4 ms·
This is silly. It's purely a historical fluke that the role of professor (scientist/teacher) even exists. There is no reason whatsoever why the same person sho
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
This is silly. It's purely a historical fluke that the role of professor (scientist/teacher) even exists.
There is no reason whatsoever why the same person should both create new knowledge and also teach calculus/cs 101/etc. I was good at research, but I sucked at teaching [1]. In contrast, many people are really terrible researchers, but actually pretty good teachers. (As you note, there is a glut of such people, so their wages are low.)
Separating these roles is a good thing.
[1] Due to a lack of standardized tests at the college level, I have no way to actually know this. But I do know my students didn't like me, complaining that I was too hard and unsympathetic.
- zanny 14y agoI don't think it is a fluke, it was just a tactic to extract a guaranteed baseline real value from intellectuals where they could jump from research project to research project for years without a return. Which is perhaps the greatest bane of capitalism - that which has poor returns in the immediate time frame is always passed over for instant results. It hurts our long run dearly to be so inefficient.
- jessriedel 14y agoIt's hardly a fluke that the creation and dispersion of knowledge are tied together. The reason research universities exist is because undergrad were willing to pay money to learn from people at the forefront of knowledge. The problem isn't having (most) of those researchers teaching, it's that our society now wants to send 50% of people to college rather than the historical norm of order 1%. The researchers are spread too thin, and the mixed bag of lecturers must necessarily pick up the slack. If you correct for the fact that the best researchers have zero incentive to teach (i.e. by just selecting those researchers and lecturers who are internally motivated to teach regardless of incentives) the researchers are way better on average. There's a place for great researchers who suck at teaching or are so great at research that teaching is a waste, e.g. the institute for advanced study. (And frankly, most of the researchers at the institute should probably be teaching the best grad students.) But, as someone who was a grad student after going to a fancy undergrad school, I think it's clear that having most researchers teach is a fantastic Good Thing.
- bokonist 14y agoMy ideal world: Basic courses should be taught by professional teachers. Intermediate courses should be taught by practitioners who also have good teaching skills. So an junior year software engineering course might be taught by a Google programmer who was good at teaching and was taking a one year sabbatical from Google to teach. Or the course might be taught by a programming researcher who was good at teaching. Master level courses should basically be the student doing an apprenticeship under an existing master practitioner. So someone wanting to be a computer science researcher would apprentice with an existing researcher. Someone wanting to be an engineer at Google would do an apprenticeship at Google.
- EliRivers 14y ago"There is no reason whatsoever why the same person should both create new knowledge and also teach calculus/cs 101/etc" How about that the person using the tool every day in the course of their work is probably going to be the person best placed to teach others how to use it? Obviously teaching is a skill and craft that has to be taught, but given two people of equal teaching ability, the person using the tool every day should be the better choice, surely?