5 ms·
Warning to people reading the comments before the article: This article is not calling Google evil, it's examining the economic and social incentives of mainta
by pessimizer 14y ago
Warning to people reading the comments before the article:
This article is not calling Google evil, it's examining the economic and social incentives of maintaining a public utility as a for-profit company and as a society. I tend to think that putting scare quotes around words in headlines is really condescending behavior from headline writers, but threads like this remind me that I'm not an authority of headline writing.
And for the people arguing that Krugman is an ignorant big government fraud for claiming that Google Reader is a public utility - Mr. Johnson's water pump on the corner that half of the people on the block use is a public utility. It's economic analysis, not a communist grab for your guns, or a socialist power play to keep capitalists from doing whatever they want to do, whenever they want to do it.
edit: hadn't refreshed in a while before replying. This comment is mischaracterizing the level of discourse in this thread now:)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- javert 14y agoYou're completely wrong. Krugman hates capitalism and free markets, and is on a crusade to end them. Claiming that X's property is a "public utility" _is_ a power grab.
- pessimizer 14y agoNo, it's claiming that it has utility for the public. There's a hint in the name.
- javert 14y agoThat's a contradiction. I personally have utility for the public. So do private companies. You can't call these things public utilities without introducing a contradiction into the language. People who try to introduce contradictions into the language only do so because they are _motivated_ to do so, because they want to get something dishonestly. Another good example, besides the one we are discussing, is the idea that people now call whatever they want a "human right." That's a contradiction, because it's not necessarily the case that it's even _possible_ to _produce_ enough of whatever that thing is. Mangling the language is a crime against thought.