5 ms·
"These data were first published in 1924. Why has such a major medical finding, published in high-impact peer-reviewed journals, faded into obscurity?" Possibl
by tokenadult 18y ago
"These data were first published in 1924. Why has such a major medical finding, published in high-impact peer-reviewed journals, faded into obscurity?"
Possibly because the reported research results were not replicated? I wish I had the citation at hand for a finding that 50 percent or more of all medical research findings published in top peer-reviewed journals end up not being replicated. But perhaps that finding can be found in one of the sources cited in Peter Norvig's excellent article about analyzing scientific research papers,
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
which I recommend readers of this thread check as they consider the claims made in the submitted blog post.
After edit: Another problem at the practical level is that it may very well be that a diet optimal for recalcification of teeth (there is no controversy at all that teeth can recalcify throughout life, that's the point of fluoride treatments, but the question is by how much) may not be optimal for cardiovascular health or some other aspect of your health that is important to you. The way human evolution works is that all of your body parts are fitted by haphazard adaptation from ancestral patterns using available materials in an environment of biochemical trade-offs, and it may be a better trade-off to have teeth that decay after reproductive age and a heart that keeps beating longer than to have teeth that never need to have cavities filled. That would have to be the subject of further research, to see which diet is optimal overall. (Yes, I am aware that some research tends to show that good dental hygiene contributes to good cardiovascular health, with the hypothesized mechanism being that infected gums allow bacteria to enter the bloodstream and cause inflammation of the heart's blood vessels.)
- Femur 18y agoI would posit that the diet presented in the article not only contributes to good dental health but also would contribute to good cardiovascular health. The diet is low on refined carbohydrates (which lead to heart disease http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/carbohydrates/ http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-...) and rich in vitamins.
- triplefox 18y agoInteresting that you mention that given that dental health is already directly linked to cardiovascular health, via incidence of inflammation and gum disease.
- electromagnetic 18y agoIt also corresponds to what I've read before, that a high-meat (not pure protein, but diets inclusive of bone marrows or organs like liver and stuff generally found in pâtés) and high animal fat diet can almost completely prevent the development of diabetes, and can actually get diabetics off of insulin. I believe the theory is, is that the body uses insulin to convert glucose to glycogen, AKA 'animal starch', and every other effect (that I'm aware of) it has on the body is not considered good. Example: It promotes triglyceride production from fatty acids (high triglycerides are usually a big factor in heart disease), and decreases the metabolism of fats (I think everyone wants this one high), proteins and reduces gluconeogenesis, which can exacerbate lactose intolerance in some people. Everything more complex than raw glucose doesn't require insulin. That's why the body largely doesn't react to fructose (which is a result of our ancestry, primates largely live in a symbiosis with the trees they feed off because larger animals like Elephants frequently kill the trees in the process of foraging, but shrieking monkeys tend to stop them) so that we do consume more of it. I think it also helps that foods high in fructose (IE fruits) are generally also high in vitamins. I mean some of the recommended RDA's for vitamin C are actually around 6,000-12,000 mg a day (30,000 mg if you're sick). Basically from what I understand, if you look at our close relatives diets (which are very similar to our ancestors diets) they essentially eat 1:1 ratio of vitamin C (in mg) to kcals. So an adult male should eat 2,500 mg of vitamin C and 2,500 kcals. Incidentally vitamin C is used in the body to produce carnitine, which moves fatty acids into the mitochondria to produce ATP. Your average goat produces around 13,000 mg of vitamin C in normal health through biosynthesis, which has to make you wonder about WHO's RDA of 45 mg a day if a goat produces 290 times that amount. We, unfortunately don't biosynthesise vitamin C.
- billswift 18y agoAll carbs require insulin. Fructose and complex carbs need other "processing" first though, which spreads out their absorption, reducing spikes in insulin levels.
- electromagnetic 18y agoActually they don't, carbs are broken down into glucose, fructose and galactose. Glucose, generally, requires insulin to be absorbed by the muscles, liver and fat cells. However Fructose doesn't, the cells then convert it into whatever form necessary, the liver usually converts it into glucose for storage. Yet muscles are capable of using fructose directly. Glucose can directly be turned into ADP or ATP, or it is converted into Glucose-1-phosphate, which then can either be turned back into glucose or follow the path to be turned into Fructose-6-Phosphate (fructose incidentally directly turns into this). F6P is then converted into triose phosphate, a change that cannot be reversed, and can be directly converted into fat. Fats, when needed, are turned back into triose phosphate and can basically be directly converted into ATP. Essentially fructose needs less processing than glucose to be readily stored. The aim of the human body is to increase its fat reserves for winter when food becomes scarce. Glucose is readily available and readily usable by the body, but all this depends directly on insulin to get it into cells to be useful. The notable cell that doesn't require insulin are brain cells, however these readily process fructose too. So it's actually possible to completely remove glucose from the body, in the event it was ever needed then fructose can be back-stepped into glucose-1-phosphate. However, the body can more than adequately produce energy directly from fats, so it would seem extremely rare that the body would need glucose.
- dejb 18y agoStudy after study has shown that read meat increases the chances of dying early, both from cardiovascular problems and cancer. Just one of the recent studies :- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03/23/AR2009032301626.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03... How much clearer do you need the evidence to be?
- dejb 18y agoOff topic or wrong? You know I'm right. You are just too weak or stupid to reply.
- sci 18y agoThere's a reasonable amount of evidence that following (generally) a diet as outlined in the article would be beneficial to one's health across the spectrum. Google 'paleolithic diet' (alternative spelling, 'palaeolithic') for further information.
- tokenadult 18y agoThe best book about life in Paleolithic days is The Nature of Paleolithic Art by R. Dale Guthrie, http://www.amazon.com/Nature-Paleolithic-Art-Dale-Guthrie/dp/0226311260 http://www.amazon.com/Nature-Paleolithic-Art-Dale-Guthrie/dp... who is a professor of zoology specializing in Paleolithic fauna and an accomplished artist and bow hunter. He cites all the best primary research literature on Paleolithic life in the notes in his book. One fact Guthrie points out is that the lifespan for Paleolithic Homo sapiens was only forty years.
- randallsquared 18y agoLifespan at birth or at adulthood? I thought it was accepted that lifespan at adulthood for hunter-gatherer types was often essentially of modern length, and it was agriculture that lowered it (while increasing number of children) until modern times?
- tokenadult 18y agoThere is good paleontological evidence for how long adults survived in Paleolithic times, and it wasn't for very long.
- randallsquared 18y agoWikipedia agrees with you, for values of "not very long" that are about 60 at mid-life. Since that includes essentially no medical care, however, I'm not sure how much of it is attributable to diet.
- catz 18y ago> lifespan for Paleolithic Homo sapiens was only forty years. That is 10 years longer that people in Swaziland. 40 is not that bad if you think that most hunter gatherer societies abandon old people (since food is a scarcity). So the life expectancy in those times was basically the modern day retirement age.
- biohacker42 18y agoYour comment is the only reason I'm not flagging that article. It's not spam, it's just so very wrong.
- Femur 18y agoWhy is the article wrong?
- biohacker42 18y agoPerhaps you missed this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=543368 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=543368
- abstractbill 18y agoThat's just general skepticism, which is great, and certainly should be the default reaction to an article like this. But when you said "It's not spam, it's just so very wrong." you made it sound like you must know of some hard evidence that actually debunked the article, rather than just the same general skepticism that tokenadult already expressed. I'm pretty sure Femur was asking you for some more details of that evidence.
- Femur 18y ago>I'm pretty sure Femur was asking you for some more details of that evidence. Indeed I was.
- biohacker42 18y agoI think where you and I and Femur disagree is what constitutes skepticism. For me an experiment who's results can't be replicated, indeed have not been replicated since 1924, is as wrong as wrong can be. It is 2 + 2 = 5 For you and Femur it is perhaps merely reasonable skepticism. Perhaps you were expecting some proof that it is wrong, not just lack of proof that it is right? In science inability to reproduce is where the buck stops. There are no further attempts to actually prove wrongness.
- pygy 18y agoAfter some research, it apears that May and Edward Melanby were published several times in high profile, peer reviewed journals (BMJ, the Lancet) on the topic of the impact of nutrition on health. Looking at the citations, it seems that the effect of diet on tooth healing have been forgotten more than disporoved. They are cited in papers focusing on tooth developement in children (but not regeneration later on), and on the role of Vitamin D and other food in Rickets. But tooth regrowth is a well documented process in animals, and, according to these papers, it also happens in humans. BTW, the linked blog post has it wrong. White flour is the least Ca++ chelating cereal (once again, according to E. Mellanby). Oatmeal appears to be the worst (see 1). 1. THE RELATION OFDIET TO HEALTH AND DISEASE.Some new investigations. E Mellanby, BMJ apr 1930 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=2312877&blobtype=pdf http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=231287... 2. THE EFFECT OF DIET ON THE DEVELOPEMENT AND EXTENSION OF CARIES IN THETEETH OF CHILDREN. (Preliminary Note.) MAY MELLANBY, C. LEE PATTISON AND C. W. PROUD BMJ aug 1924 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=2304908&blobtype=pdf http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=230490... -- -- Side note for fun: It looks like bad OCR software reinvented l33t sp34k. This is what you get when you copy/paste the title of the first paper referenced here: THE RELATION OFDIET TO HEALTH AND DISEASE. S4OMlJE 1E'E XET !NVESTIW.41T!ONS). BY EDWARI) MA1iT,LANBY, M.A. M.D.C.kMn.l F.R.C.P., F.R.S., PROFESSOR OF PHARMACOILOC', XJNTVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD.
- Ardit20 18y ago* I wish I had the citation at hand for a finding that 50 percent or more of all medical research findings published in top peer-reviewed journals end up not being replicated. * Was that finding replicated?