3 ms·
> That said, the licensing with GCC sounds very complex and burdensome too. It's not really, it's just your standard GPL. The exception simply means that they
by davidw 18y ago
> That said, the licensing with GCC sounds very complex and burdensome too.
It's not really, it's just your standard GPL. The exception simply means that they don't try and make the GPL cover everything the compiler outputs and links into executables.
- wmf 18y agoToo bad the FSF is in the process of obfuscating the GCC exception with some language about Eligible Compilation Processes in an attempt to regulate GCC plugins. http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gcc-exception-3.1-faq.html http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gcc-exception-3.1-faq.html
- davidw 18y agoNo, it's still simple: don't mix GCC with proprietary code. Code that gets output by GCC and inserted into other executables is still fine.
- blasdel 18y agoNo, they're trying to say that using GCC's intermediary representations in your own code (both as output from GCC, and as input from GCC) counts as LINKING.
- wmf 18y agoIf the FSF wants to change or clarify restrictions on GCC, they should modify the GCC license. Putting restrictions on GCC in the license of the GCC runtime library seems unnecessarily confusing.
- mustpax 18y agoI love FOSS. But realistically speaking, the more complex a license is the more expensive it is to get sound legal advice on it. I understand what the stipulations are supposed to mean: don't link with GPL unless you're going to release the source. But the legal language has a life of its own and it gets the final word. With all the stipulations around linking and compilation, there's got to be a lot of corner cases to consider and defend against, not an easy feat. Granted FSF are not the most litigious guys around, but that doesn't make the license any less legally burdensome.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davidw 18y agoOk, but 99.9% of people just use GCC to compile stuff. They don't care about linking to it, fiddling with intermediate representations, or anything like that. And the licensing is not "complex and burdensome" for people who just want to compile stuff. Indeed, it's far less "complex and burdensome" than, say, Microsoft's compiler, which is also used by a large number of people.