3 ms·
I think the basic problem is that law is taught in the USA as a graduate degree, so the stakes are higher. In Australia, most universities teach law as an unde
by jacques_chester 14y ago
I think the basic problem is that law is taught in the USA as a graduate degree, so the stakes are higher.
In Australia, most universities teach law as an undergraduate degree. It's basically viewed as the replacement for the Arts degree of the 50s: a generalist degree that shows a comfort with doing large volumes of work with verbal abstractions.
Lots of Australian law students discover that they don't want to be lawyers. They go on to other professional careers instead -- the public service, management etc etc. In my case I quit and did computer science.
I don't regret it. Legal thinking is unusually thorough and careful.
- the_watcher 14y agoI believe the US is the only country in the world to teach law school as a graduate degree. It's a function of every school modeling itself on Harvard Law (which was the first American law school). It makes much more sense to teach law as an undergraduate degree followed by an internship, since it removes the massive debt burden brought on by undergraduate + graduate school debt.
- rayiner 14y agoCanadia also.
- rayiner 14y agoThat is of course the proper way to do it. You can thank Big Academia for getting rid of the sensible LLB here in the U.S. Indeed, even if you are an American and really want to be a lawyer it's not necessarily a bad idea to try your hand at an Australian or British law school then do an LLM in the U.S. Or learn to speak Cantonese and head over to Hong Kong (or Hindi and head to India, or Portuguese and head to Brazil) where economic development has created a large demand for lawyers.
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe biggest switching divide is between common law countries (broadly, everywhere the British were) and code/civil law countries (broadly, everywhere else). They're actually quite different systems of law, not just similar systems with different contents.
- rayiner 14y agoI was thinking of going abroad to study, though I don't know if they are as accepting over in Asia of Anglos as we are of Asians.
- joonix 14y agoAustralia's education sector is catching the bug though. They want the profitable grad education, and thus Melbourne uni now offers only a JD (3 year graduate program).
- jacques_chester 14y agoUWA recently did this too, but then they partly backpedalled by offering guaranteed places in the following law degree. So really what you're getting is a 6 year double degree instead of a 5 year double degree. I think it's a bugger up, but I got my BCompSci (H1) and I'm happy I got in before the Melbourne Model struck.
- ValentineC 14y agoMost law degrees in Australia are double degrees, aren't they? I haven't found too many schools that offer single degrees in Law. Mind sharing with a non-Australian why that's the case there? (And if so, how it's different from doing a single Bachelor's degree and a JD after that.)
- jacques_chester 14y ago> Most law degrees in Australia are double degrees, aren't they? You can take a straight LLB, which is a 4-year course. But most students figure "I'll take the double degree, it only takes an extra year and it covers my bases". If you are absolutely certain that law is your destiny, then the straight LLB is the right move because you'll be able to do more electives. If you're just getting a law degree because you got a high entrance score, then the double degree spreads the risk a bit. And some of them are great career-starters. Law/Commerce is a classic power combo for people looking to enter corporate Australia. Law/Arts is popular with activists and future politicians. Law/Science is around but it's a bit of a stepchild. I studied the LLB part-time for 4 years, so I wound up with a half-degree worth of debt. If I'd gotten my shit together I'd have been able to grab a graduate-entry LLB in about a year by carrying credit, but it was long enough ago now that those credits have largely expired. Plus I just don't see the point in loading up on more debt for something I feel I've already gotten the maximum value out of. I took an Honours year instead. If I did something else next, I'd be probably considering getting a bachelor in maths and stats. That's my real weakness. > And if so, how it's different from doing a single Bachelor's degree and a JD after that. Doing a B(whatever) and then a JD takes a little longer and because of our funding rules costs more. That's why some more prestigious universities are trying to push that model: it makes them more money because they get your so-so undergraduate fees and then they get juicier postgraduate rates on top. And for longer.