4 ms·
There is some strange mental block that makes it difficult for people to understand that technological progress does not and will not result in mass unemploymen
by wyager 14y ago
There is some strange mental block that makes it difficult for people to understand that technological progress does not and will not result in mass unemployment.
Here's a clearer example with humans instead of horses:
200 years ago, Shoemaking was one of the world's largest industries. Today, it represents a very small fraction of the world economy and almost all shoemakers have been replaced by machines.
What happened?
As shoemaking machines became commonplace, shoemakers were suddenly unable to compete. Some of them found other jobs, some of them became destitute. Most were probably able to keep shoemaking until they retired, as the shoemaking machines took a while to roll out.
However, the Shoemakers' children and other children in that generation were perfectly aware that shoemaking was no longer a viable industry. No one born after the popularization of shoemaking machines studied to become a shoemaker.
What is the result?
First, we now have less expensive, higher-quality shoes. This is not always an effect of mechanization, but it usually is. Second, we don't have mass unemployment.
Why do we not have mass unemployment? Because when you replace workers with less expensive machines, one of two things happen; either the factory owner makes more money, or shoes start to cost less. If the factory owner makes more money, they spend it on a yacht or something. If the shoes cost less, the consumers have more money to spend on food or books or whatever.
So, there are now very few people employed in the shoemaking industry, but all the shoemakers' children can now go into the expanding yacht-making or food-cooking or book-printing industries.
Recap: Mechanization does not cause long-term unemployment. At worst, it causes unemployment for a single generation of workers. Ultimately, decreasing costs in one industry contribute to the growth of other industries (either via increased profits for the wealthy or decreased costs for the non-wealthy), so there is not a significant net change in employment.
- anatari 14y agoIt's not a mental block, it's because it is plausible. Just because it hasn't happened yet, doesn't mean it won't happen. In the extreme scenario, if technology advances to the point where it does nearly everything better than humans for practical necessities, it is unknown how much that will affect employment and society as we know it. In my mind, it's not a matter of if it will happen, but how far away we are from that reality. We could be 100 years away or 1000 years away and that's where the more interesting argument lies.
- wyager 14y agoIn the extreme scenario you mention, we have effectively infinite labor. Provided we also have effectively infinite energy and resources (which is entirely feasible or only a matter of time if technology is that advanced), the value of all three of those things (labor+energy+materials) drops to zero. That means we won't have to worry about employment. It will be an outdated concept. But in the mean time, we also have nothing worry about, for the reasons I mentioned.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoProblem is, the price of the nonlabor factors will never actually drop to zero. Energy and materials are basically things you pull out of the ground, and there's always going to be rent-seeking on natural resources.
- wyager 14y agoIf we have infinite labor, we have infinite resource extraction capabilities (limited by our access to energy). The scenario I see is solar-powered space mining.
- vl 14y ago>100 years away or 1000 Most likely something like 10.
- naa42 14y agoYou know, there was that 'labor movement' and typical working hours decreased in 200 years from 16 hours a day, 7 days a week to 8 hours a day, 5 days a week + vacations. It is a good reason for the lack of mass unemployment, isn't it?
- wyager 14y agoThat's actually part one of the side effects of mechanization that I mentioned; not only does employment stay roughly the same, but we get better goods for less work. "The labor movement" had little to do with it; the amount of labor required for sustenance simply dropped to a remarkably small number of hours per day, thanks to technological advancement. The fact that we now have roughly 40 hour workweeks is simply how our culture responded to an exponential increase in productivity. So I'm not really sure what you're getting at. Are you complaining that we get to work so little and have so much?
- stinkytaco 14y agoPerhaps not mass unemployment, but certainly a shift to less valued employment (i.e. service jobs). There's a reason we're seeing a larger income gap now, and it's due to a shift to capital creating value in the economy rather than labor. Lower income folks are getting even poorer by shifting into low skill jobs and people who control capital are getting wealthier.