8 ms·
Animals eating each other is part of the nature of our existence. I myself don't feel any guilt about it.
by ams6110 14y ago
Animals eating each other is part of the nature of our existence. I myself don't feel any guilt about it.
- mlent 14y agoYes, but not all animals eat one another. And we are not, like tigers and lions, obligate carnivores. We can survive and thrive without meat. Our bodies are capable of surprising dietary adaptation. If you don't need to kill/keep captive animals for food to live healthily, why do it? That's just my personal philosophy.
- Goronmon 14y agoIf you don't need to kill/keep captive animals for food to live healthily, why do it? Because it tastes good. Just like every other type of food we eat that isn't a requirement for living healthily.
- mlent 14y agoI agree that it's the only actual "reason." I just don't think it's a good reason. I think it presumes that the value of "taste" for us is greater than the value of "life" to an animal. And there's a lot of evidence that most meat is very unhealthy for you, anyways. As an interesting (perhaps?) side note, I tasted meat recently for the first time in 2+ years and it was really lame and underwhelming. :/
- jlgreco 14y ago> I tasted meat recently for the first time in 2+ years and it was really lame and underwhelming. That statement is about as bizarre as "I tasted alcohol once, I don't understand what the big deal is".
- mlent 14y agoI don't think it's the same at all. I don't think it requires a history of meat-eating in order to determine whether or not something tastes good to you or not. I tried steak, chicken, and fish. I don't think that most people would call meat "an acquired taste"? My personal theory is that vegans put in way more effort to make their food taste good than non-vegans, and we eat an extremely wide variety of foods, so eating things like "steak" or "chicken" is generally a very boring flavor experience. I had a bite of "good steak" and thought...this is alright, but I could make better-tasting seitan!
- jlgreco 14y ago> "I tried steak, chicken, and fish" That does not seem much better. You may as well say "I don't like alcohol, I tried 'good beer', wine, and liquor". There are particular animals that I like or do not like (salmon for instance I have never been a fan of with any preparation I have tried) and various preparations/cuts that I do not like (lamb chops, most preparations of steak besides rare (preferably Pittsburgh rare, which is sadly difficult to find or prepare yourself at home) and most baked/broiled preparations of poultry). These classifications are again only scratching the surface of course, basically just breaking the question down to "ale or lager? white wine or red? Dark liquor, or clear?" Regardless if it isn't your thing, then knock yourself out, but you should be sure that you don't fall into the trap of being confused why others don't share your personal preferences. (Or worse, trying to suggest that people who don't share your personal preferences are deluding themselves; lying to themselves about their own tastes.) I don't find myself annoyed by veganism/vegetariansim until I really get one of those vibes coming across.
- mlent 14y agoYeah, I just tasted it because I'd forgotten what it tasted like. Obviously taste isn't a reason to stop eating meat for everyone, and it's certainly not as compelling as animal welfare/personal health/environmental concerns.
- tene 14y agoHi. I've tried alcohol a couple of times, and I don't understand what the big deal is. Intellectually, sure, I'm aware that it decreases social inhibitions, but it didn't do much of anything for me, and it tasted pretty bad, so I haven't bothered with it any further.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoIf it didn't do anything for you, i doubt you drank very much. Most mind-altering substances also taste bad.
- Draco6slayer 14y agoI disagree. There are a lot of nutrients (mostly protein) that, without meat, require us to rely heavily on nuts and beans. A dependency on those requires a large amount of additional effort for the consumer. Nut allergies are intensely common besides, having to depend your entire muscular structure on the number of beans you eat would be both very ineffective and would have a number of negative results. Point being, meat is the most efficient way to get a lot of nutrients, and you can't declare that everyone can't eat it because you may someday discover that it's intelligent. The future is broad, we might find out that plants are actually the intelligent beings on this planet. Does that mean we should all starve ourselves now on the fear that that may happen in the future?
- mlent 14y agoEverything has protein in it. I've gotten over 100g in a day without trying and little to no nuts. Your body will naturally combine different types of amino acids to form complete proteins. You just need to eat a variety of foods and you'll be good to go. The issue with a vegan diet is eating enough calories, not getting enough protein. In fact, many people in the US eat too much protein which is very bad for you! It's easy to undereat accidentally on a vegan diet because you have to physically eat more. Hard to complain about that though. And effort, in my opinion, isn't enough to justify eating animals. Think about the specific efforts you go through to prepare raw chicken: you have to wash your hands in between handling it and your other foods so you don't risk contaminating them with salmonella. Way more effort than my dinner, where everything can safely touch!
- cameronh90 14y agoGetting sufficient nutrients on a vegetarian diet is not difficult. It requires no particular thought unless you're doing a lot of exercise and need a huge amount of protein, but even then, it's pretty easy to get unless you want to avoid eggs, milk, soya, tempeh, nuts, mycoprotein, beans, lentils, protein supplements, etc. Iron is more difficult in theory, but no other vegetarians I know have actually had a problem with it.
- bwood 14y ago
- pyre 14y ago| Because it tastes good Ah, but in a vacuum of other considerations, I hear that human flesh is very tasty. Would you fancy a go with cannibalism?
- darkxanthos 14y agoThis sounds like you're saying "We've always done it so it is ok by me." It's flawed reasoning. Following that reasoning why'd we let women start to vote? As mlent points out we have a choice today. In the past there were times when it was necessary to travel and survive. Why do it if it's unnecessary?
- bane 14y agoBecause eating some animals is necessary for human survival. Non-animal sourced diets are hopelessly unhealthy in the long term no matter how many supplements you take to try and take to make up for it.
- autarch 14y agoCitation very much needed, since all the scientific evidence says this is not true.
- bane 14y agoRead pretty much all the unbiased scientific literature that looks at the long term effects of a vegan diet, from nutritional studies to surveys of practicing populations. I won't bother to cite them. I'm assuming google isn't blocked in your country? (tip: papers published by vegan and vegetarian promoting organizations do not count). Don't think I'm defending modern diets either. Most people eat a woefully unhealthy diet regardless of what they eat. It's just that for most people who go to great lengths to adopt a highly specialized and unbalanced diet, it becomes religion, and they think it makes them immune to the fact of being an omnivore. Being an omnivore doesn't mean you can choose to eat plants OR animals, it means you must eat a bit of both. But you can certainly go for long spells on just one or the other, but long term, you'll most certainly end up with a case of malnutrition on some area. Most of the studies I've read show that 80-90% of Vegans suffer some malnutrition of some form (despite having fantastic health in many other areas). Put another way, if you have to take supplements to make up for dietary shortfalls (a number which approaches 100% in long term vegan population studies), you're doing it wrong.
- michaelvanham 14y agoMany of the animals that humans eat are born into captivity, caged their entire existence, and slaughtered at a young age. I feel sorrow for them.
- awolf 14y agoAnd many of the animals humans eat are not. They are treated well, given ample amounts of the types of food their species was intended to eat, and slaughtered respectfully. Instead of simply opting out of the horrendous conditions you don't agree with, what about voting with your dollar to support the ethical alternatives?
- mlent 14y agoThe vast, vast majority of the animals that Americans and Western Europeans eat are treated cruelly from birth until premature death. Some estimates have it as high as 99% in the US [1]. If you go to your average grocery store, like most people do, that's kind of meat you'll find. I've yet to personally meet a meat-eater who actually buys local, grass-fed, truly free-range meat. In some ways, it's more ethical, in my opinion, to eat local, "humane" meat than it is to eat factory-farm produced eggs and dairy. I can't speak for michaelvanham, but a lot of veg*ns do vote with their dollars... It's pretty easy to find locally grown produce, plant-based non-animal-tested cleaning and hygiene products, etc. No way to be perfect, but easy to try :) [1] http://www.farmforward.com/farming-forward/factory-farming http://www.farmforward.com/farming-forward/factory-farming
- darkxanthos 14y agoI have to laugh any time someone says "Humanely slaughtered" or in this case "slaughtered respectfully". I guess the oxymoron is non-obvious. Here's a couple extreme examples: I humanely slaughtered your family. I slaughtered your mother respectfully. Followed by: "Why are you so upset?? I could have just opted out of slaughtering your family but I decided to opt into doing it respectfully." I put that into familial terms to bring the context closer to home. We wouldn't stand for such language with humans. At the root is hubris and apathy.
- guygurari 14y agoI am a vegan for moral reasons, and I have no objection to people eating animals. What I do object to is the horrifying daily torture that animals must suffer in the meat, dairy and eggs industry. I am guessing this is where some of your food comes from. In my experience, people who have no qualms about using animal-based products are ignorant of the realities of how these products are made. I encourage you to watch Earthlings [1] -- free to watch on their site -- and see if you feel the same way once you've seen some evidence. [1] http://earthlings.com/ http://earthlings.com/
- mlent 14y agoAs a fellow vegan, I have to ask -- why be vegan if you have no objection to people eating animals, if they are raised/slaughtered "humanely"? Why not just buy local meat/dairy/eggs? At least where I live, it's pretty easy to meet farmers at a farmer's market and talk to them about how their animals are treated.
- awolf 14y agoExactly. If you reason for avoiding meat is only because of shitty meat producers, then why not vote with your dollar instead and support the non-shitty meat producers?
- guygurari 14y agoSee my reply to mlent.
- guygurari 14y agoFirst, I doubt we would be able to agree on a viable definition of "humane" commercial farming. But even if we did, I would not take the farmer's word for how the animals are treated. What I have heard from a former farmhand, who worked on several small farms, is that abuse of animals is simply the norm. It sounds reasonable to me that this is the situation, except perhaps in very small farms. History has taught me this: whenever humans have physical control over other humans, they tend to abuse their subjects in terrible ways. Slavery. The Holocaust. Gulags. North Korean concentration camps. It seems to me that the way we are treating animals is simply a manifestation of this tendency toward sadism. It is not difficult to find recorded evidence of pure sadism playing out both in small and large farms. Since I have no way to verify a given farmer's claims, I will not take the risk. Second, a well-balanced, strictly vegetarian diet is far more healthy than a diet that is based on animal products [1,2]. I know that many people do not believe this, and they base their views on the vast amount of disinformation that is out there. To get to the truth you have to listen to the experts. The book [1] I am citing was written by Dr. Walter Willett, one of the leading researchers on the relation between nutrition and disease. His recommendation is basically to eat as I suggested above. More precisely, he recommends (based on decades of research) to reduce animal-based foods as much as possible, and to reduce processed foods in favor of whole foods. There are of course additional recommendations that I will not go into. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Eat-Drink-Be-Healthy-Harvard/dp/0743266420 http://www.amazon.com/Eat-Drink-Be-Healthy-Harvard/dp/074326... [2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30gEiweaAVQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30gEiweaAVQ
- MarkMc 14y agoHere's a thought experiment: Imagine that I breed gorillas. Soon after reaching adulthood each gorilla is killed and made into dog food. One day I discover a gorilla whose mental abilities are similar to a 6-year old human child. That is, the gorilla can reason, communicate, be creative and show empathy just like a child. Is it OK to kill that gorilla? If so, how about an '8-year-old child' gorilla? Or 10-year-old?
- jacoblyles 14y agoChickens, cows, and fish aren't very smart.
- Peaker 14y agoCitation? AFAIK, cows are relatively smart.