3 ms·
I feel like this was a con, and yet I also feel strong social pressure to not share this opinion with my friends and co-workers. 1) Did the 9 year old write an
by EdgarVerona 14y ago
I feel like this was a con, and yet I also feel strong social pressure to not share this opinion with my friends and co-workers.
1) Did the 9 year old write any of that appeal? I don't think so. Sure, her mom may have written it with her prompting - but the entire appeal feels too well-constructed to pull at heartstrings. There's something... gimmicky about it, something that makes me feel like the appeal isn't genuine.
2) Was this kickstarter really about making a game? No, she's going to a camp to learn about making games - which is cool in theory, if there actually is a little girl and she actually is going to that camp. But it does also mean that the whole premise of the kickstarter's title is misleading at best.
3) The sudden stretch goal bonuses (where'd all this merch come from?) seemed highly questionable as well, and counter to the goal - if she just needs money to go to some camp, why even HAVE stretch goals? This feels like someone who played the system, creating a false situation to gain profit from people. I wouldn't be surprised if it turns out that there isn't actually a kid at all - that it's not even a parent who got greedy, but someone who just flat-out lied to get a good chunk of change.
A lot of people I know seem to believe it unquestioningly, which makes me wonder whether I'm being paranoid. But my gut tells me that if I heard a story like this while walking down the street, I wouldn't give them a dollar (and I frequently give people on the street asking for money a dollar). Especially if they started pulling out merch in exchange for additional donations.
I also love that this article vilifies people who appropriately point out the skeptical parts of this whole situation. I love a feel-good story as much as anyone else when it's real... but this situation throws up more red flags than a well-bribed soccer referee.
- wisesascha 14y agoOne weird thing is at the end of the video seemingly out of no where comes this whole thing about not becoming a girl who needs a man to make money for her. The production value is pretty high, so maybe the family could have afforded the 800 dollar camp, and not needed a kickstarter. It seems like a ploy for money, and not about someone making a game, and who is going to play a game made by a 9 year old. It will most likely be done in RPG Maker or Game maker with minimal original content, and a average plot. Doesn't seem like something to kickstart or even put on kickstarter
- ChuckMcM 14y agoLook at her (Susan Wilson's) other Kickstarter [1], her husband, the ex-marine sewing super hero capes, goal $20,000 raised $400. Clearly Susan is getting better at understanding the Kickstarter user mentality. And that is what she is training her kids to understand. [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/susanwilson/the-cape-project?ref=users http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/susanwilson/the-cape-pro...
- bendmorris 14y ago>I feel like this was a con, and yet I also feel strong social pressure to not share this opinion with my friends and co-workers. Thank you. I feel the same way. I think that "feminism" like this - where a girl and her mom show how she's better than her stupid older brothers - is divisive, plays on peoples' emotions, and really makes things worse for all of us. It's not pushing equality, it's responding to "boys are better" with "no, girls are better." Yet if I were to say this openly, I'd be called a misogynist.