8 ms·
AP wins big: Why a court said clipping content is not fair use
- rayiner 14y agoIt really grinds my gears when I see stuff like this: "While this could bring more licensing revenue for journalism, it may also produce a phenomenon like what is occurring in France and Germany where publishers are treating copyright like a tax to protect outdated industries — and chilling online innovation in the process." Gee, how outdated can an industry be when you're fighting for the right to use its original content for free?[1] It's not like the AP is trying to protect the underling facts here. Meltwater could have gotten around the licensing requirement simply by paraphrasing and summarizing instead of copying snippets verbatim. But that would've required paying people and it's cheaper to just let AP do the work for free. That's almost the definition of free-riding. More generally, people throw out the word "innovation" whenever they want to use content for free. The internet allows new distribution mechanisms. There is innovation in that, sure. But distribution mechanisms are useless without content. Creating an innovative new distribution system doesn't entitle you to get content for that system for free. Ultimately, what people value is the content, the distribution system is just a means to an end. If the creators of that content want to be compensated for it, they should be. Nothing stops you from "innovating" a new distribution system using content the creators of which are happy to license for free, other than the simple fact that there is no money in that because very few people want "indie" content. [1] Does the government sometimes use law to prop up outdated industries? Sure. Often the demand for a kind of product dies out but the companies producing that product manage to talk the government into artificially propping up that demand. If the government used regulation to prop up the CRT industry after people had moved to LCD's, that would be an example. But when it comes to copyrighted works, that's not the case. The demand for creative content from the major record labels and movie/television studios has never been higher. People desperately want the products Sony BMG, Warner Brothers, etc, are selling. Forcing people to pay for the privilege is not "propping up" an obsolete industry.
- 001sky 14y agoIsn't AP just (aspiring to be) a cartel? What makes them interesting? Not sure I get it.
- rayiner 14y agoHow is AP a cartel?
- 001sky 14y agoAn "association" of (aspiring) monopolistic rent seekers is == Cartel. Ie, they are seeking to control supply side economics through limited distribution. etc. [1] Obviously, Copyrights are legally granted monopolies.
- rayiner 14y agoNeither "rent seeking" nor "cartel" nor "monopolistic" means what you seem to think it means. Rent seeking is defined as trying to profit from activity that would've happened anyway without you. Since Meltwater is excerpting articles written by AP affiliates, the AP cannot be rent seeking in this case because without them the articles in question would not exist. "Monopolistic" usually refers to entities that have a monopoly on a particular kind of good. AP affiliates have no monopoly on news. Their copyright over their original content is a "legally granted monopoly" but in the sense that any property right is a legally granted monopoly. I'm not engaging in "monopolistic" practices because the government grants me a legal monopoly over my back yard. You're essentially punning on the word "monopoly." E.g. AMD has a monopoly on "Opteron" processors but is not a "monopoly" because it doesn't control the supply of processors. "Cartel" is an organization of companies who control the supply of a type of good colluding to fix prices for that good. AP does not control the supply of news and hence cannot be a cartel.
- alexqgb 14y agoThank you. It never ceases to amaze me how much of the "criticism" aimed at copyright depends on massive distortion of otherwise well-defined words. Refusing to pay your rent to a property management company on the grounds that they're a rent-seeking cartel exercising monopolistic control over "your" apartment is not astute economic analysis. Rather, it's the mark of a (soon to be evicted) idiot. Lambasting the creator and owner of an intellectual property for running a commercial operation to recover his costs and produce a profit is the same thing. And before anyone insists that "copies are different" and "making isn't taking", it's worth remembering that the bone of contention isn't in the copies. It's in the money that's not changing hands after the copy has been made. Economically speaking, digital media may be a special case in that units have zero marginal cost. But we don't throw up our hands and say "oh well, that's the end of professionally produced media." Instead, we recognize the inability of free markets to meet all our needs, realize that laws also play a vital role in advanced societies, and create exclusive and legally protected terms and conditions under which creators can safely exploit their work. And while it's true that major publishers routinely display cartel-like behavior in their negotiations with artists, it's ridiculous to say that they maintain any kind of industry-wide monopoly with regard to the general public. Indeed, anyone working in these businesses can tell you how fiercely you need to compete to win public favor. It's no OPEC, that's for sure.
- waterlesscloud 14y ago"Google News users clicked through to 56 percent of excerpted stories" That seems really, really high. I wonder what they're using as the base there?
- DavidWoof 14y agoThey misstated the statistic. It's that 56 percent of Google News users sometimes click through to excerpted stories (i.e., 44% of users never click through to the original), not that the average user clicks through to 56% of the stories. When I read stuff like that, I always wonder if the reporter simply worded it wrong, or if he actually thought that what he was saying might be true, or if he simply didn't think about it and didn't care.
- rhizome 14y agoProbably a bit of each.
- biot 14y agoMeltwater searches for phrases its clients identify as being of interest. Presumably the Google comparison is based off of searches for phrases of interest, in which it's not surprising that search result clickthrough rates are 56%.
- Tangaroa 14y agoThis is a hugely important decision. Any blog that excerpts a bit of a news story is now guilty of copyright infringement, and it will be seen as infringement for profit (hampering a fair use defense and increasing penalties) if the blog has ads or a tip jar.
- itafroma 14y agoThat's a hyperbolic interpretation of this, to say the least. The issue was that Meltwater was copying the essential portions of AP's works (e.g., the lede) such that there wasn't any need to ever read the original articles. That's a far cry from merely "excerpting a bit of a news story." If you're a blog who reposts the core parts of news stories and gives no incentive for users to actually read the original story, then yes, you're probably infringing, but that was true before this ruling. If you're excerpting a small portion of a news story for the purposes of critique, context, or comment, this ruling doesn't void that fair use, either.
- Tangaroa 14y agoAccording to the article, the judge decided that news reporting -- what blogs do -- is not transformative but is competitive with the AP. Taking enough of an excerpt to get the gist of the story -- what reputable blogs do -- is taking "the heart" of the copyrighted work, which is now infringement according to the article. Blogs that add their own criticism and commentary, which rewrite the story in their own words, reduce the incentive to read the original story. The blog acts as a news site and a substitute for the original story, which according to the article strengthens a claim of copyright infringement. The circumstances in which criticism and commentary would justify a fair use defense just got tightened, as did the amount of an article that is considered a sufficiently small portion to be fair use.
- anigbrowl 14y agoAccording to the article, the judge decided that news reporting -- what blogs do Woah, hold up on that false premise there. reporting consists of gathering information and telling people about it by writing original content. Some blogs do this, but many just recycle incoming news and slap their own brand on top of it. And there are far more editorial blogs that basically consist of some blogger's opinion about the news than there are blogs engaged in actual newsgathering. If you're just quoting extracts of AP stories without doing any research, you're not reporting. And if you're rewriting, you're not infringing, because facts themselves are not copyrightable.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pedalpete 14y agoI think they need(ed) to look at this outside the context of this being a digital solution. If Meltweather had people go through web-pages and pick out references to a client name, and then type up the relevant quotes and send the client a letter by snail mail containing references to where the client was mentioned, would this even be a discussion?
- Someone 14y agoI think the "typing by hand" is irrelevant as it is just a means of copying without any or significant creative part from the copier (and even if it did involve creativity, it might still be copyright infringement. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macmillan_Co._v._King http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macmillan_Co._v._King) Clipping services that photocopied and snail mailed articles from newspapers have existed for ages and, certainly in the EU, they pay copyright holders. From cursory looks at EU cases, it seems to me that the primary distinction the EU makes is that of deep linking search results (permitted) vs providing a portal where users do not click through to original content (copyright infringement) Of course, there are gray areas here, but at least, IMO the intent is what 'the people' find reasonable.
- hncommenter13 14y agoOn another (mildly related) note, does anyone know much about Meltwater itself? There's something that's always seemed a bit odd to me about the company, but that's just an unsubstantiated hunch.
- hncommenter14 14y agoI had to deal with Meltwater once, and formed the view that it was a screamingly expensive news monitoring service that was easily replaced by a handful of free Google News alerts. Sadly, management took the view that a subscription would be a set-and-forget way to tick the box on "staying abreast of the market" so I just had to suck it up and renew the sub...
- moneypenny 14y agoAs a journalism postgrad, I am extremely cool with this. AP employ thousands of stringers all round the world to gather and verify news, in dangerous and hostile places. Meltwater literally (not figuratively) took that news without giving anything back. So fuck Meltwater, and the horse they rode in on, when lovely people like Tim Hetherington give their lives to report.