2 ms·
I just said it's a qualitative difference. I deliberately did not opine on the legality or the ethics, I simply reject the idea that we can say that there's no
by jerf 14y ago
I just said it's a qualitative difference. I deliberately did not opine on the legality or the ethics, I simply reject the idea that we can say that there's no difference between a by-hand downloading of a couple of URLs and a massive by-script downloading of thousands+. As is so often the case, there's no bright shining line, but there is a line here, and trying to be reductionistic and claim there's no difference is, in my opinion, not a valid argument.
It may very well be the case that it should also not be illegal, or that we want the common sense solution where it's still "illegal" but not a criminal felony but rather a civil matter (illegal is not a binary flag, after all).