9 ms·
Google killed me
- sp332 14y agoHere's the edit history for the page, where you can see all the edits user Amywilentz made over the last few years. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&action=history https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&a...
- GFischer 14y agoThose are the edits for Amy Wilentz's page actually. Her contributions are here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Amywilentz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Amywilen...
- jere 14y agoIt's not too surprising that google dropped the ball. This entry that she describes doesn't even have her birth year shown, but instead lists a dozen other years. That's rather odd for a short bio. Maybe Joel was trying to be polite... never ask a lady her age? https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&oldid=497604867 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&o... >An error in a Google search “factbox” can only be corrected when Google re-indexes (whatever that means) the information that will update the search. Depending on the size of your website, re-indexing takes either a couple of days, or several months. Like good guys, small websites finish last. Note: my website is small. I think she misunderstands here. If the data is scraped from wikipedia, it really has nothing to do with her site, right?
- namank 14y agoWikipedia has to have sources.
- EwanToo 14y agoCuriously, a couple of weeks since that post was made, Google have obviously updated their results, I no longer get a "Died:" record when I search for "amy wilentz". Perhaps another case of Google ignoring you until you get a bit of publicity, or just them finally catching up.
- danso 14y agoIt reminds me of an anecdote from Steven Levy's "In the Plex" on a sneaker wearing gnome that was inexplicably making a mockery of Froogle results: > But one problem was so glaring that the team wasn’t comfortable releasing Froogle: when the query “running shoes” was typed in, the top result was a garden gnome sculpture that happened to be wearing sneakers. Every day engineers would try to tweak the algorithm so that it would be able to distinguish between lawn art and footwear, but the gnome kept its top position. > One day, seemingly miraculously, the gnome disappeared from the results. At a meeting, no one on the team claimed credit. Then an engineer arrived late, holding an elf with running shoes. He had bought the one-of-a kind product from the vendor, and since it was no longer for sale, it was no longer in the index. “The algorithm was now returning the right results,” says a Google engineer. “We didn’t cheat, we didn’t change anything, and we launched.” http://books.google.com/books?id=V1u1f8sv3k8C&pg=PA60&lpg=PA60&dq=in+the+plex+google+gnome&source=bl&ots=BRsOdubpoG&sig=53bz17o70vY82gtQsev1FkUbgbU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=XnBMUbnFItGsqAGf6ICQCA&ved=0CEMQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=in%20the%20plex%20google%20gnome&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=V1u1f8sv3k8C&pg=PA60...
- RyanZAG 14y agoNatural language parsing is not 100% accurate and can make mistakes - breaking news! All kinds of automated data collection such as this will have errors that need to be fixed manually by a human. This will be taken care of if/when we eventually have real artificial intelligence. The data parsing scripts Google and others use are fairly advanced, but they still break down to a couple rules and finding words in close proximity. There is no real intelligence involved here. EDIT: The important takeaway here is to make sure we continue to educate people (especially government) as to the issues and unreliability of these systems. Death date showing up on Google isn't a train smash, but if some government agency decides that Google is smarter than them? Then we are in trouble.
- danso 14y agoIt is interesting that google almost seems to take Wikipedia bio boxes as gospel, which is a questionable decision given that Google "rich snippets" in the search results now have such high placement. I wonder how much Wikipedia specific logic is used in the googlebot...I'm guessing that longevity of article and number of edits is a factor in taking an entry seriously.
- k3n 14y ago> It is interesting that google almost seems to take Wikipedia bio boxes as gospel FTA, I don't believe the data was taken from a bio box: > So it’s not too surprising that my original Wikipedia entry, as conceived by Joel, was — let’s be honest — more about my father (a famous New Jersey judge) than about me. Joel began the entry with my connection to my father, and immediately mentioned my father’s birthdate and the date of his death. That's the scary part, as she alludes to in the next paragraph: > If your name on Wikipedia is followed by a birth and death date, apparently those belong to you from that day forward, no matter whose dates they may be.
- Kylekramer 14y agoDon't know what is so scary about that. I am willing to bet less than 0.01% of "name[s] on Wikipedia..followed by a birth and death date" aren't the actual birth and death date. Seems like just an oddmatch caused by an overzealous relative that happened due to the incredibly large amount of data Google processes.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bazzargh 14y agoI'd add this to Wikipedia's List of premature obituaries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_premature_obituaries#W https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_premature_obituaries#W ... except that you can't cite the subject's own blog as a reliable source-particularly when they apparently wrote it post-mortem.
- Matt_Cutts 14y agoAmy Wilentz also published her essay on the Huffington Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/amy-wilentz/how-google-killed-me_b_2856969.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/amy-wilentz/how-google-killed-... Not sure whether that helps or not though.
- rdl 14y agoAfD? Is she really notable? (daughter of a state judge seems to be her primary accomplishment; also is an English professor).
- nathanb 14y agoAuthor?
- jrockway 14y agoI don't think "author" counts. I've written a book but I didn't get a Wikipedia page.
- Samuel_Michon 14y ago“Professor of English at the University of California, Irvine, where she teaches in the Literary Journalism program. Her works appeared in The New York Times, The Los Angeles Times, Time magazine, The New Republic, Mother Jones, Harper’s, Vogue, Condé Nast Traveler, Travel & Leisure, The San Francisco Chronicle, More, The Village Voice, The London Review of Books, Huffington Post. She was Jerusalem correspondent of The New Yorker, and is currently a contributing editor at The Nation.”
- bbrizzi 14y agoWhat a bad article... The author talks about something (google indexing) she admits she doesn't understand. She doesn't understand that by editing her Wikipedia article, the google crawler would update her infobox data pretty quickly. Her birth data was added to the wikipedia entry today and the google infobox is fixed. It took less than 2 hours. Not something worth whining about.
- Strang 14y agoI don't think she is really whining; she's just using dry humor. And she is raising an important point, and one that keeps recurring with Google: what do you do when their automated processes are not enough? She should not have to edit Wikipedia to resolve this situation. That is not a reasonable expectation of anyone. In fact, she chose the only solution that usually gets through to Google: blog/tweet about something and get enough exposure.
- 542458 14y agoI don't understand how the engine in my car works. I might complain to my mechanic that it won't start. To him, diagnosing a bad spark plug and swapping in a new one is a simple matter of five minutes, but to me it might as well be heart surgery. That doesn't mean I was wrong to complain. She knew something was wrong, but admittedly didn't understand all the details. She complained to bring it to the internet's attention, after which it was swiftly fixed. This doesn't mean she's done anything foolish or wrong - she was simply pointing out a problem.
- nathanb 14y agoYes, the fact that a reasonably well-respected writer and English professor doesn't understand the inner workings of Google's infobox means that her blog post is terrible. This arrogant and dismissive response highlights the problem even better than her mild and humorous complaint (which, for the record, I didn't see as whining). Perhaps she did understand that editing her Wikipedia page would correct the problem but also understood that Wikipedia's policies frown on editing one's own page, even to correct factual errors such as birth and death dates. Or perhaps she was entirely ignorant that she could even edit Wikipedia. Or perhaps she knew but didn't care and only wanted to write a humorous and potentially thought-provoking blog post. Why are you so quick to defend an algorithm which produced a wrong answer and detract a reasonable and intelligent human being?
- lotsofcows 14y agoOld, and I don't particularly agree with it, but: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/12/14/googlepedia_announced/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/12/14/googlepedia_announce...
- cm2012 14y agoThis post was really well written. Just a pleasure on the eyes.
- craigching 14y agoI loved it too, up until this part: "I’m reading Kafka’s Castle right now — which itself may kill me" Kafka is one of my favorite authors and The Castle is one of my favorite novels :( But a well-written essay nonetheless ;)
- wyclin 14y agoI was just watching this earlier. Had me in tears. http://www.theonion.com/video/pragues-franz-kafka-international-named-worlds-mos,14321/ http://www.theonion.com/video/pragues-franz-kafka-internatio...
- craigching 14y agoomg! That was hilarious! Thanks for sharing that! :)
- Tichy 14y agoIs she not aware that anyone can edit Wikipedia?
- lutze 14y agoThe problem here is that Google apparently isn't aware, not her.
- saraid216 14y agoIt's a social convention that you don't edit your own Wikipedia page, too.
- IvyMike 14y agoCheck the history: She edited her own page many times.
- itafroma 14y agoI believe she's referring to the fact that if you are the owner of the domain with the erroneous information, you can make a request to Google to re-crawl the information using Google's Webmaster Tools. Regular users can't make that request, so under normal circumstances, she would've had to wait until Google gets around to it on their own schedule.
- bjhoops1 14y ago> It all comes down to Google’s algorithm (a word I use carelessly, and frequently, but whose meaning is obscure to me, though I feel it is something mathematical) Loved this. Amusing reminder of the fact that most people do not speak our language. :)
- zem 14y agothe one that startled me was "can only be corrected when Google re-indexes (whatever that means) the information that will update the search". it would never have struck me that "reindex" was an overly jargonny term, but in retrospect i guess it is.
- billforsternz 14y agoI was struck by the same thing. The surprising thing to me was that a journalist/writer didn't figure out the nature of the process given that presumably they would understand the idea of recreating the index of a physical book.
- pmelendez 14y agoWell identity is still a problem. Hilary Mason had a similar problem on Bing a couples of months ago. http://www.hilarymason.com/blog/im-a-dead-celebrity/ http://www.hilarymason.com/blog/im-a-dead-celebrity/
- icebraining 14y agoGreat article, really well written! This is what happens when the world is ruled by a robot I take it OP hasn't had the delightful pleasure of dealing with old-fashioned human bureaucracy. My uncle tells some great stories about his time in East Berlin, before the Wall fell. A great example is the post office that did some renovations, and so delivered the old copper and other materials for reutilization. From then on, the System cleverly decided the yearly productivity goals should include delivering the same amount of copper, each year. The post office master had to figure out how to deliver the copper for a couple of years, in order to avoid failure in meeting the obviously correct goals, until he finally managed to change them. So, yeah, at least Google's algorithms have the excuse of not being sentient.
- _delirium 14y agoI can't seem to find a good canonical reference at the moment, but there's some interesting writing in organizational theory about the extent to which some of those kinds of bureaucracies are themselves basically mechanical systems, controlled by code that just happens to be manually executed by human operators. In general, code executed by computers tends to be executed more "rigidly", but in some systems humans can also be quite automaton-like in just executing instructions. In those cases it's not clear the human operators, rather than the algorithms they're executing, are in control of the decisions (it may not even be true that any one human knows what algorithm is being executed). Of course, you could argue someone can always change the bureaucratic protocol, but that's even true with computer code: someone at Google can always edit the code, at some times more easily than others.
- akozak 14y agoDo you have a reading list you could share?
- cecilpl 14y agoI had this exact thought while walking to work this morning. It came to me that the vast majority of modern society is completely independent of the actual people executing it. There are very few jobs that could not be done just as well by another person with the same training. Most jobs are like coded modules. They have well-defined inputs and outputs - even creative jobs can be defined in terms of "create something people will pay for". The system is what runs the world, not the individual people who carry it out.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoWith all the real world relation databases, they still parse wikipedia, badly. That's our real world object relation databases status, unfortunately.
- mirkules 14y agoIt's interesting to think about the consequences of dissemination of wrong information about yourself online (as a "non-important" person) by a largely well-respected outlet such as Google. As a far-fetched example, it's not uncommon for identity thieves to use a dead person's identity - and if the author applied for a job and the employer Googled her name... you can see where this is heading. I suspect there might be some liability issues about incorrect information online, perhaps as a result of other cases with more dire consequences than simply not getting a job.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lesinski 14y agoI wonder if this would suit the criterion for defamation. That would be a really interesting case to see.
- leephillips 14y agoTo get damages she would need to demonstrate harm. But if she could, this becomes interesting, as Google can not hide behind the usual search-engine defense: they are not merely linking to sites here, but making up their own facts. (IANAL.)
- danso 14y agoI think Google would be fine in this case, if we're assuming American law. Wilentz arguably qualifies as a "public figure" and so Google would have to be proven to show gross negligence and/or malicious intent in getting the dates wrong. Assuming the googlebot did as it normally does, Google has an even stronger case that they aren't intentionally being bad actors, as the googlebot gets so many other things correct with its algorithm.
- cromwellian 14y agoJust wait till she finds her insurance company or local government has wrong information and see how long it'll take to get a fix. Years ago, the bank which had my car loan got sold to another bank which got sold to another bank. When I finished paying off the loan, they sent documents I needed to the wrong address. I had moved to a different state and the bank had as well, and it took weeks to correct this. I actually had to contact the DMV at my former state and get them to send a letter to the new bank, which then released records, which then allowed me to update my DMV in in CA. I won't even get into the mistakes that Sallie Mae made on my student loan records, or how many times my health insurance provider screwed up. Machines screw up, but humans screw up too, and sometimes getting the problem fixed in a bureaucracy takes even more effort. I don't think bureaucracies "refresh" their policies/procedures (algorithms) or data as fast as software companies do.
- megablast 14y agoIt is only a matter of time before they start to use Google for this information, they already use it for mapping, and have made some mistakes. The fictitious island is one example.
- Matt_Cutts 14y agoI believe this has been fixed for a while now. It was fixed by the time I reported this over a week ago, for example. If you see an error in a Knowledge Panel (the box on the right-hand side), look for the "Feedback / More info" link at the bottom of the box and then you can click next to a fact to report a problem. People do review those reports, and that's the fastest way to report an issue.
- alexjeffrey 14y agoit's mentioned in the post that the author reported the facts a number of times.
- The1Mirage 14y agoIt has been corrected since then - the post is from February 28th, not sure why it's just now hitting HN. This isn't a real-time complaint.
- bubersson 14y agoYou can always check the data in Freebase: http://www.freebase.com/m/09v5l5c?links&lang=en&historical=true http://www.freebase.com/m/09v5l5c?links&lang=en&hist...
- danso 14y agoApologies. I posted this because it came up recently in a media blog [insert joke about media being slow]. So it was a manual fix that corrected the issue? I guess that makes since given that her Wikipedia entry didn't have the standardized birthdate listing (at least in the first line) until today (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&oldid=533720454 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&ol...). Would that fix alone been enough to fix her snippet?
- pgrote 14y agoI wonder how many of these items are manual fixes? It would be interesting to see the number of them adjusting the index.
- etherealG 14y agoplease increase the font size on your site. a lovely read for it's content, but painful process of consuming it.
- sebcat 14y agoFunny, slightly off topic, but still relevant fact: When I google my name, the first page is about a sex offender living in Texas.
- emur 14y ago:) hahaha every one makes mistakes .. even google
- Stratoscope 14y agoI've been curious to learn how these knowledge boxes work, ever since I saw my dog Lucy show up as the star photo in a search for Rat Terrier: https://www.google.com/search?q=rat+terrier https://www.google.com/search?q=rat+terrier In fact, on a mobile device she's the only photo. Yes! Are these generated algorithmically? Some amount of manual curation? Or what? Of course it is humbling to discover that my dog is much more famous than I am...
- Matt_Cutts 14y agoLooks like Lucy is the primary exemplar picture for a rat terrier on Wikipedia? http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lucy,_a_Rat_Terrier.jpg http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lucy,_a_Rat_Terrier.j... P.S. She's a cute dog!
- Stratoscope 14y agoThanks, Matt, I certainly agree that Lucy deserves every bit of her fame. :-) Yes, it must be the Wikipedia article. (Of course I'm the one who put her there.) It was interesting to note that the aspect ratio of her photo fits the tall photo space in the knowledge box better that most dog photos which tend to be more horizontal.
- monsur 14y agoIt is refreshing to read the perspective of how a non-techie views Google and tech. It's a viewpoint that's important to remember.
- smallegan 14y agoI wonder if natural language parsing will pick up this article and soon her profile will read that she was killed by Google. RIP Amy Wilentz, you will be missed.
- jackalgreen 14y agoBing thinks she is dead too http://www.bing.com/search?setmkt=en-US&q=amy+wilentz http://www.bing.com/search?setmkt=en-US&q=amy+wilentz
- tomkarlo 14y agoHandling death in databases of living people is a big problem. You know it's going to happen to everyone you're tracking, sooner or later. But they never seem to update their info when it does.
- barakm 14y agoI'll point out that her Freebase entry (sourced by Wikipedia) contained exactly the incorrect data until it was fixed. See http://www.freebase.com/m/09v5l5c?links&lang=en&historical=true http://www.freebase.com/m/09v5l5c?links&lang=en&hist... Freebase, owned by Google, is part of its structured data efforts but few people remember this :) Contributing structured data is awesome! (former Metaweb/Freebase employee, current Googler)
- aeturnum 14y ago>It all comes down to Google’s algorithm (a word I use carelessly, and frequently, but whose meaning is obscure to me, though I feel it is something mathematical)... It seems to me that people are comfortable not computer technology and indignant when they are forced to be aware of the details. I doubt, for instance, you would ever see this sentence: "It all comes down to the car's engine (a word I use carelessly, and frequently, but whose meaning is obscure to me, though I feel it is probably part of the car)..." It would be silly, on its face, to display ignorance of such a common part of the vehicle(s) that you use to get around. However, it's seen as normal to be totally disinterested in the inner workings of computers (despite their ubiquity). I'm sure this was true for cars and other pieces of technology at some point, but I don't know how long ago that was. I also don't know what caused it to change. I feel like, if people were a little more aware of what happens "under the hood" of computing products, they would be more interested in the areas of concern for the tech community (what does company X do with my information? How well is my data protected? What limitations are built into this device?).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- optymizer 14y agoNo, I didn't read blogs from dead people before, but I have read articles with a larger font size.
- matrix2002 14y agoShe is complaining about how her "true" life doesn't reflect the facts that Google says about her. This was a problem before the internet, before computers, before TV even. We have all been subjected to our public persona in high school or in our home town. It is not accurate. Sometimes, it is the complete opposite of the truth. So, I don't know why this author thinks it should be different with Google. Google gets a lot of things right, it gets a lot of things wrong as well. I don't worry about what a search engine says about me. I know what I am. I am not what Google says and I am not what my high school yearbook says either.