3 ms·
Your experience exactly matches my experience at school. However, I have since learned that I can acquire other languages, and I can communicate effectively in
by ColinWright 14y ago
Your experience exactly matches my experience at school. However, I have since learned that I can acquire other languages, and I can communicate effectively in them, and it's nothing to do with pure memorisation.
Yes, you need to memorise some things, but I've found that once I've got a few hundred words, the structures start building themselves in my brain. I don't bother memorising verb endings, they start to come of their own accord when I'm communicating with people. I read simple novels in my target language, spotting when the same words turn up multiple times and looking them up to make sure I've got the right definition.
Things accrue, the structures emerge, and suddenly I'm a parody of a foreigner, but I can communicate.
Your characterisation of math and programming needing effectively no memorisation is similarly counter to my experience. You need to know some things, they need to be as natural as breathing, otherwise when confronted by a huge structure to build, you have nowhere to start. Without knowing some of the standard results, sometimes even the statements of problems in math make no sense.
Try working with code written by complete beginners as they've struggled, and failed, to implement something beyond their current skill set, and you will find that you know, and have memorised, much more than you think. Pair program with a beginner and you will be frustrated at how little they know, things you take for granted, things you have memorised.
So my experience is that learning a foreign language is not entirely irrelevant to programming. For you to say it is, from your personal experience, makes me wonder if you have actually ever learned one.
Can you tell us your experience base? How many (natural) languages can you communicate in?