a legitimate question. The announcement that they would be phasing out ActiveSync support at the end of last year coupled with the announcement just made that they were doing the same for CalDAV/CardDav (when they announced the end of Reader) indicate they're "silo-ing" the service somewhat. Unless I've missed something, it's still not clear that iOS/iCal calendars are going to sync with Google's unless they "whitelist" Apple. It's not a "cunning plan," it's self-preservation and keeping your stuff working or at the least not being at the mercy of a commercial concern who demonstrates a willingness to break it even for paying customers.
- asdfaoeu 14y agoJust move it when/if they shutdown the service? It's not like they are going to suddenly shutdown the service or remove your ability to export contacts.
- Karunamon 14y ago>It's not a "cunning plan," it's self-preservation Fair enough, and I can see the value in keeping a local backup just for redundancy and convenience purposes (being locked out of my Google account for whatever reason would suck), but using it as your daily driver? Ehhhhhhh.... As far as shutdown fears, though? Calendar, Contacts, and Gmail are the core-est of the core products. They're tied directly into the Android ecosystem as well. Reader was more or less a niche product. Google isn't going to shut down any of the holy three applications which make up the entire backbone of their mobile OS's PIM functionality. Any such fears are completely irrational.
- spinchange 14y agoI didn't say anything about them shutting down the services, I said they were "silo-ing" them and clearly moving away from having them interoperate with 3rd party software. It is not at all irrational to worry for how long your enterprise users' contacts and calendars will continue to sync. They've thrown us a lifeline for the time being and even appear to be working on a fix for Outlook 2013 so it will sync (it doesn't as of right now), but the whole process of sunsetting support for ActiveSync then CalDAV completely tips their hand that they want to control who and what interoperates with it - and for how much longer it will interoperate with platforms beside their own Android core PIM suite =| the entire mobile and desktop universe. There are people paying for Google's enterprise apps offering that don't use Android. What is in question is for how long core services of those apps will work outside of a browser/Android device.
- leephillips 14y agoAt least it will probably prevent Google-caused privacy disasters like this from happening: http://lee-phillips.org/gcaldisaster/ http://lee-phillips.org/gcaldisaster/
- lelandbatey 14y agoI agree with your sentiment: Honestly, is there anything that matches Google search quality of services? Is there any email hosting, paid or not, that is as feature rich as Gmail? What about online documents? Calendars and contacts? What about all the other little things I get, like Gtalk or Google hangouts? Honestly, if there was any alternative that covered all of these with the quality of Googles services, I'd switch in a heartbeat, even if I had to pay $30+ a month for them all. Actually, if anyone has recommendations, I'd love to hear them!
- rayiner 14y agoBing isn't as good as google yet, but its reached the threshold of good enough. Hosted Exchange email is very feature rich. I pay outlook.com 5 per month and get wonderful integration with all my devices for calander, contacts, and ToDo. Gtalk is hard to replace because your friends use it. I use apples messages and it works fine with people on gtalk. For my core functioms, outlook.com is head and shoulders better. People have probably just gotten used to how utter shit the gmail UI has become, but outlook.com is refreshingly well designed (the web client). And activesync support is of course killer.
- jackalope 14y agoData corruption is unforgivable. My bank might have have better accountants, stronger safes, great hours, terrific customer service and round-the-clock security, but you can bet that if they randomly lost my money on a regular basis (or even once?) that I'd withdraw it and stuff it in my mattress until I found a better alternative.