4 ms·
> (YC asks people to decide that day whether or not to accept an offer from us, but we do this because at that point they already know all they need to, not to
by mindslight 18y ago
> (YC asks people to decide that day whether or not to accept an offer from us, but we do this because at that point they already know all they need to, not to pre-empt other offers. There is no other seed firm that decides after us.)
How is this behavior any different? Offering last is a unique position which allows a group to already know the other options. It's not surprising that other firms also want decisions ASAP - they certainly don't want to be floating long term offers that function as backup plans for the best groups.
If YC wants seed funding to be synchronous like college admissions, then it should make its own process conducive - give time to accept an offer during which groups can interview elsewhere.
- joshu 18y agoBecause the terms and dates are known before people apply.
- mindslight 18y agoDo the other seed funding firms say that they'll float you an offer while you're awaiting YC's decision? PS- I realize that with YC being the "gold standard" of seed funding, other firms will always want to get earlier commitment. But moralizing about adding stress makes little sense when other firms currently have no way to actually cooperate.
- pg 18y agoOf course they have a way to cooperate. All they have to do is make their offers expire later.
- mindslight 18y agoAnd interview later unless they want to make long-standing offers. Perhaps making YC have an explicitly longer acceptance period would encourage the reputable funds to interview concurrently, causing the games played by the disreputable ones to become more transparent?
- wheels 18y agoI think the problem somewhat isn't so much with YC being the gold standard, it's that the amount of differentiation of the various accelerators is less than desirable. They all do pretty much the same cash, at the same time, with the same relatively wide net, for the same percentage. If on the other hand, one group focused, say, exclusively on mobile or e-commerce or B2B or infrastructure or started at a different time of the year, or offered more cash, or wanted a smaller slice I think suddenly they could make the time frame less relevant.
- wheels 18y agoI could have missed something, but I don't think the YC terms are known until people get invited for interviews. The angel documents that YC uses are public, but I don't think the YC terms are. So, I don't believe teams at this point that are dealing with exploding termsheets do know the (potential) YC terms.
- pg 18y agoWhen we invite groups to interviews, we also give them a link to a page with all the documents, so they can have a lawyer look at them if they want. I believe our terms are actually more founder-friendly than the series AA terms. We had to make the series AA terms neutral lest investors balk.
- pg 18y agoIt's different because it doesn't force anyone to forgo other opportunities. While we ask people to decide that day, we don't insist on it. As I explained earlier, if people have some specific reason they need more time, we've always given it to them. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=528064 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=528064 And when people do accept, we never ask for more than a verbal "yes"; we don't make groups sign an LOI agreeing to participate. I hear a lot of what goes on behind the scenes in these situations, and I can assure you that it's not merely out of a desire for administrative neatness that other seed firms give applicants offers that expire quickly. It is 100% certain they do it to pressure people into deciding before they can talk to us. That is not the intention, or the effect, when we ask people to decide that day.
- mindslight 18y agoAh, I hadn't realize this had been hashed out in another thread. I took exception to that excerpt because it sounded pretty hand-wavy; I've read your justification of why you ask for an immediate decision, and it makes sense up until you start introducing the possibilities of multiple offers.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]