14 ms·
Brains of the Animal Kingdom: Research shows we've underestimated
- losethos 14y agoquantum random numbers are not subconscious. 400Mhz is a little hard for a 10Hz brain cell to synchronize to. Quantumn random numbers destroys your stupiditity in a way even you should be able to understand. God says... 7:1 My son, keep my words, and lay up my commandments with thee. 7:2 Keep my commandments, and live; and my law as the apple of thine eye. 7:3 Bind them upon thy fingers, write them upon the table of thine heart. 7:4 Say unto wisdom, Thou art my sister; and call understanding thy kinswoman: 7:5 That they may keep thee from the strange woman, from the stranger which flattereth with her words. 7:6 For at the window of my house I looked through my casement, 7:7 And beheld among the simple ones, I discerned among the youths, a young man void of understanding, 7:8 Passing through the street near her corner; and he went the way to her house, 7:9 In the twilight, in the evening, in the black and dark night: 7:10 And, behold, there met him a woman with the attire of an harlot, and subtil of heart.
- rdl 14y agoA lot of those seemed like really striking examples of bad experiment design. I wish there were more venues for publishing negative results (as well as experimental setup for failed experimental design) -- I know sometimes it is done for really "interesting" negative results, but there's a strong bias against publishing when you don't see what you want, in the conventional journal system.
- Alex3917 14y agoIf by 'we' the authors of this article mean people who only believe things that have been 'proven' by science, then the intelligence of animals will always be underestimated by definition.
- uptown 14y agoI have no question that animals far exceed the cognitive capabilities most humans give them credit for. It saddens me that there's such a massive void in knowledge about this world we live in. I wonder how much more advanced humans would be if more time were spent expanding that knowledge instead of gratifying our other pleasure-systems by focusing instead on increasing bank account balances, political power, or participating in destructive conflicts with other humans. Knowledge for the sake of knowledge seems to be turning into one of those huge unappreciated things that seems to have been degraded in its worth unless it's able to be leveraged to some competitive advantage.
- svenkatesh 14y agoScience research requires funding. Even though we beat our chests about STEM education, basic sciences are woefully underfunded in relation to the number of students who graduate every year with BS, MS, and PhD degrees in life sciences.
- njharman 14y agoFunding is prelevant. Governments, foundations, charities, donations, kick starters. What we lack is proper priority. We value things such as wealth & imaginary gods higher than knowledge.
- xk_id 14y agoThank you! You are a great human.
- lukifer 14y agoWhether intended ironically or not, this comment amused me. (Knowledge seeking, moral high ground, and social approval are also pleasure-reward systems; not that there's anything wrong with that!) Carry on; both of you are fantastic humans. :)
- xk_id 14y agoNo, it wasn't intended ironically! I resonated because the other day I spoke with an academician in business studies, who was researching how corporations can make more money... I argue that consumerist systems of ideas are essentially against human nature, fundamentally flawed. Because they focus locally, history-wise; "me, now, need that. yes, good. more. thank you." In the mean time, humans are a uniquely interdependent species, in that they are interdependent not just in space, but also in time – through the techno-ideological legacies that are being passed on to next generations (and research is at the heart of all that). So, any endeavour that does not start as a concern for the future, and for the next generations, is against our very human nature... You know, somebody put it well: "for the most part, what we are surrounded by is not the dead work of the living, it is the living work of the dead." :) Also, I believe that with the advent of computers, it has never been a better time in human history to do science (then, again, I also believe the statement could have been made at any point in human history. See above.) The computational power, the software, and Google – the great minds of our past would have surely looked at those and believe they are the holy grail of humanity. And the most amazing part is, that they empower anybody to conduct research. In sciences, I find meaning and sanity. And people behave like gentlemen. Yes, that is pleasurable and deeply satisfying; but it is also preferable to the materialistic hysterias, which created so many socio-economic problems – proof of their lack of human ecology. I hope I made a strong argument :) I saw somebody say this in a Youtube video: "Stay human. Stay curious. And let the entire world know that you are."
- dgreensp 14y agoOther primates had been tested, but they had been tested on human faces -- based on the assumption that ours are the easiest to tell apart. ::face-palm::
- enjo 14y agoAlthough there are interesting results there. There have been a few studies now done with dogs and their ability to not only recognize human faces, but to decipher emotions from them. It's fascinating insight into how domesticated dogs complement humans in really amazing ways.
- nessus42 14y agoYes, if that's really true one has to wonder about the common sense of the scientists who did that research!
- Houshalter 14y agoWell if it turned out that they could tell apart human faces that would be an interesting result. But it certainly doesn't prove that they can't distinguish members of their own species, if that is what the researchers were claiming.
- darkxanthos 14y agoWow. I remember a time when I thought scientists were infallible, almost magical in their reasoning abilities. Then I read stuff like this and remember "Nope. Still only human." ;)
- coldtea 14y ago>I remember a time when I thought scientists were infallible, almost magical in their reasoning abilities. Then I read stuff like this and remember "Nope. Still only human." Why would you think that? Scientists are just humans that follow a methodology of inquiry (and keep tabs). Nothing more. Sure, some scientists are super-smart (e.g Feynman) but that's because they happen to be geniuses, not because they are scientists. They can also be stupider than the guy flipping burgers at McDonalds, not only in generic fields (he might be better at music than them), but also in general thinking. Even having a PhD doesn't mean much. I've seen people I know getting those that are dumb as hell (being meticulous and methodological seems more of a predictor of getting one). And of course the classic: sex, money, ideology, power, personal psychological complexes etc can make a scientist think BS just like any other guy.
- emailandeggs 14y agoMost tests concerning intelligence fall prey to confirmation bias. Some, even worse, setup the test to fall into what we already know is an ability/tendency of an organism and then wrap it in a human-oriented; often overly-emotional, abstraction.
- gwern 14y agoAlso worth reading: "If a Lion Could Talk: Animal Intelligence and the Evolution of Consciousness" http://web.archive.org/web/20090416230704/http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/b/budiansky-lion.html http://web.archive.org/web/20090416230704/http://www.nytimes...
- Whm0102 14y agoThe things listed are kind of old... this discussion has been going on for a while. Goldfish and tit for tat, fish and tool use, none of it is really new... so the implication that we're just getting to it isn't quite accurate, and the article didn't even mention what little actually is unique to humans. If you want an interesting talk about "uniqueness" Robert Sapolsky has one from a few years back that has been highlighted on ted, but I feel like the way it is approached in the article implies it is new, and it is not. http://www.ted.com/talks/robert_sapolsky_the_uniqueness_of_humans.html http://www.ted.com/talks/robert_sapolsky_the_uniqueness_of_h... One thing that is not correct is that humans are unique in sex not being used solely for reproduction, bonobos are very reliant on sex for social purposes.
- xk_id 14y agoExcellent article! A couple of observations... "Aristotle's idea of the scala naturae, the ladder of nature, put all life-forms in rank order, from low to high, with humans closest to the angels. During the Enlightenment, the French philosopher René Descartes, a founder of modern science, declared that animals were soulless automatons. In the 20th century, the American psychologist B.F. Skinner and his followers took up the same theme, painting animals as little more than stimulus-response machines." <- rudimentary systems of ideas. And I kindof gasped towards the end of the article, when I read this: "The one historical constant in my field is that each time a claim of human uniqueness bites the dust, other claims quickly take its place. Meanwhile, science keeps chipping away at the wall that separates us from the other animals." I mean, as I said, excellent article, but let's not falsify by omission. We are the only species who can build on previous generations' achievements; and the only species who can abstract indefinitely (i.e, always make a statement about a previous statement). These are both due to the special linguistic behaviours we are capable of.
- dormouse 14y agoYet don't you think your last statement there is a perfect example of walking through a quiet wood and declaring a woodpecker absent? We certainly don't understand non-human languages/communication systems, and significant evidence is piling up that it's often far more sophisticated than we think it is. And "building on previous generations' achievements" is a little ill-defined; isolated groups of individuals often form a unique society, even if they aren't conducting research on human intelligence.
- xk_id 14y agoI didn't say other species clearly do not possess equally impressive linguistic abilities. But qualitatively, our stand in sharp distinction. Surely, we can never be certain the woodpecker is absent, but, that's just a new take on the fact that our theories are merely the expectations with maximum probability. I stay open, and prepared to accept if a new sign of legacy-based behaviour is found in other species, as well as a form of extra-neural storage of symbolic configurations (e.g writing). But surely you cannot ask me to expect those. I'm not sure about what you meant in your last remark. I meant that humans are uniquely able of starting where the former generations left off. This explains the techno-ideological development that has been occurring naturally for all and any of us (unless a library was burned down, which was a pathological thing to do).
- jessedhillon 14y agoHere's the author's Wikipedia page http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frans_de_Waal http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frans_de_Waal
- jkaljundi 14y agoYou could also say we've vastly overestimated the intelligence of human animals.
- fkdjs 14y agoIn that respect, I would say we are separating into different species.
- Lost_BiomedE 14y agoAfter working a while with animal behavior and neuro-research, I tend to ask myself if there is proof an animal can't do something rather than if they can. They usually learn slower than humans, depending on animal and task, but they can learn complex tasks. What they fail at usually tends to be due to physical limitations such as visual acuity. I don't think we have found the limits of what many animals can do but we are raising the bar slowly. It takes a lot of thought and work to design an experiment with a complex task correctly. Of Note: Pigeons can classify a Picasso from a Monet at an expert level and peck their answer within 300ms: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1334394/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1334394/. They were tested on assembly lines to pick out defective parts. They did better than humans but were not used due to decreased moral of other humans on the line. This was done in the early 60's I believe. Here is an article on it in the New Scientist (1962) http://books.google.com/books?id=HxU-9UeDCI0C&pg=PA498&lpg=PA498&dq=Pigeon+assembly+line&source=bl&ots=cQ7vOtf7Kg&sig=V6Ro8Mvx3yjs_l7nJYY8bJR1EBo&hl=en&sa=X&ei=liBOUdaAFI3TqQHYooDgBg&ved=0CD8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=Pigeon%20assembly%20line&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=HxU-9UeDCI0C&pg=PA498&#...
- vacri 14y agoProof that you can't do something is harder to get than proof that you can. It's hard to prove that an animal can't make a hammer drill, for example.
- darkxanthos 14y agoPlease link me to a study or web article. That's amazing. EDIT: I see the links now! Thanks!
- xk_id 14y agoLink to the study about pigeons' discrimination between Picasso and Monet paintings: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1334394/pdf/jeabehav00221-0041.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1334394/pdf/jeab... Still looking for a source for the assembly lines tests.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- darkxanthos 14y agoThis is my belief too and a reason I'm vegetarian. In my mind the chance of us eventually beginning to see animals as more and more people like are VERY good. I don't want to look back over the last 20 years and realize that I killed and ate so many people especially since it is unnecessary. Part of my chain of reasoning is seeing how black people were referred to as animals and their intelligence and general ability was VERY much underestimated since we are in fact all human beings. Then seeing all of the research we've done with dolphins. They have their own language and social structure. Even bees have a language that we're just now beginning to understand. In fact, the more research we do, the more evidence we seem to find that we've sold "animals" short.
- ams6110 14y agoAnimals eating each other is part of the nature of our existence. I myself don't feel any guilt about it.
- mlent 14y agoYes, but not all animals eat one another. And we are not, like tigers and lions, obligate carnivores. We can survive and thrive without meat. Our bodies are capable of surprising dietary adaptation. If you don't need to kill/keep captive animals for food to live healthily, why do it? That's just my personal philosophy.
- Goronmon 14y agoIf you don't need to kill/keep captive animals for food to live healthily, why do it? Because it tastes good. Just like every other type of food we eat that isn't a requirement for living healthily.
- mlent 14y agoI agree that it's the only actual "reason." I just don't think it's a good reason. I think it presumes that the value of "taste" for us is greater than the value of "life" to an animal. And there's a lot of evidence that most meat is very unhealthy for you, anyways. As an interesting (perhaps?) side note, I tasted meat recently for the first time in 2+ years and it was really lame and underwhelming. :/
- georgemcbay 14y ago"For instance, on the planet Earth, man had always assumed that he was more intelligent than dolphins because he had achieved so much—the wheel, New York, wars and so on—whilst all the dolphins had ever done was muck about in the water having a good time. But conversely, the dolphins had always believed that they were far more intelligent than man—for precisely the same reasons." - Douglas Adams
- sudo_robin 14y agoShould we be saying "Research shows research underestimated"
- benched 14y agoI have always believed that we were nowhere near over our chauvinism as a species in this regard.
- nicrogo 14y agoI've realised a long time ago that human knowledge on animal intelligence was underrated. They may not be able to predict future observations nor to be able to remember trivial events from the past nor to create or use tools, but when you take a closer look at them, whether they are insects, fish or mammals, they can all sense danger and opportunity in nature. It's no automatic reflexes but true analytics of their environment. After all a worm is said to have an IQ of 1 when the IQ of a computer is 0. Animal kingdom is smarter than previously thought and most of them probably have emotions like fear, pain & empathy. This is no anthropomorphism but a true fact.