5 ms·
> If you want to build truly viable open source software, you need people to contribute to your project[...] I think it would somehow be very hard to get peopl
by derefr 14y ago
> If you want to build truly viable open source software, you need people to contribute to your project[...]
I think it would somehow be very hard to get people excited about contributing to the effort to build a new, amazing piece of forum software... in Java.
Clojure, maybe ;)
- moondowner 14y agoJava is at the 3rd place on GitHub on Top Languages (sharing it with Python), which proves that there's collaboration going on in Java projects https://github.com/languages https://github.com/languages
- tszming 14y agoA lot of Java projects on Github are Android related. On server-side, you have a lot of alternatives you can choose from, but on Android, most of the time, you don't have the choice.
- moondowner 14y agoThere are also non-Android related Java projects there, for example from the guys from Netflix, SpringSource, LinkedIn, Twitter, etc... but I think that you're right, a lot of Java projects are Android related.
- tszming 14y agoAn interesting phenomenon is a lot of Java projects on Github if they are not Android related, very likely they are from big guys like Twitter, Netflix, LinkedIn, Yammer etc. Definitely they all have the reasons (e.g. performance, static typing) to use Java or JVM technologies, but if you count the number of projects from indie developers, Ruby, JavaScript & Python are much popular - and they are the target audience of Discourse. Java is still the No.1 language but it is unhealthy (IMO) if most indie developers prefer to ignore it, despite the benefits it bring.
- danieldk 14y agoI think it would somehow be very hard to get people excited about contributing to the effort to build a new, amazing piece of forum software... in Java. Don't underestimate what effect Java 8 will have. Sure, closures are old by now, but JDK 8 combines them with streams, similar to those that have become popular in Scala and Haskell. You can write stuff like this, https://github.com/mikaelhg/lambda-demo/blob/master/src/main/java/lambda/LambdaDemo.java https://github.com/mikaelhg/lambda-demo/blob/master/src/main... without creating intermediate lists or whatever. Replace a call to a collection's stream method by parallelStream and subsequent operations such as map are parallelized. Java 8 is perhaps not `Haskell cool', but you'll be able to get it past management and still enjoy some of the functional programming fun. (Now, give me value structs and reified generics Oracle!)
- prawks 14y ago> you'll be able to get it past management and still enjoy some of the functional programming fun. I think a lot of technologies where the ability to convince management to use it is a feature are ones that don't get individual open-source contributors the most excited, unfortunately. Maybe I'm naive to Java's open-source community, but from the outside I don't envision it to be as active as Ruby's (at least outside of Android), even with Ruby no longer being "the cool thing".
- danieldk 14y agoMaybe I'm naive to Java's open-source community, but from the outside I don't envision it to be as active as Ruby's (at least outside of Android), even with Ruby no longer being "the cool thing". Actually, that was my view too. In my previous job, I had used C, C++, Prolog, and some Haskell for four years. My outside view was that the Java opensource ecosystem is boring. My current employer uses Java almost exclusively, and I have to admit being surprised how much high-quality open source libraries are available, packaged up for Maven. I still think that Java is so-so, but the open source ecosystem is quite strong, and there are really excellent IDEs (such as IntelliJ IDEA).
- prawks 14y ago
- bradleyjg 14y agoSo, your answer is that java isn't cool enough? Did you see the part of the essay where he wrote that he wasn't looking for the cool kids flavor of the month?