7 ms·
USPS Discrimination Against Atheism?
- claudius 14y agoThey should make similar experiments with Saudi-Arabia and maybe a few other countries :-)
- mooism2 14y agoBecause discrimination is perfectly fine so long as you're not discriminating as much as somebody more extreme? Of course not. And don't try to wiggle out of it by saying you were only joking. You are still perpetuating the viewpoint.
- claudius 14y agoActually, my idea was that Saudi-Arabia would be less discriminating in this matter, hence displaying the idiocy of such delays even more obviously.
- ethomson 14y agoWhat view point is being perpetuated? I read that pretty literally - that they should, indeed, try this with addresses in Saudi Arabia. Because, you know, it would be interesting. Even if that's not true, I don't think that this is a scientific enough study to suggest that there's serious discrimination problem at the USPS, or where the problem even lies. Does the sender name trigger delays in customs? Does the sender's activity trigger delays in customs and has been flagged for further scrutiny but the name is coincidental?
- DanBC 14y agoThey sent a mix of parcels, some with "ATHEIST" branding and some without it. They claim that the parcels with Atheist tape were delayed. If the problem wasn't with the tape we'd expect to see delays spread across all parcels. > I don't think that this is a scientific enough study I agree. It'd be interesting to see a bigger study with better numbers. 140 parcels is a tiny number compared to what USPS handles per day.
- leephillips 14y ago"140 parcels is a tiny number compared to what USPS handles per day." Why does the size of the sample in relation to the size of the population mean that the numbers need to be better?
- mpyne 14y agoBecause 140 parcels, not randomly selected, is nowhere near enough to meet the various statistical tests needed to draw meaningful conclusions.
- leephillips 14y agoDoes not answer my question. The commenter I was responding to mentioned the size of the population; you refer only to the size of the sample.
- mpyne 14y agoIf the population size is 140 then a "sample" of 140 gives you a complete description. If the population size is 1.4e10 then a non-random sample of 140 is going to give very low confidence. For the topics in between you're going to have to look up Wikipedia pages on statistics to see how sample size and population size relate, how that changes with the methodology used to select your sample, etc. If you know statistics already and you have a point to make then just make it. "20 Questions" might work on Jabber or IRC but it doesn't on a forum like this.
- leephillips 14y ago"If the population size is 140 then a 'sample' of 140 gives you a complete description." That would not be what we think of as a sample, but rather a census. "If the population size is 1.4e10 then a non-random sample of 140 is going to give very low confidence." If the sample is non-random then the conclusions are unreliable, regardless of the population size. I don't understand most of the rest of your comment, except as angry sputtering designed to avoid having to correct yourself. As to my playing 20 questions, since I can not imagine in general how the population size could be relevant to statistical conclusions drawn from a random sample, I was wondering if those who imply the opposite could explain it to me. Because it seems obvious that if you want to measure the salinity of the ocean, you can scoop up a cup of water from it and analyse that. You don't have to use a different size cup for different size oceans, or even know how big your ocean is. But if I'm missing something, I'd love to learn what it is.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dsfasfasf 14y agoHis intent is to see what happens. Read the sentence again
- 616c 14y agoI think it is funny people make such points about Saudi Arabia, as they are what we should compare to. However, I live in a Gulf country neighboring to KSA and trust me mail censorship is bizarrely complicated and we all laugh about it.
- claudius 14y agoIt’s just the first country that comes to mind that fits the bill of being openly religious/islamic (as opposed to Turkey), having a somewhat working government (as opposed to Egypt, Libya or so) and not being too hostile to ‘the West’ (as opposed to Iran) to make such an experiment at least thinkable.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- _ak 14y agoWhy are you so apologetic about religious discrimination in the US? "But these other people are so much worse than I am" has never been a valid argument.
- dsfasfasf 14y agoHis intent is to see what happens. I did not see anybody being apologetic.
- claudius 14y agoMy intent was more ‘You would likely get better results from a country usually assumed to be worse’. Really, I am absolutely not defending the USPS here in any way whatsoever, nor do I claim that the US doesn’t suffer from religious discrimination.
- marknutter 14y agoI bet if you put "Allahu Akbar" tape on a package it'd fair much worse.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoI'd legitimately be interested to see that tested.
- oellegaard 14y agoWow, didn't expect this in a developed country :-(
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- youngerdryas 14y agoWe must fight the twin evils of godless communism abroad and liberal humanism at home.
- DrinkWater 14y agoHonestly, this concept of building a product around such a sensitive issue like religion/spirituality is kind of "dumb". Wasn't it clear to them that such problems will arise, sooner or later? People get offended if you brand your product with something "christian" or "islamic", so why should people not be offended by atheism? I dont get this whining. Keep religion to yourself, in all endeavors.
- claudius 14y agoYes! Religion, as sexuality, should only be visible at home, and expecting a fair treatment of atheism in public is as silly as expecting to be allowed to hold your boyfriend’s hand in public or expecting to be allowed to discuss last Sunday’s sermon on the street.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- aurelianito 14y agoI do expect people to be allowed to hold hands in public. I also expect people to be able to discuss last Sunday's sermon on the street. I would not live in a place were any of those things is prohibited. Luckily, I live in a civilized place where both activities are permitted (Argentina :D).
- GFischer 14y agoWell, having those activities permitted doesn't make Argentina civilized :P (tongue-in-cheek, I'm Uruguayan). I live in a proper Secular/nonreligious country :) (1) and we tolerate both as well. (1) we have separation of church and state, and only 4% of regular Christians, though 60% do believe in some sort of god http://countrystudies.us/uruguay/43.htm http://countrystudies.us/uruguay/43.htm Argentina does not have separation of Church and State (though they don't enforce it much, they even had a Muslim-raised president), and the United States has a state-mandated belief in God.
- 14y ago
- PhantomLobe 14y agoIt would be interesting to see the time delta per state. Maybe in some states the Atheist shoes arrive earlier :D
- carlyle4545 14y agoPerhaps its God Himself intervening..
- rdl 14y agoGod also apparently intervened against their webserver, perhaps by creating ten thousand bored hackers 15-50 years ago, who hit it from Hacker News today.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- edwinjm 14y agoThis makes the migh moral standards claim of believers staggering.
- harrel 14y agoThis is unbelievable, somebody gotto do something about it.
- pc86 14y agoLike what? What would you suggest somebody "gotto" do?
- mason240 14y agoI would like to see a similar experiment where boxes, some randomly labled with "Christian" tape, are handled by atheists. We all know the results would be the same.
- thejteam 14y agoNot enough packages to make a real claim. The variance on package delivery times in the USPS is high. As an example, I recently had two identical packages shipped to me. They both left the same facility at the same time. They were identical weight(heavy) and dimensions. They were wrapped the same. They were shipped from in the same state as me. One arrived in 2 days. One arrived in 10. Also, they mentioned that one of the packages in Michigan took 37 extra days. With that sample size it explains about 10 percent of the average right there.
- Jabbles 14y agoI agree that a larger sample would be welcomed. In particular, spreading the experiment out over many days would help eliminate a "oh all these packages are the same, they probably go here" mistake. Whilst sending them all out on the same day eliminates some sources of bias, it may have made the experiment more susceptible to other errors.
- Retric 14y agoHaving high variance requires a larger difference to pass a statistical test.
- pflats 14y agon = 85 and p < 0.01. What's inherently wrong with that? (I have my own personal crusade against the 5% p-value, but this is under 1%.) I agree that the sample size is far too small to criticize individual states, but 85 seems plenty large for the hypothesis of "Atheist-branded packages sent by the USPS are being delayed more than normal packages."
- yummyfajitas 14y agoHow did you compute a p value without knowing the variance? [Edit: my bad, didn't read the fine print which explains statistical methods at very bottom of page.]
- maxerickson 14y ago
- Strilanc 14y agoThe actual statistics are in teeny tiny print near the bottom. They don't give the raw data, unfortunately. I'd copy-paste the text here, but everything is embedded in images. (Which is absurd.) Also, one of the four comments I can see is not like the others. (It might be removed before you see it.)
- cema 14y agoWell, this is almost certainly illegal. (What is described by the article.) I wonder if any kind of investigation is going to follow. Perhaps not criminal, but journalistic. Freedom of speech is paramount to a broad spectrum of Americans, as far as I can tell, and I expect many would be interested.
- VMG 14y agoMaybe they discriminate against public display of private belief in general.
- bluedino 14y agoOut of 89 packages (half of the 179), 9 went missing? That's 10%. That is insane for the US Postal Service to be allowed that, but it follows my personal experience with them. I don't think I've ever had them lose a letter in my life, but when it comes to packages I don't know how they lose so many. I shudder when I get a USPS tracking email from an online seller because I know there's fair chance I will never see the damn thing.
- IgorPartola 14y agoWhere do you live? In MA, CT, and NC I have had a USPS package go missing exactly twice. In the first case I'm pretty sure the mailperson just left it on the wrong porch and the neighbor never admitted it. In the second, they had confirmed delivery, but the package was not there, so Amazon sent another item.
- rdouble 14y agoI have mailed 13 packages to myself over the past decade and USPS has lost or destroyed 5 of them. "Media Mail" is not recommended. Someone decides that they think the box contains an item that isn't a book and rip the box apart.
- jmj42 14y agoI live in IL, and have had exactly 0 USPS packages go missing. In fact, I take the opposite stance. I prefer USPS, both when receiving and when sending.
- bluedino 14y agoMichigan. A bigger problem with USPS is that it's a lot harder to get your packages if you're not around when they attempt delivery. The local UPS office is open until 8:00 so I can go get missed packages after work, I have a few hours Window on Saturday that I can go get packages at the Post Office. And that's IF they can find the package. Their online delivery rescheduling/holding is also useless.
- utopkara 14y agoI believe with all my heart that evangelist goblins with fear of god are interfering with the sorting process to delay those evil packages. Sure, it is possible that a foreign vendor might forget to put the full zip code on the address label; but where is the morality in that explanation.
- mich41 14y agosome of our customers asked us not to use ATHEIST-branded packing tape on their shipments We sent 178 packages to 89 people 4 participants didn't get back to us with their dates and so were not included in the analysis So they used easily-spoofable data submitted by people who knew about the study and a priori believed to be discriminated against. It may easily be just trolling by atheist jihadists from the US.
- AtheistBerlin 14y agoif only that were the truth. sadly not, no data spoofing involved.
- mich41 14y agoThat's very sad, indeed. Anyway, thank you for your explanation. It really increased my confidence in reliability of your sources.
- smarx 14y agoWhat did the two kinds of packages actually look like? If the illustration is accurate, the "atheism" tape is white with black text, while the other tape is perhaps standard brown packing tape. Could it be that the standard packing tape is just better tape? Could it be that black text on white tape confuses a scanner somewhere? A better control might be identical tape but with a different word (something neutral like "shoes").
- glyphobet 14y agoThese guys share an office with us, so I saw the packages. The Atheist tape is standard packing tape, there's no difference in quality of the tape.
- smarx 14y agoGreat, so can you tell us what the tape looked like? Is the illustration accurate?
- AtheistBerlin 14y agothe illustration is accurate. you're right about the better control, we may do that if we replicate the study... but really I don't think the absence of writing on the neutral tape can explain the findings.
- smarx 14y ago> ... but really I don't think the absence of writing on the neutral tape can explain the findings. To me, it seems like a far more likely explanation than a USPS bias against packages affiliated with atheism.
- glyphobet 14y agoYes, the illustration is accurate.
- trotsky 14y agoAll of these are international packages going through Jamaica Bay in New York which is notorious for delays. A significant percentage of packages are selected for extra screening here, but no where near 100%. Those go into a set of queues that always mean randomized and often lengthy delays. Most of the packages chosen for the screening are picked by humans that I would almost guarantee are more likely to pick the packages that catch their eye for any reason. Also, if you send through a package that weighs just north of a kilogram it is almost guaranteed to be subjected to extra screening. This is by no means a secret among international shippers, and would make it pretty easy to stack the deck if you wanted to. I bet a lot of shoes weigh around that much, no?
- glyphobet 14y agoThese guys share an office with me, so I saw the packages. They all contained one tote bag and were nowhere near a kilogram.
- AtheistBerlin 14y agoJust to confirm, not all of the packages pass through Jamacia Bay and we were careful to ensure the packages were as similarly eye-catching as possible... but those selecting humans would be wiser than to only choose the most eye-catching packages. I'm not gonna put a flag on a package containing drugs, for example. And as the other commenter says, we only sent tote bags, not shoes.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- NateDad 14y agoFor those that say this is just USPS sucking in general.... my wife runs a small business that sends thousands of packages per year both in the US and international. The number of packages that have been truly lost numbers in the single digits. Delays happen, but rarely (most delays are the individual post offices holding on to the package until the recipient comes to the post office to pick it up... we still don't know why they do that). If she suffered 10% loss of deliveries, she'd go out of business. Luckily, that doesn't happen... though she also doesn't label her boxes with atheist tape.
- noonespecial 14y agoThey sent packages from Berlin to the US and found a bunch of variance in delivery times and their first thought was "its the tape"? They have more faith than I do.
- leephillips 14y agoIf they were relying on "faith" they wouldn't have bothered to test their guess, would they have? Isn't that the very opposite of "faith"?
- dictum 14y agoRemember when televangelists raised funds and sold trinkets by telling people that "they" (the non-religious, secular institutions, other religions...) were plotting against them in nefarious ways? You still can't gaze into the abyss without it gazing into you.
- PaulHoule 14y agoI don't know if it is just USPS. Mail between Germany and the U.S. has never been reliable in my opinion. My experience was that one of of two packages I sent to my Mom back in the states would disappear somehow. I've had TSA people wrinkle my shirts and leave behind an apologetic yellow tag, but only in Germany have I had them carefully take apart everything in my cases, find something they didn't want me to have, remove it, put everything carefully back the way it was, and never say a word.
- daleknauss 14y agoIt seems to me that their control packages should have had tape with 'less offensive' text on them. This would ensure that it's not just a matter of the atheist packages being more eye-catching or out of the ordinary.
- 001sky 14y agoThis is a bullshit premise. A policy of "non-branding" packages, is not discriminatory. In particular, one that is actually enforced on politically sensitive/provocative topics. If the "brand" were white supremacy (a-chromatic or KKK...) or perhaps anti-semetic (NAZI brand !) packing tape, I don't think the PO should feel bad about not putting these types of "billboards" // "targets" on people's door steps. The USPS, is strictly not in the business of delivering Hate Mail. But...Nice try!
- Buzaga 14y agoI've bought two artofmanliness.com shirts online that were to be delivered by USPS, they never arrived... all I know this service is shit.
- bhauer 14y agoI read this and was left wanting control tests using other couriers such as UPS and Fedex.
- gngeal 14y agoI'm just wondering...will France ban pupils from wearing these shoes in schools? ;)
- PaulHoule 14y agoA/B testing may be safe in the hands of Athiests, but would you want it in the hands of terrorists?