5 ms·
Chinese Develop "Kill Weapon" targetting Aircraft Carriers
- gaoshan 18y agoA "kill" weapon? What, as opposed to a "happy" weapon?
- endtime 18y agoI agree that it's a stupid name, but there are nonlethal weapons (e.g. tasers, rubber bullets, etc.).
- redcap 18y agoI believe it's military lingo for a device (missile) that can completely take out some hardware (in this case a massive ship) and 'kill' it. This is a game-changer for the US Navy, and likely other military organisations too.
- endtime 18y agoI don't know a ton about China, but unless it's just the tone of the article this missile seems very highly targeted at the US Navy (I think we're much more carrier-heavy than other navies; feel free to correct me if I'm wrong). Does the Chinese government/military have the mindset that they are likely to go to war with the US? Seems kind of unrealistic to me. Maybe they are thinking about how to keep the US out of the picture if they were to invade Taiwan? Not that I think the US would intervene anyway... I'm sure someone here knows much more about China than I do - what am I missing?
- redcap 18y agoThe US is a perceived military adversary as far as Taiwan, and to a lesser extent, southeast Asia is concerned. I really do think (hope) that the chance of all-out war is unlikely, but military orgs prepare for all circumstances. There may be a perception gap on the part of Chinese military hawks as to what the US aim is - they feel pent-in/threatened, and they're responding. This is a great country who has had a recent history of being a whipping boy (Europe in the 19th century, Japan in the early 20th) - only in recent years is China starting to regain its 'rightful' place in the world.
- endtime 18y agoThat makes sense. From where I stand (US civilian) war with China seems hyperbolically unlikely. But I guess the Chinese military might not see things as I do.
- chaostheory 18y ago"a recent history of being a whipping boy" This is really what Taiwan is about, a constant reminder of China's past humiliation; it's a big emotional issue for the Chinese. I feel that this is the driving force for everything that China has done recently yeah I agree though that war for Taiwan is unlikely, since China's real invasion of Taiwan already started years ago. It's just too lucrative for Taiwanese manufacturing businesses to set up shop in China, and they've already been migrating to China en-mass years ago. Add to that Chinese laws forcing many of these Taiwanese businesses to have a cap as to how much money they can transfer outside of China (specifically back to Taiwan) and then you can see the long term problem for Taiwan...
- Rod 18y agoAssuming that China does have the weapon described in the article, that does not mean that China is getting ready to go to war with the United States. It could simply mean that China is looking for conventional weapons for deterrence purposes. Nothing would freak the U.S. Navy out more than losing carriers. No carriers equals no airpower, equals a bunch of vulnerable ships and submarines.
- tokenadult 18y agoChina prepares for war against the United States as the obvious power in its region of greatest interest. Maybe the two countries will get along fine. But, to give an example, some people in Japan and some in the United States anticipated the war that didn't start until 1941 ever since the 1890s.
- ixnu 18y agoIt's the Too Big to Fail principle in military terms. The projection of force is greatly reduced when the fear of losing an asset determines its domain. A carrier that has to stay 2000 km from the action puts a tremendous strain every aspect of operations.
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoA carrier that has to stay 2000 km away from the action is completely useless. Carriers are designed for one thing: tactical air support. Can't do that from 2000km.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- falsestprophet 18y agoCarriers were designed for many things, but never for action against a serious opponent like China or even Iran. Like much of the US military, the carriers were meant to bully weak Soviet satellite states. Today they are used to bully weak states of all persuasions.
- mnemonicsloth 18y agoThat must be why it took four years to defeat the Japanese. If the US Navy had been really serious, instead of mucking around with fleets of aircraft carriers...
- falsestprophet 18y agoIt is probably a mistake to plan for future wars in the model of a war 70 years in the past. Surface fleets were rendered obsolete around the 1960s when anti-ship missiles matured. Things change, 70 years before the aircraft carrier, warships were made of wood and powered by the wind.
- 18y ago
- thras 18y agoSurface ships are just floating targets anyway. Nations like the U.S. and China will go to war with nuclear submarines shooting thermonuclear tipped ICBMs at each other's cities or not at all.
- Rod 18y agoWouldn't that be a bit too dramatic?!? Once you've played the "nuclear card", you have committed suicide, basically. Given that a nuclear war would ensure mutual destruction, wouldn't China and the U.S. be better off fighting with conventional weapons only?
- chancho 18y agoInteresting game. The only winning move is not to play.
- cschneid 18y agoThat's BS. Nuclear War is a great game to play, for all ages (seriously, check it out, it's a fun waste of 30 minutes)
- moe 18y agoWell, better of as in what? From my amateur perspective I just can't see a war scenario that would make sense either way. - Then again, does war ever make sense? In a conventional conflict China would basically put their 4:1 headcount up against the modern US war machinery. And however that turns out, the losing side would probably pull the "tactical" nuclear card at some point...
- jibiki 18y agoBingo. Once we start losing massive numbers of soldiers, launching nuclear weapons starts to seem much more justifiable. Particularly if anyone is convinced that launching first gives us an advantage in the ensuing fallout.
- mynameishere 18y agoOld news. http://www.exile.ru/articles/detail.php?ARTICLE_ID=6779&IBLOCK_ID=35 http://www.exile.ru/articles/detail.php?ARTICLE_ID=6779&...
- redcap 18y agoInteresting article, but I don't see anything in there about a specific Chinese ASBM that can travel at Mach 10. The OP article suggests that the missile can do 2000 km in 12 minutes. To my mind that counts as bluewater as opposed to being off someone's coast. On the flip side, we haven't seen a naval war where low-tech threats have been leveraged to their highest effect.
- redcap 18y agoYou might have wanted this article from Exiled Online which includes details wrt to the new Chinese ASBM: http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carriers-will-die/ http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carrier...
- chaostheory 18y agothis is actually better commentary (somewhat reminds me of raganwald though): http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carriers-will-die/all/1/ http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carrier...
- demallien 18y agoSure, except the author keeps on trying to sound like he has spotted a flaw that the top US brass haven't even thought of yet: "Ships have no defence against ballistic missiles!" Except of course, AEGIS has been under development for years, and is now actually deployed in the field. What's the full name for AEGIS? Oh, that's right, Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense System. It's deployed on what platform? Cruisers... In other words, the author's central point is a load of bollocks, ships do indeed now have a defence against ballistic missiles. Getting back to the main topic, well done to the Chinese if they have indeed managed to implement a high-velocity, low-trajectory heavy missile capable of taking out a carrier. Now the arms race begins. Can the US make an incremental improvement to AEGIS to defend against this new threat? This ties in nicely to yesterday's discussion on HN, kicked off by Gruber's comments on complexity. If the US military had to design a defence system against ballistic missiles from scratch today, there is every reason to think that they'd stuff it up. But instead, they have gradually built up the missile-intercept capability, starting with the relatively simple Nike-Zeus, moving up to systems such as Patriot, and then building on that success to create AEGIS and Ground-based Midcourse Defense systems. Each step is simply an evolution on what has come before, and a defence against this new attack will also just be an evolution on what has come before...
- chaostheory 18y ago"In other words, the author's central point is a load of bollocks, ships do indeed now have a defence against ballistic missiles." I may have read the article differently... I feel that the author has put the emphasis on aircraft carriers being obsolete, and his main point is that the US Navy has a flawed focus of fewer and larger units; instead of building a larger fleet consisting of smaller ships like AEGIS, stealth ships, or other smaller boats. Cruisers != Aircraft Carriers
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- rjprins 18y agoWhat is all this non sense about a war. The US and China are about as far from war as Siamese twins are from schizophrenia! -- I know, it doesn't make any sense at all!! Besides, the strongest weapon China has against the US is economic leverage. If they want, they can almost turn the US in a third-world nation by dumping their dollars.